Compare with…

Arguments

Intended labeling

√SELL + ApplHAVE(Recipient, Themegoods) + for-selected MeasurePPrice ⟨Amount, Denomination⟩

Voice introduces Agent. Low ApplHAVE introduces Recipient and relates Recipient to Theme. √SELL / proc takes Theme (goods) as Incremental Theme of eHAVE. for selects one MeasureP whose inner arguments are Amount (degree) and Denomination (unit). Optional high Appl / Loc introduces Platform or affectee — not a sixth inner argument and not the denomination.

Examples

DOC vs to-frame. Cheapness tracks ACC: Recipient in the DOC, Theme in the to-frame. Price never becomes a DOC applied object.

✓ Pat sold Chris a lawnmower.

RolesHide roles AgentRecipientTheme
Agent Pat Recipient Chris Theme a lawnmower

Recipient in the DOC.

✓ Pat sold a lawnmower to Chris.

RolesHide roles AgentRecipientTheme
Agent Pat Recipient to Chris Theme a lawnmower

Theme in the to-frame.

✓ Pat sold Chris a lawnmower for twenty dollars / for $20.

RolesHide roles AgentRecipientThemePrice
Agent Pat Recipient Chris Theme a lawnmower Price for twenty dollars / for $20

Price never becomes a DOC applied object.

✓ Pat sold a lawnmower for $20.

RolesHide roles AgentThemePrice
Agent Pat Theme a lawnmower Price for $20

Recipient omitted; for-PP may reread as Theme₂ of exchange — still one MeasureP

✓ Pat sold a lawnmower.

RolesHide roles AgentTheme
Agent Pat Theme a lawnmower

Recipient and Price independently omissible

* Pat sold Chris for a lawnmower.

RolesHide roles AgentRecipientfor-PP
Agent Pat Recipient Chris for-PP for a lawnmower

Recipient ≠ Theme₂

* Pat sold $20 a lawnmower.

RolesHide roles AgentThemePrice
Agent Pat Theme a lawnmower Price $20

Price ≠ DOC applied object

If Chris were incoming Theme₂ of a swap, for-Chris should be as cheap as for-$20. It is not. If Price were a Recipient, it would alternate into the DOC applied-object slot the way Chris does. MeasureP is not a Recipient.

NegQ baseline (English map)

✓ Didn’t Pat sell Chris a lawnmower for twenty dollars?

✓ Didn’t Pat sell a lawnmower to Chris for twenty dollars?

✓ Wasn’t Chris sold a lawnmower for twenty dollars?

* Wasn’t twenty dollars sold Chris a lawnmower?

Notes

Working paper · September 2026 · English micro-entry · Beyond Index 2

Default asymmetric commercial-transfer sense. Recipient HAS goods; Price is one for-selected MeasureP ⟨Amount, Denomination⟩. Not trade/swap, not payGIVE, not four sisters of one V.

Compare languages EN micro-entry live ES vender live FR vendre live IT vendere live DE verkaufen live NL verkopen live HU elad live PL sprzedać live NO selge live BG продавам live RU продавать live PT vender live AR باع live HE מכר live KO 팔다 live TR satmak live FI myydä live EL πουλάω live HI बेचना live JA uru live Beyond Index 2 ZH mài live NV Group A deferred

Compare languages. Sense × language tick: sell · English. Twins: sell · Spanish (vender) · sell · French (vendre) · sell · Italian (vendere) · sell · Japanese (uru) · sell · Mandarin (mài) · sell · German (verkaufen) · sell · Dutch (verkopen) · sell · Hungarian (elad) · sell · Polish (sprzedać / sprzedawać) · sell · Norwegian (selge) · sell · Bulgarian (продавам) · sell · Russian (продавать / продать) · sell · Portuguese (vender) · sell · Arabic (باع) · sell · Hebrew (מכר) · sell · Korean (팔다) · sell · Turkish (satmak) · sell · Finnish (myydä) · sell · Greek (πουλάω / πουλώ) · sell · Hindi (बेचना). Measuring companions: deduct · earmark · chargeFEE. Geometry neighbors: give · payGIVE · trade · swap. Index 2 does not list sell.

