Compare with…

Arguments

Intended labeling (shared with English / Japanese)

√PAY_GIVE + ApplHAVE(Recipient给, MeasurePAmount ⟨Amount, Denomination⟩) + 为/买…付-Consideration

Voice introduces Payer. Low ApplHAVE introduces Recipient and relates Recipient to the MeasureP. √付 / proc takes MeasureP ⟨n, U⟩ as Incremental Theme of eHAVE — the money. Mandarin spells Recipient with 给, may 把-front the money QP as a whole, and hosts Consideration as 为 / 买…付 — not a second 把-object. Optional Platform / Source (wire channel, from-account) are Loc / FROM extras — not Theme₃ and not a sixth inner argument. Optional Purpose (为了 / 来) is Type B stacked outside Consideration.

Examples

No English DOC / to-frame ACC flip that promotes Recipient into a second ACC of money+goods. Amount stays the money QP — often 把-fronted as a whole. Recipient is 给. Consideration stays outside a second 把. Cheapness under Neg therefore tracks the 把-money QP unless Focus / WH independently highlights Recipient or Consideration. Companion light verb 支付 keeps the same cloth.

✓ 帕特付给了克里斯二十美元。

RolesHide roles AgentRecipientMeasureP
Agent 帕特 Recipient 给克里斯 MeasureP 二十美元

Agent · 付 · 给-Recipient · MeasureP

✓ 帕特没把二十块付给克里斯吗?

RolesHide roles AgentRecipientMeasureP
Agent 帕特 Recipient 给克里斯 MeasureP 把二十块

canonical NegQ · 没…吗 · 把-money

✓ 帕特没付给克里斯二十美元吗?

RolesHide roles AgentRecipientMeasureP
Agent 帕特 Recipient 给克里斯 MeasureP 二十美元

postverbal MeasureP; no 把

✓ 帕特没为割草机付给克里斯二十美元吗?

RolesHide roles AgentRecipientMeasurePConsideration
Agent 帕特 Recipient 给克里斯 MeasureP 二十美元 Consideration 为割草机

为-Consideration · not second 把

✓ 帕特没把 8400 USDT 付给 Kim 吗?

RolesHide roles AgentRecipientMeasureP
Agent 帕特 Recipient 给 Kim MeasureP 把 8400 USDT

crypto MeasureP under 把

✓ 帕特付了二十块。

RolesHide roles AgentMeasureP
Agent 帕特 MeasureP 二十块

Recipient and Consideration independently omissible

* 把割草机付给克里斯二十块。

RolesHide roles RecipientMeasurePgoods
Recipient 给克里斯 MeasureP 二十块 goods 把割草机

goods as 把-object of 付 — sell cloth

* 把二十块把账单付了。

RolesHide roles MeasurePdocument
MeasureP 把二十块 document 把账单

no DOC of money + bill

NegQ baseline (Mandarin map · Group A §5)

✓ 帕特没把二十块付给克里斯吗?

✓ 没把多少美元付给克里斯? MeasureP WH inside 把

✓ 付了多少钱 / 付多少美元? degree / Amount+#

✓ 以什么货币没付? in-strategy rescue

✓ 谁没把多少钱付给谁? in-situ height

* 没把多少付了美元给克里斯? classifier / degree split under 把

* 把割草机付给克里斯二十块。 sell cloth on 付

A bare negative answer on the canonical NegQ most readily challenges the event or the money (把-Theme cheapness). Challenging the Recipient wants that individual already under discussion. That is the opposite of 卖, where 把 fronts the goods and the money is inside Price.

payBILL contrast (sister root — not this page)

✓ 没付账吗 / 没把账单付了吗?

✓ 没付割草机的钱吗?

✓ 没把账单用二十块付了吗? instrument / denomination wrapping under BILL

* 把二十块把账单付了。

Cheap associate is the document. MeasureP as instrument under 用 is not sell’s Price and not a second 把-object of give-geometry pay. See payBILL · Mandarin.

Notes

Working paper · September 2026 · Mandarin micro-entry · Beyond Index 2 · Group A · Payment

Give-geometry pay in Mandarin. Amount = money QP (often 把-fronted); Recipient = 给; Consideration = 为 / 买…付, not a second 把-object. Same √PAY_GIVE + ApplHAVE geometry as English payGIVE and Japanese harau; cloth is coverbs and split-field order. Group A flip vs sell · mài: 把 fronts money here, goods there.

