Compare with…

Arguments

Intended labeling

√ASCRIBE + VoiceJ(Judge) + Charge + Target  ·  hierarchy Cognizer / Judge > Charge / Content > Target

Voice introduces Judge (proto-Agent of the attitude). The ascription relates Charge to Target under HOLD. English spells one productive verbal cloth: ACC Charge + to-Target. Institutions and author-metonymic documents can be Judge; weather cannot. Optional high Affectee / outer CAUSEG wrap Voice; they are not listed inner arguments.

Examples

One productive frame (to), plus passive rearrangements. Charge is the Case object; Target wears to. Cheap NegQ association and cheap WH track ACC = Charge. creditMERIT advertises a to/with flip; attribute does not — that packaging contrast is the English point of the deepen. XFER / FIN use related surface letters for MeasureP / Account — different roots; pointer only below.

✓ The board attributed the early completion to the contractor.

RolesHide roles JudgeChargeTarget
Judge The board Charge the early completion Target to the contractor

to-frame · ACC Charge · to-Target

✓ The report attributed the delay to the airline.

RolesHide roles JudgeChargeTarget
Judge The report Charge the delay Target to the airline

document-metonymy Judge · fine

✓ They attributed the delay to the weather.

RolesHide roles JudgeChargeTarget
Judge They Charge the delay Target to the weather

weather = Target OK

✓ The early completion was attributed to the contractor.

RolesHide roles ChargeTarget
Charge The early completion Target to the contractor

passive · Charge promoted

✓ Didn’t they attribute the early completion to the contractor?

RolesHide roles JudgeChargeTarget
Judge they Charge the early completion Target to the contractor

polar NegQ · to-frame

✓ They ascribed the delay to the airline.

RolesHide roles JudgeChargeTarget
Judge They Charge the delay Target to the airline

companion scout · Levin ascribe class

✓ The board attributed 30% of the savings to the contractor.

RolesHide roles JudgeChargeTarget
Judge The board Charge 30% of the savings Target to the contractor

quantified Charge · not XFER MeasureP

* The weather attributed the delay to the airline.

RolesHide roles JudgeChargeTarget
Judge The weather Charge the delay Target to the airline

weather as Judge

* The board attributed the contractor the early completion.

RolesHide roles JudgeDOC
Judge The board DOC the contractor the early completion

no DOC

* The board attributed the contractor with the early completion.

RolesHide roles JudgeTargetCharge
Judge The board Target the contractor Charge with the early completion

no creditMERIT with-cloth

* The board attributed the early completion on the contractor.

RolesHide roles JudgeChargeTarget
Judge The board Charge the early completion Target on the contractor

no blame on-cloth

* The board attributed the contractor for the early completion.

RolesHide roles JudgeTargetCharge
Judge The board Target the contractor Charge for the early completion

no blame for-cloth as productive ATT

* The board attributed the early completion of the contractor.

RolesHide roles JudgeChargeTarget
Judge The board Charge the early completion Target of the contractor

of ≠ English Target cloth

XFER pointer only, not an ATT cloth: The board attributed 0.3 ETH to each wallet. do not deepen

NegQ baseline · association tracks ACC (= Charge)

✓ Didn’t they attribute the early completion to the contractor? to-frame · cheap = Charge

✓ Wasn’t the early completion attributed to the contractor? passive Charge

✓ XFER contrast (pointer): Didn’t the board attribute 0.3 ETH to each wallet?

* Wasn’t the weather attributing the delay to anyone? weather as Judge under Neg

* Didn’t they attribute the contractor the early completion? no Neg-rescued DOC

* Didn’t they attribute the contractor with the early completion? no Neg-rescued with-frame

# Didn’t they attribute the early completion to the contractor — meaning the contractor didn’t cause it. cause-true not a default

A bare No on the canonical NegQ most readily challenges the ascription event or the ACC Charge. Challenging the to-Target wants that content already under discussion. Negation does not grow a double-object and does not create a with-frame or a MeasureP on ATT. HOLD is not cause-true — parallel to MERIT’s missing cause default and FIN’s missing payout default.

