Compare with…

Arguments

Intended labeling

√PAY_GIVE + ApplHAVE(Recipient, MeasurePAmount ⟨Amount, Denomination⟩) + for-Consideration

Voice introduces Payer. Low ApplHAVE introduces Recipient and relates Recipient to the MeasureP. √PAY_GIVE / proc takes MeasureP ⟨n, U⟩ as Incremental Theme of eHAVE — the money. Optional for-PP names Consideration (what the money was exchanged against). Optional Platform / Source (wire channel, from-account) are Loc / FROM extras — not Theme₃ and not a sixth inner argument.

Examples

DOC vs to-frame. Cheapness tracks ACC: Recipient in the DOC, MeasureP (money) in both. Consideration never becomes a DOC applied object. Goods never become the applied object of pay.

✓ Pat paid Chris twenty dollars.

RolesHide roles AgentRecipientMeasureP
Agent Pat Recipient Chris MeasureP twenty dollars

Recipient in the DOC, MeasureP (money) in both.

✓ Pat paid twenty dollars to Chris.

RolesHide roles AgentRecipientMeasureP
Agent Pat Recipient to Chris MeasureP twenty dollars

to-frame. MeasureP (money) in both.

✓ Pat paid Chris twenty dollars for the lawnmower / for $20.

RolesHide roles AgentRecipientMeasurePConsideration
Agent Pat Recipient Chris MeasureP twenty dollars Consideration for the lawnmower / for $20

DOC + for-Consideration

✓ Pat paid twenty dollars for the lawnmower.

RolesHide roles AgentMeasurePConsideration
Agent Pat MeasureP twenty dollars Consideration for the lawnmower

Recipient omitted; for-PP = Consideration

✓ Pat paid twenty dollars.

RolesHide roles AgentMeasureP
Agent Pat MeasureP twenty dollars

Recipient and Consideration independently omissible

* Pat paid Chris the lawnmower twenty dollars.

RolesHide roles AgentRecipientMeasurePgoods
Agent Pat Recipient Chris MeasureP twenty dollars goods the lawnmower

four-place accident

* Pat paid a lawnmower twenty dollars.

RolesHide roles AgentMeasurePgoods
Agent Pat MeasureP twenty dollars goods a lawnmower

goods ≠ applied object of pay

If the lawnmower were Recipient or Theme₂ of a swap, it would alternate into the DOC applied-object slot the way Chris does. It does not. MeasureP is the money; Consideration is not a second ACC sister.

NegQ baseline (English map)

✓ Didn’t Pat pay Chris twenty dollars?

RolesHide roles AgentRecipientMeasureP
Agent Pat Recipient Chris MeasureP twenty dollars

NegQ. Recipient in the DOC, MeasureP (money) in both.

✓ Didn’t Pat pay twenty dollars to Chris for the lawnmower?

RolesHide roles AgentRecipientMeasurePConsideration
Agent Pat Recipient to Chris MeasureP twenty dollars Consideration for the lawnmower

NegQ. to-frame + for-Consideration.

✓ Wasn’t Chris paid twenty dollars?

RolesHide roles RecipientMeasureP
Recipient Chris MeasureP twenty dollars

Passive promotes Recipient in the DOC.

✓ Wasn’t twenty dollars paid to Chris?

RolesHide roles RecipientMeasureP
Recipient to Chris MeasureP twenty dollars

Passive promotes twenty dollars as a whole.

* Wasn’t Chris paid the lawnmower twenty dollars?

RolesHide roles RecipientMeasurePgoods
Recipient Chris MeasureP twenty dollars goods the lawnmower

four-place accident

* Didn’t Pat pay a lawnmower twenty dollars?

RolesHide roles AgentMeasurePgoods
Agent Pat MeasureP twenty dollars goods a lawnmower

goods ≠ applied object of pay

payBILL contrast (sister root — not this page)

✓ Didn’t Pat pay the invoice?

RolesHide roles Agent
Agent Pat

Cheap associate is the document.

✓ Wasn’t the invoice paid?

Passive promotes the invoice.

✓ Didn’t Pat pay the invoice with twenty dollars / in dollars?

