Compare with…

Arguments

Intended labeling

√PAY_BILL + Bill / Obligation (ACC) + optional MeasureP as INSTRUMENT (with / in)

Voice introduces Payer. The Bill / Obligation is the Case object — a document or obligation-kind (invoice, bill, fine as document). Optional MeasureP ⟨Amount, Denomination⟩ reenters as instrument (with twenty dollars) or denomination (in dollars), not as ACC Theme and not as a DOC applied object. Platform (at the window / over the wire) is Loc extra. Source (from the escrow) is adjunct FROM — not deduct’s Domain object.

Examples

One object: the document / obligation. Money stays a with/in-PP when expressed. There is no productive DOC of bill + money. The invoice passivizes; a silent twenty does not.

  1. ✓ Pat paid the invoice. canonical · document ACC
  2. ✓ Pat paid the bill.
  3. ✓ Pat paid the invoice with twenty dollars. MeasureP as instrument
  4. ✓ Pat paid the invoice in dollars. denomination wrapping
  5. ✓ Pat paid the fine / the tuition bill. obligation-kind ACC
  6. ✓ Didn’t Pat pay the invoice with twenty dollars / in dollars?
  7. ✓ Wasn’t the invoice paid? passive promotes document
  8. * Wasn’t twenty dollars paid the invoice. no DOC · money ≠ applied object
  9. * Pat paid the invoice Chris twenty dollars. four-place accident
  10. * Pat paid twenty dollars the invoice. money ≠ DOC Theme of bill

Passive · document vs silent twenty

✓ The invoice was paid. document promotes

✓ The bill was paid with twenty dollars.

* Twenty dollars was paid the invoice. no DOC promote of money

* Twenty was paid dollars the invoice. Amount ≠ separate promote

✓ Chris was paid twenty dollars. payGIVE DOC contrast · Recipient promotes

Border nouns · rent / tuition / fine

✓ Pat paid the rent / the tuition / a fine. obligation-kind ACC · or MeasureP with sortal N

✓ How much rent didn’t they pay? QP pied-pipes

✓ What didn’t they pay? can be rent

The series leaves the border as packaging of one MeasureP with a sortal N, or a documented coercion to payBILL — not a fifth slot.

payGIVE contrast (sister root — not this page)

✓ Pat paid Chris twenty dollars.

✓ Pat paid twenty dollars to Chris for the lawnmower.

✓ Wasn’t Chris paid twenty dollars?

✓ Wasn’t twenty dollars paid to Chris?

* Wasn’t twenty dollars paid the invoice?

Cheap associate is the money QP. Passive promotes Recipient (DOC) or MeasureP. That is not payBILL’s document ACC. See payGIVE.

Notes

Working paper · September 2026 · English micro-entry · Payment

Obligation / document pay. The accusative is the bill or invoice, not the Amount. MeasureP comes back as instrument (with) or denomination (in). No productive DOC. Invoice-clearance is e2. Not payGIVE, not sell Price, not chargeFEE Source.

EN micro-entry live Index 2 Payment split JA twin seikyūsho ZH twin 付账 DE twin bezahlen FR twin payer ES twin pagar IT twin pagare PT twin pagar RU twin оплатить NL twin betalen PL twin zapłacić HU twin kifizet BG twin платя NO twin betale TR twin ödemek KO twin 내다 EL twin πληρώνω FI twin maksaa HI twin चुकाना AR twin دفع HE twin שילם

Sense × language tick: payBILL · English. Twins: Japanese (seikyūsho-o harau) · Mandarin (付账) · German (bezahlen) · French (payer) · Spanish (pagar) · Italian (pagare) · Portuguese (pagar) · Russian (оплатить) · Dutch (betalen) · Polish (zapłacić) · Hungarian (kifizet) · Bulgarian (платя) · Norwegian (betale) · Turkish (ödemek) · Korean (내다) · Greek (πληρώνω) · Finnish (maksaa) · Hindi (चुकाना) · Arabic (دفع) · Hebrew (שילם). Sister sense (do not merge): payGIVE · Japanese (harau). Index 2 pointer: pay. Geometry neighbors: chargeFEE · remit · wire · transfer · sell · deduct · bet. Multi-sense lemma — CAPS sense as HTML subscript.

Working paper. English-only micro-entry deepened from Lexical_Entry_Pay_Argument_Structure (§6 payBILL), with NegQ baselines from Negative_Questions_Pay §7 and the Group A contrast set §5.5 / §9. It does not restamp those DOCX files. Constructed examples diagnose Case, document-ACC vs money-ACC, and instrument MeasureP; they are not spontaneous-speech citations.
Constructed examples. Frames below are the lexical entry’s diagnostics (document ACC, passive of invoice, with/in MeasureP, no DOC of bill + money). Invoice-clearance / DISCHARGE is e2 of payBILL. Payment-true of a silent twenty and goods-HAVE are not defaults of this root.
Sense split. Index 2 lists pay under Payment. The entry splits payGIVE from payBILL (and keeps paySELL off this page). Do not collapse invoice-ACC into a fourth Theme of give-geometry pay. Shared morphology is packaging, not one NegQ profile.
Scout / deferred. Romance pagar una factura / payer la facture, Germanic betale regningen, and Navajo obligation-word packaging notes in Groups A–D remain labeled speculation/scout. No fake elicitation for non-English this tick.