Working paper. English-only micro-entry from Lexical_Entry_Sell_Argument_Structure, with WH and NegQ baselines from the Chase-grand and Negative_Questions_Sell Group A extracts. It does not restamp those DOCX files. Constructed examples diagnose Case and MeasureP; they are not spontaneous-speech citations.
Constructed examples. Frames below are the lexical entry’s diagnostics (DOC vs to, MeasureP WH, underivables). Payment-true is implicated, not entailed — same moral as earmark not entailing spending.
Class table. Index 2 does not list sell. Like chargeFEE, this root sits Beyond Index 2 with measuring companions deduct and earmark. Neighbouring Index 2 classes (Transfer, Payment) are not a translation of sell.
Scout / deferred. Japanese and Mandarin micro-entries are live at sell-ja.html and sell-zh.html. Navajo packaging notes in the Group A extracts remain labeled speculation/scout. No fake elicitation for NV this tick.

Hierarchy

Not five-place. Not four sisters of one V. Surface count can name Pat, Chris, a lawnmower, and a price, but the lexicon does not list four co-arguments of √SELL.

$20 = twenty dollars = one MeasureP. Orthography is not extra arity. The dollar sign is a denomination prefix that spells the same unit the plural noun spells postnominally. There is no sixth argument “currency symbol.”

Listed core is three-place in the give sense (Pat sold Chris a lawnmower). The added layer is 3+1: an extra selected PP, not Type A causation and not bet’s 1+3 risk geometry. Bet’s Stake is itself a MeasureP; sell’s Theme is goods and its Price is a separate MeasureP.

MeasureP WH diagnostics

WH forces Amount ≠ Denomination inside one Case object of for. Verbal WH sees the MeasureP, not unit and degree as two objects of sell. Same MeasureP pattern as deduct.

  1. ✓ Pat sold Chris a lawnmower for how many dollars?
  2. ✓ Pat sold Chris a lawnmower for twenty of what?
  3. ✓ In what currency did Pat sell Chris a lawnmower for twenty?
  4. * Pat sold Chris a lawnmower for what twenty.
  5. * What twenty did Pat sell Chris a lawnmower for?
  6. * Dollars did Pat sell Chris a lawnmower for how many?

Two constraints conspire on the stars: Left Branch Condition (Amount in Spec,MeasureP / DegP; English cannot extract the degree and leave the unit stranded under for), and sortal mismatch under bare what (what wants an N or whole DP; twenty is a numeral, not a denomination).

Superiority ranks Agent > Recipient / Theme > Price-MeasureP > (optional Platform). Denomination does not get its own slot in that ranking unless recoded as of what or in what.

Scaler vs unit (Chase · fifty grand)

Grand is a thousand-scaler, not U. Fifty grand what seats what as denomination N after a DegP+scaler. Polar Did and information-seeking WH compete at C — echo or of/in rescues, not a second verbal object. Do not treat American slang as structure.

Geometry · sell ≠ trade/swap ≠ payGIVE

In Pat sold Chris a lawnmower, Chris comes to HAVE the lawnmower. That is give-geometry. The DOC is the spell-out of a low applicative HAVE, exactly as gave Chris a lawnmower.

  • ≠ trade / swap. Chris is Recipient HAVE-goods, not Theme₂. SWAP inversion is a different root; *Pat sold 8,400 USDT for 0.2 BTC is only good if the goods really are the USDT.
  • ≠ payGIVE. On sell, Recipient HAS goods; Price is for-MeasureP. On pay, Recipient HAS Amount. Shared currency nouns do not merge the roots.
  • Payment-true is implicated, not entailed. A separate pay event can be anaphoric to the Price without being listed on sell.