Compare languages ZH micro-entry live Beyond Index 2 Group A measuring-locus ES pagar live FR payer live NV companion deferred DE bezahlen live NL betalen live NO betale live

Compare languages. Sense × language tick: payGIVE · Mandarin (fù / 付). Twins: English payGIVE · Japanese (harau) · Spanish (pagar) · French (payer). Sister sense (do not merge): payBILL · Mandarin (付账) · English · Japanese. Index 2 pointer: pay. Contrast grid: sell · Mandarin (mài) (HAVE-goods + 以/用/多少钱-MeasureP_Price). Geometry neighbors: give · chargeFEE · ZH · remit · wire · transfer. Measuring companions: deduct · creditFIN · bet. Index 2 does not list Mandarin under Payment (ZH Index 2 cell is Risk / dǔ only).

Working paper. Mandarin-only micro-entry from Tritransitive NegQ Group A contrast set (Negative_Questions_Pay_GroupA_Contrast_Set §5), sharing geometry with Lexical_Entry_Pay_Argument_Structure and the English / Japanese payGIVE micro-entries. Constructed diagnostics diagnose 把, 给, measure-word integrity, and MeasureP; they are not spontaneous-speech citations. Navajo money-HANDLE companions in the same DOCX are pointed only — this tick does not deepen them. Companion 支付 is packaging of the same GIVE geometry — not a second root invented here.
Constructed examples. Frames below are packaging hypotheses aligned with Volume 4 Group A notes. Payment-true is e2 of payGIVE (Recipient HAS Amount). Goods-HAVE and invoice-clearance are not defaults of this root. Do not fake elicitation. Where the extract labels prediction or scout, this page keeps the flag.
Class table. Index 2 does not list Mandarin under Payment. Like sell · Mandarin, this root sits Beyond Index 2 as a Group A sense×language page. Neighbouring Index 2 classes (Risk / dǔ) are not a translation of payGIVE. English Payment citations remain on pay.
Scout / deferred. Navajo money-HANDLE packaging shares the Group A DOCX but is not a micro-entry this tick. Classifier-ride details beyond the attested 把-money QP / 给-Recipient / 为-Consideration grid remain scout where the extract labels speculation. No fake elicitation.

Hierarchy

Same inventory as English payGIVE. Not four-place. Surface count can name Pat, Chris, twenty dollars, and a lawnmower, but the lexicon does not list four co-arguments of √PAY_GIVE / √付.

$20 = 二十美元 / 二十块 = one MeasureP. Orthography / measure-word morphology is not extra arity. Mensural 二十美元 on the Amount and optional sortal measure on Consideration are two QPs on two already-listed objects — they do not grow √付. There is no sixth argument “currency symbol.” Asking for the classifier (多少块, 多少美元) is asking inside the money QP, not asking for a second object of 付.

What Group A Mandarin changes is coverb cloth, split-field order (V between Agent and Theme when 把 fronts), and where Amount+Denomination host (measure word inside one QP under 把). What it does not change is the inventory. Twenty is still not dollars. Dollars is still not a sister of 付. Payment-true is still e2. Goods-HAVE is still missing. On sell, Recipient HAS goods and Price is 以/用/多少钱. On payGIVE, Recipient HAS Amount and Consideration is the 为-PP.

MeasureP WH diagnostics

WH forces Amount ≠ Denomination inside one Case object of pay — here often under 把. Verbal WH sees the MeasureP, not unit and degree as two objects of 付. Mandarin keeps WH in situ under polar 吗 more freely than English Did + what. Same MeasureP pattern as English payGIVE, Japanese harau, and deduct — but here the MeasureP is the Incremental Theme under 把/付, not a Price layer of sell. *把多少付了美元 and *把二十付了美元 are the Mandarin spelling of *what twenty and of the illegal QP split under 把.

  1. ✓ 没把多少美元付给克里斯? Amount WH + # head inside 把
  2. ✓ 付了多少钱 / 付多少美元? degree; unit bound
  3. ✓ 以什么货币没付? in-strategy rescue
  4. ✓ 谁没把多少钱付给谁? in-situ; Agent > MeasureP > Recipient
  5. ✓ 谁没为割草机付给克里斯二十块? Consideration under 为
  6. * 没把多少付了美元给克里斯? classifier stranded from N under 把
  7. * 把二十付了美元。 Mandarin of *what twenty / LBC split
  8. * 把美元付了二十。 unit stranded from Amount under 把

Two constraints conspire on the stars: Left Branch / QP integrity (Amount and measure word stay inside one 把 domain; Mandarin cannot treat bare 二十 as the sortal of a stranded WH under 把), and the one-object ceiling for 把 on 付 (goods cannot become a second 把-object of pay). Rescues are 多少美元, 多少钱, and 以什么货币 — the Group A spelling of English how many dollars / in what currency. The rescue does not make 美元 a sister of 付了.