Hierarchy

Not a fourth argument of payGIVE. Surface count can name Pat, the invoice, and twenty dollars — but the lexicon does not list bill and money as co-arguments of one DOC. Writing those as sisters predicts *Wasn’t twenty dollars paid the invoice? and a silent-twenty Theme. Neither holds.

〚√PAY_BILL〛 = λB λe . DISCHARGE(e) ∧ Obligation(e)=B. MeasureP optional as INSTRUMENT(e, ⟨n,U⟩), not as ACC. Result e2: the obligation is discharged. Payment-true of a HAVE-Recipient Amount is e2 of payGIVE, not this root.

Working hierarchy: Payer > Obligation (> optional MeasureP-as-instrument, Platform, Source). Obligation outranks instrument MeasureP for Case and passives. There is no Appl_HAVE Recipient shell and no productive DOC.

MeasureP / WH diagnostics

On payBILL, verbal WH’s cheap object is the document. MeasureP is not ACC Theme; when present it is instrument / denomination. WH that treats money as the Case object of this root is a speaker swap into payGIVE.

  1. ✓ What didn’t Pat pay? the bill / the invoice
  2. ✓ Which invoice did Pat pay?
  3. ✓ How much rent didn’t they pay? border · QP with sortal N
  4. ✓ What did Pat pay the invoice with? instrument
  5. ✓ In what / of what did Pat pay the invoice?
  6. * What did Pat pay twenty the invoice? no money+bill DOC
  7. * What did Pat pay the invoice twenty? LBC-shaped accident
  8. ✓ How many dollars did Pat pay Chris? payGIVE contrast · money ACC

Superiority ranks Payer > Obligation > (optional Instrument MeasureP / Platform). Amount and Denomination never compete as two verbal WH-items of payBILL. of/in/with recode the unit or the whole QP as a PP, not as a second ACC.

Geometry · payBILL ≠ payGIVE ≠ sell ≠ chargeFEE

In Pat paid the invoice with twenty dollars, the invoice is discharged. Twenty dollars is how, not who HAS the money as Theme. That is obligation-clearance — not give-geometry pay.

  • ≠ payGIVE. Shared morphology. Split: GIVE writes MeasureP as ACC Theme and Recipient as Appl_HAVE; BILL writes the document as ACC and MeasureP as instrument. DOC: GIVE yes; BILL no. e2: HAVE of Amount vs DISCHARGE of Obligation. Crossing the roots smuggles a four-place reading (*Wasn’t twenty dollars paid the invoice?).
  • ≠ sell. Sell: Recipient HAS goods; Price stays inside for. BILL: document is ACC; money is instrument. No SWAP inversion; no Price MeasureP of for.
  • ≠ chargeFEE. Shared commercial cloth and MeasureP Hom. Split: chargeFEE promotes Payer as ACC Source (FROM); BILL promotes the invoice as ACC Obligation. No levy; no Domain of loss as object.
  • ≠ cost. The lawnmower cost Chris twenty dollars — *Was Chris costed twenty dollars? Cost drops Voice. BILL keeps Payer Voice and promotes the document.
  • ≠ deduct / creditFIN. Deduct’s MeasureP is ACC decrement; Domain stays from-PP. BILL’s MeasureP is instrument when present; the ACC is the obligation, not a ledger decrement.
  • ≠ remit / wire as channel. Remit/wire sit on payGIVE’s cloth with Source/channel extra. Paying an invoice by wire still has the document as ACC of BILL when that is the selected object.
  • Four fors stay off this ACC. GIVE’s for = Consideration. sell’s for = Price. deduct’s for = Reason. grant/earmark’s for = Purpose. BILL’s object is not a for-PP; Purpose layers (paid the invoice to settle the account) stay outer Type B.
  • Invoice-clearance is e2. A follow-up No — the twenty never left is compatible as an implicature about how one pays a document; it denies e2 only of payGIVE. No — the invoice is still open denies e2 of BILL.

Shells, ApplP, and Case

Base tree (English · payBILL)

VoiceP  [ Pat
  VP  [ √PAY_BILL   [ DP  the invoice ] ]
  (PP_with  [ with  [ MeasureP  [ Amount twenty ] [ N dollars ] ] ])
  (PP_in    [ in    [ N dollars ] ]) ]

No Appl_HAVE. No Appl_SWAP. No Appl_TASK. English assigns ACC to the Bill / Obligation only. MeasureP, when present, is a PP (with, in). Platform and Source are Loc / FROM extras. Four surface participants never need a DOC of bill + money.

Neo-Davidsonian sketch (entry §8)

∃e [ DISCHARGE(e)
  ∧ PAYER(e, pat)
  ∧ Obligation(e)=invoice
  ∧ INSTRUMENT(e, ⟨20, dollars⟩) ]

After e, the obligation is cleared. HAS(Recipient, ⟨n,U⟩) is not listed — that is payGIVE. Delivery of goods and settlement of a side bet are not defaults.