RolesHide roles AgentMeasureP
Agent Pat MeasureP with twenty dollars / in dollars

MeasureP as instrument (with/in). Cheap associate is the document.

* Wasn’t twenty dollars paid the invoice?

RolesHide roles MeasurePdocument
MeasureP twenty dollars document the invoice

That is not payGIVE’s DOC

Cheap associate is the document. Passive promotes the invoice. That is not payGIVE’s DOC. See payBILL.

Notes

Working paper · September 2026 · English micro-entry · Payment

Give-geometry pay. Recipient HAS the Amount; money is the Incremental Theme MeasureP ⟨Amount, Denomination⟩. Consideration is a selected for-PP, not Purpose. Not payBILL, not sell Price, not chargeFEE Source.

Compare languages EN micro-entry live Index 2 Payment split JA harau live EN payBILL live ZH fù live ES pagar live FR payer live NV Group A deferred DE bezahlen live NL betalen live NO betale live RU платить live

Compare languages. Sense × language tick: payGIVE · English. Twins: Japanese (harau) · Mandarin (fù / 付) · Spanish (pagar) · French (payer). Sister sense (do not merge): payBILL. Index 2 pointer: pay. Contrast grid: sell (HAVE-goods + for-MeasureP_Price). Geometry neighbors: give · chargeFEE · remit · wire · transfer. Measuring companions: deduct · creditFIN · bet.

Working paper. English-only micro-entry from Lexical_Entry_Pay_Argument_Structure, with NegQ baselines from Negative_Questions_Pay and the Group A contrast set. It does not restamp those DOCX files. Constructed examples diagnose Case and MeasureP; they are not spontaneous-speech citations.
Constructed examples. Frames below are the lexical entry’s diagnostics (DOC vs to, MeasureP WH, underivables). Payment-true is e2 of payGIVE (Recipient HAS Amount). Goods-HAVE and invoice-clearance are not defaults of this root.
Sense split. Index 2 lists pay under Payment. The entry splits payGIVE from payBILL (and keeps paySELL off this page). Do not collapse invoice-ACC into a fourth Theme of give-geometry pay.
Scout / deferred. Japanese harau is live at pay-give-ja.html; Mandarin fù / 付 is live at pay-give-zh.html; Spanish pagar is live at pay-give-es.html (Index 2 Payment; DAT Recipient + ACC MeasureP). French payer is live at pay-give-fr.html (Index 2 Payment; DAT Recipient lui/à + ACC MeasureP; Done=100). Navajo money-HANDLE packaging notes in the Group A extract remain labeled speculation/scout. No fake elicitation for NV this tick.

Hierarchy

Not four-place. Surface count can name Pat, Chris, twenty dollars, and a lawnmower, but the lexicon does not list four co-arguments of √PAY_GIVE.

$20 = twenty dollars = one MeasureP. Orthography is not extra arity. The dollar sign is a denomination prefix that spells the same unit the plural noun spells postnominally. There is no sixth argument “currency symbol.”

Listed core is give-geometry with money as Theme (Pat paid Chris twenty dollars). The added layer is optional Consideration, not Type A causation and not sell’s Price-as-MeasureP-of-for. On sell, Recipient HAS goods and Price is the for-MeasureP. On payGIVE, Recipient HAS Amount and Consideration is the for-PP.

MeasureP WH diagnostics

WH forces Amount ≠ Denomination inside one Case object of pay. Verbal WH sees the MeasureP, not unit and degree as two objects of pay. Same MeasureP pattern as sell’s Price, deduct, and bet’s Stake — but here the MeasureP is ACC Theme, not a for-selected Price.

  1. ✓ How many dollars did Pat pay Chris?
  2. ✓ How many dollars / in what currency didn’t Pat pay Chris?
  3. ✓ What did Pat pay Chris twenty of / in?
  4. * What did Pat pay Chris twenty?
  5. * What did Pat pay Chris twenty for the lawnmower?
  6. * Twenty was paid Chris dollars.