把 fronts one money QP, not a second object

✓ 没把多少美元付给克里斯?

✓ 没把 8400 USDT 付给 Kim 吗?

* 没把多少付了美元给克里斯?

* 把割草机付给克里斯二十块。

把 + WH measure takes the whole money QP. *把多少付了 N is the illegal split. *把割草机付给…二十块 is the English four-place / sell-cloth crash unless the verb is 卖. NegQ does not swap the two 把-targets.

Geometry · payGIVE ≠ 卖 Price ≠ 收/扣 ≠ payBILL

In 帕特把二十块付给了克里斯, Chris comes to HAVE the twenty. That is give-geometry. 给-Recipient is the spell-out of low ApplHAVE — the HAVE diagnostic that 换 can drop. The Incremental Theme is a MeasureP of funds, not goods.

Which theta role is the object in this low ApplHAVE domain is the revisable note Causative templates and argument selection.

  • ≠ 卖 / sell. Cloth mismatch under one operator: 没把二十块付给克里斯吗? questions a money QP under 把; 没把割草机卖给克里斯吗? questions goods under 把 with Price outside. Shared 多少钱 and shared 给 are packaging. The coverb / fronting gives the heads away: 把 tracks the money on 付; 把 tracks the mower on 卖.
  • ≠ 换 / swap. 换 inverts two Themes. 付 does not. ✓ 没把 8400 USDT 换成 0.2 个比特币吗? is SWAP. ✓ 没把 8400 USDT 付给 Kim 吗? keeps 给-Recipient. *没把 0.2 个比特币付给 Kim、换 8400 吗? is only good if the Amount really is the BTC.
  • ≠ 收 / 扣 / chargeFEE. 没向帕特收二十块吗 / 没把二十块从帕特扣了吗 write Pat as Source (money FROM). 付给帕特 writes Pat as Recipient (money TO). Follow-ups flip. Both refuse a second 把 of goods+money.
  • ≠ payBILL / 付账. Invoice/obligation as ACC or 把-object; MeasureP as instrument (用). No silent twenty as DOC object. Crossing the roots smuggles a four-place reading.
  • ≠ grant Purpose / earmark / blame for. Pay’s 为 names Consideration (AGAINST). Grant’s Purpose and blame’s Charge stay apart. Type B 为了 stacks outside.
  • Payment-true is e2. A follow-up that Chris never ended up with the twenty denies e2 of payGIVE. Goods-HAVE is sell’s e2, not pay’s. Invoice-clearance is e2 of payBILL.

Ordinary coercion toward trade (Amount as Theme₁, lawnmower as Theme₂) is available and is not the listed payGIVE grid. Wire, remit, and transfer-as-remit sit on this cloth with Source/channel extra.

Shells, ApplP, and coverbs

Base tree (asymmetric payGIVE · Mandarin cloth)

VoiceP  [ 帕特
  vP / initP
    baP  [ 把  [ MeasureP / QP  [ Amount 二十 ] [ U 块/美元 ] ]
      ApplP_LOW  [ Appl_HAVE
        VP  [ √付   … ]  给 克里斯 ] ]
    PP_Cons  [ 为 / 买…付  [ Consideration … ] ] ]

Mandarin 付 never assigns four structural Cases the English DOC way. Amount is the money QP (optionally 把-fronted); Recipient is 给; Consideration is inside P. 把 fronts the inner Incremental Theme of 付 — not Voice and not CAUSE. Split-field order places V between Agent and Theme when 把 fronts; that is packaging of one already-listed object, not a fifth θ-slot. A language that appears to have “paid him the mower twenty dollars” has either a second domain (CAUSE / 让 or high Appl) or a MeasureP that is not a second object.

Amount is Incremental Theme of pay on the give-reading. The lawnmower is Consideration, not Theme. Homomorphism is on ⟨n,U⟩. Passive-like promotion of the MeasureP as a whole, or of Recipient under appropriate Voice, never promotes twenty alone without its unit.

Voice filter: weather fails Payer; institutional payers (escrow, payroll, the city) pass. Weaker than Voice_J on blame — systems can pay; they cannot blame.

Type A · Causee vs Recipient

✓ 谁让帕特把二十块付给克里斯? 让 outer · 把 inner money · 给 Recipient

✓ 院长没让帕特把二十块付给克里斯吗?

让 introduces the outer Causer. 把 still fronts the inner money QP of 付. NegQ can associate with either layer because they are different heads. 让 does not absorb the measure word. Consideration stays outside Causee Case. Purpose 为了 / 来 is Type B and does not 把-front as if it were Theme.