When Recipient is dropped (Pat sold a lawnmower for $20), the for-PP can be reread as incoming Incremental Theme of an exchange. That rereading changes the Appl head (HAVE vs SWAP); it does not split twenty from dollars or add a verbal sister for the unit. Theme₂ is still one MeasureP.

Shells, ApplP, and Case

Base tree (asymmetric sale)

VoiceP  [ Pat
  vP / initP
    ApplP_LOW  [ Chris   [ Appl_HAVE
      VP  [ √SELL   [ Theme  a lawnmower ] ] ] ]
    PP_for  [ for  [ MeasureP  [ Amount twenty ] [ N dollars ] ] ] ]

English sell never assigns four structural Cases. Japanese Double-o is the morphological version of the same ceiling: two accusatives from one domain are blocked. A language that appears to have “sold him the mower twenty dollars” has either a second domain (CAUSE or high Appl) or a MeasureP that is not a second object.

Amount is not an Incremental Theme of sell on the give-reading. The lawnmower is. Twenty dollars can measure the sale as a scale (the price at which the HAVE event is licensed) without being the object that is incrementally transferred. On the SWAP rereading, the MeasureP becomes the incoming Incremental Theme — still one Theme, still internally Amount + Unit. Where an alternation chooses the object by incremental theme, as in English spray/load beside the lexical causative, the revisable note is Causative templates and argument selection.

Omission does not demote Price to a pure adjunct. High and selected P-layers are optional in the numeration; they are still arguments when present. The diagnostic is participanthood under Case, binding, and WH — not omitability.

Underivables (English)

  1. * Pat sold Chris for a lawnmower. Recipient ≠ Theme₂
  2. * Pat sold $20 a lawnmower. Price ≠ DOC applied object
  3. * Pat sold Chris a lawnmower for what twenty. Amount ≠ denomination N
  4. * What twenty did Pat sell Chris a lawnmower for?
  5. * Wasn’t twenty dollars sold Chris a lawnmower? Price-U ≠ nominative DOC subject
  6. * Dollars did Pat sell Chris a lawnmower for how many? Unit not verbal sister of how many

Group A packaging · Mandarin live · Navajo deferred

Group A (English, Japanese, Mandarin, Navajo) is the contrast set already used for MeasureP pied-piping. Same hierarchy; different host of Amount+Denomination and cloth of Recipient. English page remains the EN micro-entry; Japanese at sell · Japanese (uru); Mandarin at sell · Mandarin (mài / 卖). Navajo stem-internal unit remains open/scout — label speculation; do not fake elicitation. Full sense×language page for Navajo is a later queue tick.

Open items

  • Currency-symbol syntax. Is $ a D-level denomination prefix, a classifier, or a silent N dollars with $ as a written diacritic? WH facts treat $20 as twenty dollars either way. Speculative.
  • Dual-denomination prices (for 0.2 BTC / 8,400 USDT). Still one MeasureP with a pair-name unit (LP-token moral), not two Themes / a sixth slot.
  • Sell versus cost / chargeFEE. Charge Chris $20 for a lawnmower looks closer to pay-geometry with MeasureP as object and Chris as applied source. Needs its own grid; do not reuse this frame.
  • Group A tightness / Navajo. Japanese classifier-ride is on sell-ja.html; Mandarin 把 / 给 / 多少钱 on sell-zh.html. If Navajo price-unit is stem-internal, denomination WH may be verb alternation. NV scout / predicted — not elicited here.

Corpus filenames

Primary extract for this micro-entry; companions supply WH scaler correction and NegQ / Group A packaging notes. DOCX originals under the Tritransitive lit tree; text extracts used this tick under /tmp/sell-extracts/.

Series placement: lexical-entry companion to Transfer, deduct, bet, and earmark. Feeds WH-Raising of Denominations and Pied-Piping MeasureP. Does not reopen Type A / Type B causation-chain papers.