Notes

Working paper · September 2026 · English micro-entry · Attitude / ascribe content · Index 2

Attitude / ascribe-content sense in English. Working name √ASCRIBE. Hierarchy Cognizer / Judge > Charge / Content > Target. Productive Case cloth: Charge ACC + to-Target. No productive DOC, with-frame, for-frame, or on-frame (contrast creditMERIT’s to/with flip and blame’s for/on clothes). Same family as blame and creditMERIT; sense-split twin of attributeXFER. Mandarin twin live: attributeATT · 归因 / 归因于. Japanese twin live: attributeATT · 属性する. Spanish twin live: attributeATT · atribuir. French twin live: attributeATT · attribuer. Italian twin live: attributeATT · attribuire. No MeasureP, no HAVE, no SWAP.

Compare languages EN micro-entry live Index 2 Attitude ZH 归因 live JA 属性する live ES atribuir live FR attribuer live IT attribuire live DE zuschreiben live HU tulajdonít live NL toeschrijven live NO tilskrive live BG приписвам live PL przypisywać live NV deferred

Compare languages. Sense × language tick: attributeATT · English (deepened from shallow stub). Twins: Mandarin (归因 / 归因于) · Japanese (属性する) · Spanish (atribuir) · French (attribuer) · Italian (attribuire) · German (zuschreiben) · Hungarian (tulajdonít) · Dutch (toeschrijven) · Norwegian (tilskrive) · Bulgarian (приписвам) · Polish (przypisywać). Geometry neighbors: blame · creditMERIT · attributeXFER · assignASCRIBE · chargeACCUSE · creditFIN. Index 2 English Attitude cites blame, credit, attribute — Vols. 1, 3. Multi-sense lemma — sense as CAPS subscript, never concatenated attributeATT. Keep the ATT/XFER split.

Working paper. English micro-entry deepened from the thin stub to sprint depth, twin of live attribute-att-zh.html and attribute-att-ja.html. Geometry from Lexical_Entry_Attribute_Argument_Structure and Group A Larson shells; NegQ association maps from Negative_Questions_Attribute (chats 15 / 26). Constructed diagnostics diagnose the to-frame (Charge ACC / to-Target), Voice filter, missing with/DOC/for/on clothes, and the ATT / XFER root split; they are not spontaneous-speech citations. Mandarin and Japanese twins already live; Romance attributeATT and Navajo companions deferred.
Constructed examples. Frames below are packaging hypotheses aligned with the lexical entry, Group A shell plate, and NegQ Attribute paper. Cause-true and settlement are not entailed — same missing defaults as blame and creditMERIT. Do not fake elicitation. XFER / FIN strings appear only as contrast pointers.
Sense-class · ATT/XFER split. Index 2 lists English Attitude as blame, credit, attribute (Vols. 1, 3). This page deepens the ascribe-content reading of attribute as √ASCRIBE. The ledger / book-HAVE reading is a different root at attributeXFER (and neighbour creditFIN). Shared English phonology is the marked case — Groups A–D usually split the morphology (ZH 归因于 vs ledger 入账). Japanese attributeATT is 属性する.
Scout / deferred. Spanish atribuir ATT is live at attribute-att-es.html; French attribuer ATT is live at attribute-att-fr.html; Italian attribuire ATT is live at attribute-att-it.html. Navajo HANDLE packaging for Target shares Group A notes but is not a micro-entry this tick. Relative productivity of Levin ascribe-class companions (ascribe, impute) vs primary attribute is scout-leaning. No fake elicitation.

Hierarchy

Same inventory as Mandarin 归因于 and Japanese 属性する. Not five-place. Not four sisters of one V. Surface count can name the board, the early completion, the contractor, and an outer cause — but the lexicon does not list four co-arguments of √ASCRIBE.

No MeasureP on ATT. There is no verbal Amount+Denomination object unless Charge itself has been recoded as a quantified share (hybrid — flag, do not deepen as verbal MeasureP). Degrees that sneak in live on the Abney spine of Charge or of a light noun — Left Branch Condition for sell / pay / chargeFEE / creditFIN does not apply as a verbal diagnostic here.

Weather still satisfies Target and fails Judge. Cause-true is still not entailed. Charge and Target still do not invert at Transfer cost. Treating attributeATT as Agent > Theme > Goal, or collapsing it with attributeXFER because English spells both attribute, predicts a DOC, a HAVE entailment, a MeasureP LBC host, a productive with-frame, or a grammatical weather-as-Judge — none of those exist on ATT.