Two constraints conspire on the stars: Left Branch Condition (Amount in Spec,MeasureP / DegP; English cannot extract the degree and leave the unit stranded next to the verb), and sortal mismatch under bare what (what wants an N or whole DP; twenty is a numeral, not a denomination). of/in recode the unit as a PP.

Superiority ranks Payer > Recipient / MeasureP > Consideration > (optional Platform). Denomination does not get its own slot in that ranking unless recoded as of what or in what.

Optional in on bare U (Disney+ · SHIBA)

pay (in) SHIBA — in optional on bare denomination when Amount is silent/anaphoric to offer-price π. *pay in thirty thousand SHIBA crashes: in wants U, not a complete ⟨n,U⟩. Repair: pay thirty thousand in SHIBA. Same independence of denomination from amount as bet BTC / charge in yen. Do not treat the optional P as a second verbal object.

Geometry · payGIVE ≠ sell Price ≠ chargeFEE ≠ payBILL

In Pat paid Chris twenty dollars, Chris comes to HAVE the twenty. That is give-geometry. The DOC is the spell-out of a low applicative HAVE, exactly as gave Chris twenty dollars — but the Incremental Theme is a MeasureP of funds, not goods.

Which theta role is the object in this low ApplHAVE domain is the revisable note Causative templates and argument selection.

  • ≠ sell. On sell, Recipient HAS goods; Price is for-MeasureP. On payGIVE, Recipient HAS Amount; Consideration is for-PP of goods/service. Shared currency nouns do not merge the roots. NegQ cheapness flips: money is ACC on pay, inside for on sell.
  • ≠ chargeFEE. They charged Chris twenty dollars writes Chris as Source (money FROM). They paid Chris twenty dollars writes Chris as Recipient (money TO). Both passivize Chris; the Appl is not the same.
  • ≠ cost. The lawnmower cost Chris twenty dollars — *Was Chris costed twenty dollars? Cost does not write Appl_HAVE Recipient. Pay does.
  • ≠ payBILL. Invoice/obligation as ACC; MeasureP as instrument (with/in). No silent twenty as DOC object. Crossing the roots smuggles a four-place reading.
  • ≠ grant Purpose / earmark / blame for. Pay’s for names Consideration (AGAINST). Grant’s for is Type B Purpose. Deduct’s for is high Reason. Blame’s for is Charge. Keep the fors apart.
  • Payment-true is e2. A follow-up No — Chris never ended up with the twenty denies e2 of payGIVE. Goods-HAVE is sell’s e2, not pay’s. Invoice-clearance is e2 of payBILL.

Ordinary coercion toward trade (Amount as Theme₁, lawnmower as Theme₂) is available and is not the listed payGIVE grid. Wire, remit, and transfer-as-remit sit on this cloth with Source/channel extra; Index 2 lists them as their own citations.

Shells, ApplP, and Case

Base tree (asymmetric payGIVE)

VoiceP  [ Pat
  vP / initP
    ApplP_LOW  [ Chris   [ Appl_HAVE
      VP  [ √PAY_GIVE   [ MeasureP  [ Amount twenty ] [ N dollars ] ] ] ] ]
    PP_for  [ for  [ the lawnmower ] ] ]

English payGIVE assigns ACC to the money (both DOC and to-frame) and, in the DOC, to Recipient as applied object. It never assigns four structural Cases. Japanese Double-o is the morphological version of the same ceiling: two accusatives from one domain are blocked; o lands on the MeasureP, ni on Recipient.

Amount is Incremental Theme of pay on the give-reading. The lawnmower is Consideration, not Theme. Homomorphism is on ⟨n,U⟩. Passive promotes twenty dollars as a whole, or promotes Recipient in the DOC, never twenty alone (*Twenty was paid Chris dollars).

Voice filter: weather fails Payer; institutional payers (escrow, payroll, the city) pass. Weaker than Voice_J on blame — systems can pay; they cannot blame.

Omission does not demote MeasureP or Consideration to pure adjuncts when present. The diagnostic is participanthood under Case, binding, and WH — not omitability.

