Arguments
Intended labeling
√PAY_BILL + Bill / Obligation (ACC) + optional MeasureP as INSTRUMENT (with / in)
Voice introduces Payer. The Bill / Obligation is the Case object — a document or obligation-kind (invoice, bill, fine as document). Optional MeasureP ⟨Amount, Denomination⟩ reenters as instrument (with twenty dollars) or denomination (in dollars), not as ACC Theme and not as a DOC applied object. Platform (at the window / over the wire) is Loc extra. Source (from the escrow) is adjunct FROM — not deduct’s Domain object.
Examples
One object: the document / obligation. Money stays a with/in-PP when expressed. There is no productive DOC of bill + money. The invoice passivizes; a silent twenty does not.
- ✓ Pat paid the invoice. canonical · document ACC
- ✓ Pat paid the bill.
- ✓ Pat paid the invoice with twenty dollars. MeasureP as instrument
- ✓ Pat paid the invoice in dollars. denomination wrapping
- ✓ Pat paid the fine / the tuition bill. obligation-kind ACC
- ✓ Didn’t Pat pay the invoice with twenty dollars / in dollars?
- ✓ Wasn’t the invoice paid? passive promotes document
- * Wasn’t twenty dollars paid the invoice. no DOC · money ≠ applied object
- * Pat paid the invoice Chris twenty dollars. four-place accident
- * Pat paid twenty dollars the invoice. money ≠ DOC Theme of bill
Passive · document vs silent twenty
✓ The invoice was paid. document promotes
✓ The bill was paid with twenty dollars.
* Twenty dollars was paid the invoice. no DOC promote of money
* Twenty was paid dollars the invoice. Amount ≠ separate promote
✓ Chris was paid twenty dollars. payGIVE DOC contrast · Recipient promotes
Border nouns · rent / tuition / fine
✓ Pat paid the rent / the tuition / a fine. obligation-kind ACC · or MeasureP with sortal N
✓ How much rent didn’t they pay? QP pied-pipes
✓ What didn’t they pay? can be rent
The series leaves the border as packaging of one MeasureP with a sortal N, or a documented coercion to payBILL — not a fifth slot.
payGIVE contrast (sister root — not this page)
✓ Pat paid Chris twenty dollars.
✓ Pat paid twenty dollars to Chris for the lawnmower.
✓ Wasn’t Chris paid twenty dollars?
✓ Wasn’t twenty dollars paid to Chris?
* Wasn’t twenty dollars paid the invoice?
Cheap associate is the money QP. Passive promotes Recipient (DOC) or MeasureP. That is not payBILL’s document ACC. See payGIVE.
Notes
Working paper · September 2026 · English micro-entry · Payment
Obligation / document pay. The accusative is the bill or invoice, not the Amount. MeasureP comes back as instrument (with) or denomination (in). No productive DOC. Invoice-clearance is e2. Not payGIVE, not sell Price, not chargeFEE Source.
Sense × language tick: payBILL · English. Twins: Japanese (seikyūsho-o harau) · Mandarin (付账) · German (bezahlen) · French (payer) · Spanish (pagar) · Italian (pagare) · Portuguese (pagar) · Russian (оплатить) · Dutch (betalen) · Polish (zapłacić) · Hungarian (kifizet) · Bulgarian (платя) · Norwegian (betale) · Turkish (ödemek) · Korean (내다) · Greek (πληρώνω) · Finnish (maksaa) · Hindi (चुकाना) · Arabic (دفع) · Hebrew (שילם). Sister sense (do not merge): payGIVE · Japanese (harau). Index 2 pointer: pay. Geometry neighbors: chargeFEE · remit · wire · transfer · sell · deduct · bet. Multi-sense lemma — CAPS sense as HTML subscript.
Working paper.
English-only micro-entry deepened from Lexical_Entry_Pay_Argument_Structure (§6 payBILL), with NegQ baselines from Negative_Questions_Pay §7 and the Group A contrast set §5.5 / §9. It does not restamp those DOCX files. Constructed examples diagnose Case, document-ACC vs money-ACC, and instrument MeasureP; they are not spontaneous-speech citations.
Constructed examples.
Frames below are the lexical entry’s diagnostics (document ACC, passive of invoice, with/in MeasureP, no DOC of bill + money). Invoice-clearance / DISCHARGE is e2 of payBILL. Payment-true of a silent twenty and goods-HAVE are not defaults of this root.
Sense split.
Index 2 lists
pay under Payment. The entry splits
payGIVE from
payBILL (and keeps
paySELL off this page). Do not collapse invoice-ACC into a fourth Theme of give-geometry pay. Shared morphology is packaging, not one NegQ profile.
Scout / deferred.
Romance pagar una factura / payer la facture, Germanic betale regningen, and Navajo obligation-word packaging notes in Groups A–D remain labeled speculation/scout. No fake elicitation for non-English this tick.
Hierarchy
Not a fourth argument of payGIVE. Surface count can name Pat, the invoice, and twenty dollars — but the lexicon does not list bill and money as co-arguments of one DOC. Writing those as sisters predicts *Wasn’t twenty dollars paid the invoice? and a silent-twenty Theme. Neither holds.