WH / NegQ diagnostics · no MeasureP LBC

Unlike sell / payGIVE / chargeFEE / bet / creditFIN, attributeATT has no verbal MeasureP. There is therefore no Left-Branch Condition of the Amount-from-Denomination type on √ASCRIBE. Degrees that appear are DP-internal on Charge or on a light noun.

  1. ✓ Who attributed the early completion to the contractor? WH = Judge
  2. ✓ What did the board attribute to the contractor? WH = Charge · to-frame
  3. ✓ Who did the board attribute the early completion to? WH = Target · stranded to
  4. ✓ What was attributed to the contractor? passive Charge
  5. ✓ How much of the delay did they attribute to the weather? degree on Charge · Abney-side, not verbal MeasureP
  6. * How much didn’t they attribute completion to the contractor? no verbal MeasureP LBC host on ATT
  7. ✓ They attributed the delay to the weather. weather = Target · fine
  8. * They made the weather attribute the delay to the airline. weather still not inner Judge under make

Superiority ranks Judge > ACC Charge > K-DP Target > outer. There is no ranking of Charge against a silent Purpose, Price, or Theme₂. Cheap NegQ association tracks the Case object (= Charge under the to-frame).

to-Target ≠ Goal HAVE · Charge ≠ FIN MeasureP

to Target = ascribee under HOLD — not sell Recipient HAVE, not allocate Goal with optional HAVE, not FIN wallet / Account. Charge = content of the attitude — not ledger Amount, not sell Price, not pay Consideration. Chat 15 / 26: Chinese 把 fronts Charge of ATT or MeasureP of XFER — same 把, different object under 没; English keeps the ATT/XFER split by root, not by particle letter alone.

Geometry · attributeATT ≠ attributeXFER ≠ creditMERIT ≠ blame ≠ sell

In The board attributed the early completion to the contractor, the board holds that the early completion is ascribable to the contractor. That is ascription, not HAVE of goods and not ledger INCREMENT. The early completion is Charge. The contractor is Target. HOLD is an attitude; cause-true is not a presupposed fact.

  • ≠ attributeXFER / creditFIN. Same surface family of “attribute” talk; different root. XFER / FIN write MeasureP TO a Domain / Account (The board attributed 0.3 ETH to each wallet). ATT has no MeasureP and no Account. Collapsing them because both can sit next to English attribute / to is the error the lexical entry was written to block. XFER stays at attribute-xfer.html; FIN at credit-fin.html — pointer only this tick for ledger strings.
  • ≠ English DOC / Transfer invert. There is no productive *attributed the contractor the early completion. Negation does not rescue it. Transfer Themes invert under Romance swap NegQ; ATT Charge and Target do not.
  • ≠ creditMERIT packaging merge. Shared √ASCRIBE family and shared Voice filter; creditMERIT writes positive / meritorious polarity and a productive with-frame (Target ACC / with-Charge). Attribute keeps the to-frame only — Charge ACC / to-Target — and does not advertise the MERIT with-flip. Polarity on ATT is more neutral / content-ascribe than MERIT’s positive HOLD.
  • ≠ blame / √ASCRIBE_FAULT. Blame ascribes fault; attribute ascribes content (polarity open). Blame’s ACC is typically Target (blame the contractor for the delay); attribute’s ACC is Charge (attribute the delay to the contractor). Blame has for/on clothes English attribute lacks as productive ATT clothes.
  • ≠ sell / ApplHAVE / allocateGOAL. No ApplHAVE, no for-Price MeasureP, no optional HAVE Goal. Surface to on ATT is Target wrapper-K, not Goal address with MeasureP Theme.
  • Missing defaults. Cause-true and settlement are not entailed. Didn’t they attribute the early completion to the contractor? is compatible with the contractor not in fact causing the early completion.

Mandarin twin spells Charge under 把 / post-V and Target in 于 (归因于). Japanese twin is 属性する. No 属性する sentence is printed here. English twin: to-frame Charge ACC / Target to. Weather OK as Target, *not* as Judge. Document-metonymy Judge OK.