Omission does not demote MeasureP or Consideration to pure adjuncts when present. The diagnostic is participanthood under coverb, binding, and WH — not omitability. Topic can lift Platform or Source without promoting them over the MeasureP in the hierarchy.

Underivables (Mandarin)

  1. * 把割草机付给克里斯二十块。 goods ≠ 把-object of 付 · sell cloth
  2. * 没把多少付了美元给克里斯? classifier / degree split under 把
  3. * 把二十付了美元。 *what twenty / LBC
  4. * 把美元付了二十。 unit stranded from Amount
  5. * 把二十块把账单付了。 payBILL ≠ payGIVE DOC
  6. * 没把 0.2 个比特币付给 Kim、换 8400 吗? no SWAP inversion (unless Amount really is BTC)
  7. * 把割草机卖给克里斯二十块 as if it were 付 cloth sell ≠ pay under one 把-target

Group A packaging · this tick Mandarin only

Group A (English, Japanese, Mandarin, Navajo) is the contrast set for MeasureP pied-piping with the Incremental Theme flipped from sell’s goods to pay’s money. Same hierarchy; different host of Amount+Denomination and cloth of Recipient. This tick is Mandarin payGIVE only. English twin is live at pay-give.html; Japanese twin at pay-give-ja.html. Navajo money-HANDLE stem switch shares the Group A DOCX and remains open/scout — label speculation; do not fake elicitation. Full sense×language page for Navajo is a later queue tick. *what twenty, *nani nijū-o, and *把二十付了美元 are one constraint written in three hosts.

Open items

  • Navajo micro-entry. Same Group A geometry; money-HANDLE packaging; denomination WH may be stem alternation. Deferred — do not invent depth this tick. The extract states where denomination WH under doo … da must be asked: money-class stem vs next word, not a fifth object.
  • Border nouns (房租 / 学费 / 罚款). One MeasureP with sortal N, or documented coercion to payBILL. Speculative packaging, not a fifth slot.
  • Dual-denomination / LP tokens (把 8400 USDT 付给… for 0.2 BTC Consideration). Still one MeasureP Theme with pair-name unit when the Theme really is the USDT; inversion is sell/spend of crypto, not payGIVE of USDT.
  • Classifier-ride on 付, elicited against *what twenty / *把二十付了美元. Scout beyond the attested 把-QP / 多少美元 grid.
  • chargeFEE · Mandarin (收 / 收费). Live (scout) at charge-fee-zh.html. FROM rather than HAVE-TO. Same surface names as Recipient of 付; follow-ups flip.
  • Outer CAUSE (让). Site on the causing vs on HAVE of the Amount; Consideration never becomes Causee Case.

Corpus filenames

Primary extract for this micro-entry is Group A NegQ on pay (Mandarin §5). Geometry is shared with the English lexical entry. Disney+ pay companions supply optional-in / bare-U denomination notes under English; Mandarin maps them as 以什么货币 / bare unit under 把. Text extracts used this tick under /tmp/pay-zh-extracts/ and /tmp/pay-extracts/.

Series placement: Mandarin sense×language twin of English payGIVE and Japanese harau. Feeds WH-Raising of Denominations and Pied-Piping MeasureP under Group A cloth with the Incremental Theme flipped from sell’s goods to pay’s money. Does not reopen Type A / Type B causation-chain papers. Does not invent NV elicitation.

Index 2 citations for this class

Payment citations from Index 2
CodeLanguageIndex 2 citationAs printed
ENEnglishpay, remit, wire, transferVol. 3
ESSpanishpagar ES micro-entry, transferir, girarVol. 5
FRFrenchpayer FR micro-entry, virer, transférerVol. 5
ITItalianpagare IT micro-entry, bonificare, trasferireVol. 5
HUHungarianpayGIVE · fizet HU micro-entry, átutalVols. 3, 6
BGBulgarianpayGIVE · плащам BG micro-entry, превеждамVols. 3, 6
PLPolishpayGIVE · płacić / zapłacić PL micro-entry, przelewać / przelaćVols. 3, 6
DEGermanpayGIVE · bezahlen DE micro-entry, überweisenVol. 7
NLDutchpayGIVE · betalen NL micro-entry, overmakenVol. 7
NONorwegianpayGIVE · betale NO micro-entry, overføreVol. 7

Languages Index 2 does not list for this class are left off the table. Mandarin is absent from Index 2 Payment — this page is Beyond Index 2. Spanish pagar, French payer, and Italian pagare are live Index 2 micro-entries; their transfer companions stay unfilled. Hungarian fizet is live; átutal stays unfilled. Polish płacić / zapłacić is live; przelewać / przelać stay unfilled. Bulgarian плащам is live; превеждам stays unfilled. Other rows are class citations.