〚√PAY_BILL〛 = λB λe . DISCHARGE(e) ∧ Obligation(e)=B. MeasureP optional as INSTRUMENT(e, ⟨n,U⟩), not as ACC. Result e2: the obligation is discharged. Payment-true of a HAVE-Recipient Amount is e2 of payGIVE, not this root.
Working hierarchy: Payer > Obligation (> optional MeasureP-as-instrument, Platform, Source). Obligation outranks instrument MeasureP for Case and passives. There is no Appl_HAVE Recipient shell and no productive DOC.
MeasureP / WH diagnostics
On payBILL, verbal WH’s cheap object is the document. MeasureP is not ACC Theme; when present it is instrument / denomination. WH that treats money as the Case object of this root is a speaker swap into payGIVE.
- ✓ What didn’t Pat pay? the bill / the invoice
- ✓ Which invoice did Pat pay?
- ✓ How much rent didn’t they pay? border · QP with sortal N
- ✓ What did Pat pay the invoice with? instrument
- ✓ In what / of what did Pat pay the invoice?
- * What did Pat pay twenty the invoice? no money+bill DOC
- * What did Pat pay the invoice twenty? LBC-shaped accident
- ✓ How many dollars did Pat pay Chris? payGIVE contrast · money ACC
Superiority ranks Payer > Obligation > (optional Instrument MeasureP / Platform). Amount and Denomination never compete as two verbal WH-items of payBILL. of/in/with recode the unit or the whole QP as a PP, not as a second ACC.
Geometry · payBILL ≠ payGIVE ≠ sell ≠ chargeFEE
In Pat paid the invoice with twenty dollars, the invoice is discharged. Twenty dollars is how, not who HAS the money as Theme. That is obligation-clearance — not give-geometry pay.
- ≠ payGIVE. Shared morphology. Split: GIVE writes MeasureP as ACC Theme and Recipient as Appl_HAVE; BILL writes the document as ACC and MeasureP as instrument. DOC: GIVE yes; BILL no. e2: HAVE of Amount vs DISCHARGE of Obligation. Crossing the roots smuggles a four-place reading (*Wasn’t twenty dollars paid the invoice?).
- ≠ sell. Sell: Recipient HAS goods; Price stays inside for. BILL: document is ACC; money is instrument. No SWAP inversion; no Price MeasureP of for.
- ≠ chargeFEE. Shared commercial cloth and MeasureP Hom. Split: chargeFEE promotes Payer as ACC Source (FROM); BILL promotes the invoice as ACC Obligation. No levy; no Domain of loss as object.
- ≠ cost. The lawnmower cost Chris twenty dollars — *Was Chris costed twenty dollars? Cost drops Voice. BILL keeps Payer Voice and promotes the document.
- ≠ deduct / creditFIN. Deduct’s MeasureP is ACC decrement; Domain stays from-PP. BILL’s MeasureP is instrument when present; the ACC is the obligation, not a ledger decrement.
- ≠ remit / wire as channel. Remit/wire sit on payGIVE’s cloth with Source/channel extra. Paying an invoice by wire still has the document as ACC of BILL when that is the selected object.
- Four fors stay off this ACC. GIVE’s for = Consideration. sell’s for = Price. deduct’s for = Reason. grant/earmark’s for = Purpose. BILL’s object is not a for-PP; Purpose layers (paid the invoice to settle the account) stay outer Type B.
- Invoice-clearance is e2. A follow-up No — the twenty never left is compatible as an implicature about how one pays a document; it denies e2 only of payGIVE. No — the invoice is still open denies e2 of BILL.
Shells, ApplP, and Case
Base tree (English · payBILL)
VoiceP [ Pat
VP [ √PAY_BILL [ DP the invoice ] ]
(PP_with [ with [ MeasureP [ Amount twenty ] [ N dollars ] ] ])
(PP_in [ in [ N dollars ] ]) ]
No Appl_HAVE. No Appl_SWAP. No Appl_TASK. English assigns ACC to the Bill / Obligation only. MeasureP, when present, is a PP (with, in). Platform and Source are Loc / FROM extras. Four surface participants never need a DOC of bill + money.
Neo-Davidsonian sketch (entry §8)
∃e [ DISCHARGE(e)
∧ PAYER(e, pat)
∧ Obligation(e)=invoice
∧ INSTRUMENT(e, ⟨20, dollars⟩) ]
After e, the obligation is cleared. HAS(Recipient, ⟨n,U⟩) is not listed — that is payGIVE. Delivery of goods and settlement of a side bet are not defaults.
Voice filter · Payer
✓ Who paid the invoice?
✓ Pat / the escrow / payroll / the city paid the invoice. institutional payers pass
* Did the weather pay the invoice? not a Payer
Same weaker filter as payGIVE: systems can pay; they cannot blame. Weather fails proto-Agent.
LFG / HPSG / CCG: two PREDs for the two pay roots. On BILL, MeasureP is not OBJ; OBJ is the document. OBJ2 only on the DOC frame of GIVE.