Underivables (English)

  1. * Pat paid Chris the lawnmower twenty dollars. four-place / goods ≠ Theme₄
  2. * Pat paid a lawnmower twenty dollars. goods ≠ DOC applied object
  3. * What did Pat pay Chris twenty? Amount ≠ denomination N (LBC)
  4. * What did Pat pay Chris twenty for the lawnmower?
  5. * Twenty was paid Chris dollars. Amount ≠ nominative without unit
  6. * Wasn’t twenty dollars paid the invoice? payBILL ≠ payGIVE DOC
  7. * Did the weather pay Chris twenty dollars? Voice filter

Group A packaging · Japanese live · Mandarin / Navajo deferred

Group A (English, Japanese, Mandarin, Navajo) is the contrast set for MeasureP pied-piping with the Incremental Theme flipped from sell’s goods to pay’s money. Same hierarchy; different host of Amount+Denomination and cloth of Recipient. Japanese harau is at payGIVE · Japanese (harau) (ACC money vs uru’s de Price). Mandarin fù is at payGIVE · Mandarin (付) (把-money + 给-Recipient). Spanish pagar is at payGIVE · Spanish (Group B: DAT Recipient + ACC MeasureP + por-Consideration). French payer is at payGIVE · French (Group B: DAT Recipient lui/à + ACC MeasureP + pour-Consideration; Done=100). Navajo money-HANDLE stem switch remains open/scout — label speculation; do not fake elicitation. Full sense×language page for Navajo is a later queue tick.

Open items

  • Border nouns (rent / tuition / fine). One MeasureP with sortal N, or documented coercion to payBILL. Speculative packaging, not a fifth slot.
  • Dual-denomination / LP tokens (pay 8,400 USDT for 0.2 BTC). Still one MeasureP Theme with pair-name unit when the Theme really is the USDT; inversion is sell/spend of crypto, not payGIVE of USDT.
  • Japanese classifier-ride / Mandarin measure-word on 付, elicited against *what twenty / *把二十付了美元. JA/ZH scout — not elicited here.
  • Navajo. If price-unit is stem-internal, denomination WH may be verb alternation (money-class HANDLE vs goods-class). Predicted, not elicited.
  • Outer CAUSE (make Pat pay Chris twenty). Site on the causing vs on HAVE of the Amount; Consideration never becomes Causee Case.

Corpus filenames

Primary extract for this micro-entry; companions supply NegQ baselines, Group A packaging, and optional-in denomination notes. DOCX originals under the Tritransitive lit tree; text extracts used this tick under /tmp/pay-extracts/.

Series placement: lexical-entry companion to sell, Transfer, deduct, chargeFEE, and earmark. Feeds WH-Raising of Denominations and Pied-Piping MeasureP. Closes the payment cell of the English lexical grid for give-geometry pay. Does not reopen Type A / Type B causation-chain papers.

Index 2 citations for this class

Payment citations from Index 2
CodeLanguageIndex 2 citationAs printed
ENEnglishpay, remit, wire, transferVol. 3
ESSpanishpagar ES micro-entry, transferir, girarVol. 5
FRFrenchpayer FR micro-entry, virer, transférerVol. 5
ITItalianpagare IT micro-entry, bonificare, trasferireVol. 5
HUHungarianpayGIVE · fizet HU micro-entry, átutalVols. 3, 6
BGBulgarianpayGIVE · плащам BG micro-entry, превеждамVols. 3, 6
PLPolishpayGIVE · płacić / zapłacić PL micro-entry, przelewać / przelaćVols. 3, 6
DEGermanpayGIVE · bezahlen DE micro-entry, überweisenVol. 7
NLDutchpayGIVE · betalen NL micro-entry, overmakenVol. 7
NONorwegianpayGIVE · betale NO micro-entry, overføreVol. 7

Languages Index 2 does not list for this class are left off the table. Spanish pagar, French payer, and Italian pagare are the Romance micro-entries; transferir / girar, virer / transférer, and bonificare / trasferire stay class companions. Hungarian fizet, Polish płacić / zapłacić, and Bulgarian плащам are the Group C micro-entries; átutal, przelewać / przelać, and превеждам stay class companions. Other non-English rows are class citations, not sense×language micro-entries.