Voice filter · Payer

✓ Who paid the invoice?

✓ Pat / the escrow / payroll / the city paid the invoice. institutional payers pass

* Did the weather pay the invoice? not a Payer

Same weaker filter as payGIVE: systems can pay; they cannot blame. Weather fails proto-Agent.

LFG / HPSG / CCG: two PREDs for the two pay roots. On BILL, MeasureP is not OBJ; OBJ is the document. OBJ2 only on the DOC frame of GIVE.

Underivables (English)

  1. * Wasn’t twenty dollars paid the invoice? no DOC of money + bill
  2. * Pat paid the invoice Chris twenty dollars. four-place accident
  3. * Pat paid twenty dollars the invoice. money ≠ DOC Theme of BILL
  4. * Twenty was paid dollars the invoice. Amount ≠ separate promote
  5. * What did Pat pay twenty the invoice? no money+bill WH sisters
  6. * Did the weather pay the invoice? Voice filter
  7. * Pat paid Chris the invoice twenty dollars. invoice ≠ Theme₄ of GIVE

NegQ pointer · association sites

Negative questions on payBILL read the obligation geometry; they do not invent a fourth theta name of payGIVE. Neg sits high and associates downward. Cheap inner associate = the document. MeasureP stays instrument when present. No forced collapse of payment-true onto invoice-true.

English NegQ / WH–Neg core (from Negative_Questions_Pay §7)

✓ Didn’t Pat pay the invoice?

✓ Wasn’t the invoice paid?

✓ Didn’t Pat pay the invoice with twenty dollars / in dollars?

* Wasn’t twenty dollars paid the invoice?

✓ What didn’t Pat pay? the bill / the invoice

✓ How much rent didn’t they pay? border QP

Missing defaults on BILL: no forced payment-true of a silent twenty as e2; no goods-HAVE. Present default: invoice-clearance. A follow-up No — the twenty never left reports an implicature about means; No — the invoice is still open denies e2. Crossing into Didn’t Pat pay Chris twenty dollars? is a speaker swap to GIVE, not an inner reading of BILL.

Group A packaging · Japanese / Mandarin live; Navajo deferred

Group A keeps the BILL vs GIVE Case split under Neg. Japanese twin is live at payBILL · Japanese (seikyūsho-o harau): document ACC; *Double-o of bill + money; instrument de. Mandarin twin is live at payBILL · Mandarin (付账): document ACC / 把; *two-把 of bill + money; instrument 用. Navajo: predicted obligation word plus money stem or a single discharge stem — not two Patients; remains open/scout. Label speculation; do not fake elicitation.

Open items

  • Border nouns (rent / tuition / fine). One MeasureP with sortal N, or documented coercion to payBILL. Speculative packaging, not a fifth slot.
  • Japanese seikyūsho-o / yachin-o — live twin at pay-bill-ja.html. Further classifier-ride / border elicitation remains open.
  • Mandarin 账单 / 把 / 用 — live twin at pay-bill-zh.html. Further classifier-ride / border elicitation remains open.
  • Romance factura / facture / bolletta as ACC under pagar / payer / pagare, with MeasureP as con / avec / con. Companion of Group B packaging. spec
  • Germanic betale regningen / die Rechnung bezahlen vs DOC-like GIVE frames. Same split under Neg. spec
  • Outer CAUSE (make Pat pay the invoice). Site on the making vs on DISCHARGE; Consideration / instrument never becomes Causee Case under √PAY_BILL’s English cloth.
  • pay attention / pay a visit / pay tribute — further roots; stay out of the commercial map except as distractors.

Corpus filenames

Primary extract for this micro-entry; companions supply NegQ baselines and Group A packaging. DOCX originals under the Tritransitive lit tree (lit/grok-tritransitive/files/). Text extracts used this tick under /tmp/pay-extracts/.

Series placement: lexical-entry sister of payGIVE; companion to sell, Transfer, deduct, chargeFEE, and remit/wire. Closes the obligation cell of the English payment split. Does not reopen Type A / Type B causation-chain papers. Does not invent cross-language elicitation.

Index 2 citations for this class

Payment citations from Index 2
CodeLanguageIndex 2 citationAs printed
ENEnglishpay, remit, wire, transferVol. 3
ESSpanishpagar, transferir, girarVol. 5
FRFrenchpayer, virer, transférerVol. 5
ITItalianpagare, bonificare, trasferireVol. 5
HUHungarianfizet, átutalVols. 3, 6
BGBulgarianплащам, превеждамVols. 3, 6
PLPolishpłacić / zapłacić, przelewać / przelaćVols. 3, 6
DEGermanbezahlen, überweisenVol. 7
NLDutchbetalen, overmakenVol. 7
NONorwegianbetale, overføreVol. 7

Languages Index 2 does not list for this class are left off the table. Non-English rows are class citations, not sense×language micro-entries. Index 2 does not split GIVE from BILL; the sense pages do.