Underivables (English)
- * Wasn’t twenty dollars paid the invoice? no DOC of money + bill
- * Pat paid the invoice Chris twenty dollars. four-place accident
- * Pat paid twenty dollars the invoice. money ≠ DOC Theme of BILL
- * Twenty was paid dollars the invoice. Amount ≠ separate promote
- * What did Pat pay twenty the invoice? no money+bill WH sisters
- * Did the weather pay the invoice? Voice filter
- * Pat paid Chris the invoice twenty dollars. invoice ≠ Theme₄ of GIVE
NegQ pointer · association sites
Negative questions on payBILL read the obligation geometry; they do not invent a fourth theta name of payGIVE. Neg sits high and associates downward. Cheap inner associate = the document. MeasureP stays instrument when present. No forced collapse of payment-true onto invoice-true.
English NegQ / WH–Neg core (from Negative_Questions_Pay §7)
✓ Didn’t Pat pay the invoice?
✓ Wasn’t the invoice paid?
✓ Didn’t Pat pay the invoice with twenty dollars / in dollars?
* Wasn’t twenty dollars paid the invoice?
✓ What didn’t Pat pay? the bill / the invoice
✓ How much rent didn’t they pay? border QP
Missing defaults on BILL: no forced payment-true of a silent twenty as e2; no goods-HAVE. Present default: invoice-clearance. A follow-up No — the twenty never left reports an implicature about means; No — the invoice is still open denies e2. Crossing into Didn’t Pat pay Chris twenty dollars? is a speaker swap to GIVE, not an inner reading of BILL.
Group A packaging · Japanese / Mandarin live; Navajo deferred
Group A keeps the BILL vs GIVE Case split under Neg. Japanese twin is live at payBILL · Japanese (seikyūsho-o harau): document ACC; *Double-o of bill + money; instrument de. Mandarin twin is live at payBILL · Mandarin (付账): document ACC / 把; *two-把 of bill + money; instrument 用. Navajo: predicted obligation word plus money stem or a single discharge stem — not two Patients; remains open/scout. Label speculation; do not fake elicitation.
Open items
- Border nouns (rent / tuition / fine). One MeasureP with sortal N, or documented coercion to payBILL. Speculative packaging, not a fifth slot.
- Japanese seikyūsho-o / yachin-o — live twin at pay-bill-ja.html. Further classifier-ride / border elicitation remains open.
- Mandarin 账单 / 把 / 用 — live twin at pay-bill-zh.html. Further classifier-ride / border elicitation remains open.
- Romance factura / facture / bolletta as ACC under pagar / payer / pagare, with MeasureP as con / avec / con. Companion of Group B packaging. spec
- Germanic betale regningen / die Rechnung bezahlen vs DOC-like GIVE frames. Same split under Neg. spec
- Outer CAUSE (make Pat pay the invoice). Site on the making vs on DISCHARGE; Consideration / instrument never becomes Causee Case under √PAY_BILL’s English cloth.
- pay attention / pay a visit / pay tribute — further roots; stay out of the commercial map except as distractors.
Corpus filenames
Primary extract for this micro-entry; companions supply NegQ baselines and Group A packaging. DOCX originals under the Tritransitive lit tree (lit/grok-tritransitive/files/). Text extracts used this tick under /tmp/pay-extracts/.
- Lexical_Entry_Pay_Argument_Structure.docx primary · §6 payBILL
- Negative_Questions_Pay.docx EN NegQ · §7 payBILL root
- Negative_Questions_Pay_GroupA_Contrast_Set.docx EN map; JA/ZH/NV BILL packaging
- DisneyPlus_Pay_in_Optional_Overt_Amount.docx optional in on bare U (GIVE companion)
- Harry_Pay_For_Clause_Free_Variation_Neg.docx for-clause variation companion
Series placement: lexical-entry sister of payGIVE; companion to sell, Transfer, deduct, chargeFEE, and remit/wire. Closes the obligation cell of the English payment split. Does not reopen Type A / Type B causation-chain papers. Does not invent cross-language elicitation.
Index 2 citations for this class
Payment citations from Index 2
| Code | Language | Index 2 citation | As printed |
| EN | English | pay, remit, wire, transfer | Vol. 3 |
| ES | Spanish | pagar, transferir, girar | Vol. 5 |
| FR | French | payer, virer, transférer | Vol. 5 |
| IT | Italian | pagare, bonificare, trasferire | Vol. 5 |
| HU | Hungarian | fizet, átutal | Vols. 3, 6 |
| BG | Bulgarian | плащам, превеждам | Vols. 3, 6 |
| PL | Polish | płacić / zapłacić, przelewać / przelać | Vols. 3, 6 |
| DE | German | bezahlen, überweisen | Vol. 7 |
| NL | Dutch | betalen, overmaken | Vol. 7 |
| NO | Norwegian | betale, overføre | Vol. 7 |
Languages Index 2 does not list for this class are left off the table. Non-English rows are class citations, not sense×language micro-entries. Index 2 does not split GIVE from BILL; the sense pages do.