Shells, ApplP, and Case

Base tree (ascribe-content · English clothes)

to-frame:
VoiceP  [ JudgeNOM
  vP / √ASCRIBE
    ACC               Charge
    PP_to             Target ]

*with-frame (unavailable on ATT):
VoiceP  [ JudgeNOM
  vP / √ASCRIBE
    ACC               Target
    PP_with           Charge ]   ← productive on creditMERIT; * on attributeATT

English ATT never assigns four structural Cases. Charge is ACC; Target wears P. No low ApplHAVE. No low ApplSWAP. No ApplTASK. No MeasureP (unless quantified-Charge hybrid — flag). High Appl / Affectee is extra when present and is not a listed argument of √ASCRIBE.

Composition is V(DP) on the ACC Charge. To is wrapper-K on the Abney spine (lexical entry §6.4): V(DP), not V(to(DP)). Early completion does not travel a path; the contractor is not a Goal with HAVE rights.

Outer CAUSEG (they made the board attribute the delay to the weather) wraps Voice. The causee, not the weather, is the Judge. *They made the weather attribute the delay to the airline keeps the inner Voice filter. Type A climbing unions Voice domains; Charge stays content and never climbs as a dative MeasureP.

Omission does not demote Charge to a pure adjunct. Selected P-layers are optional in the numeration; they are still arguments when present. The diagnostic is participanthood under Case, binding, and WH — not omitability. Charge clauses are islands in a way rationale adjuncts are not; there is no Neg-raising out of Charge.

Type A · make wrap

✓ Didn’t they make the board attribute the early completion to the contractor? outer Neg denies causing

* They made the weather attribute the delay to the airline. weather still not inner Judge

Attribute Group A Larson shell plate: ascription geometry with Judge, Charge, and Target, across the Group A languages.
Attribute Group A Larson shells. Read as attributeATT (ascription). attributeXFER is a different root and is not this drawing. The figure is not re-derived in prose here.

Underivables (English ATT)

  1. * The weather attributed the delay to the airline. weather / inanimate as Judge
  2. * Wasn’t the weather attributing the delay to anyone? Voice filter survives Neg
  3. * They made the weather attribute the delay to the airline. CAUSEG wrap does not wash Voice filter
  4. * The board attributed the contractor the early completion. no productive DOC
  5. * What did the board attribute the contractor? missing DOC under WH
  6. * The board attributed the contractor with the early completion. no with-frame
  7. * How much didn’t they attribute completion to the contractor? no verbal MeasureP LBC host on ATT
  8. * The board attributed the early completion on the contractor. no blame on-cloth
  9. * They swapped the contractor for the early completion. SWAP cloth ≠ ascribe-content
  10. ✓ weather as Target: They attributed the delay to the weather. inanimate Target fine
  11. ✓ document Judge: The report attributed the delay to the airline. metonymy Judge fine

Groups A–D packaging · this tick English deepen

English micro-entry (deepened stub). Mandarin and Japanese Group A twins are live. Brief pointers only:

  • Group A. Mandarin live at attribute-att-zh.html (归因 / 归因于; 把 Charge; 于 Target; companions 归功于 / 归咎于 scout). Japanese live at attribute-att-ja.html (属性する. No 属性する sentence is elicited.). Navajo: scout — HANDLE packaging for Target, not Judge. Keep ATT/XFER split against ZH ledger and JA 計上 / 付与.
  • Group B. Romance usually lists atribuir / attribuer / attribuire under Attitude in Index 2 without an ATT/XFER split on the inventory line. MERIT Romance twins are already live under credit; Spanish attributeATT is live at attribute-att-es.html; French attributeATT is live at attribute-att-fr.html; IT ATT live at attribute-att-it.html.
  • Group C. Hungarian Focus+nem and Polish GEN-neg predicted to treat MeasureP as Incremental (XFER/FIN) and Charge as content (ATT). Elicited paradigms remain open.
  • Group D. German already names ascribe vs ledger letters (zuschreiben vs gutschreiben / book); DE attributeATT micro-entry live (keep ATT/MERIT split vs MERIT DE). Dutch MERIT is live at credit-merit-nl.html and Dutch ATT is live at attribute-att-nl.html (shared toeschrijven; keep the split). Norwegian follows the same split.

Open items

  • Romance / Navajo micro-entries. Same Group A / B geometry; a/à Target clothes and HANDLE packaging. Deferred — do not invent depth this tick.
  • Levin ascribe-class companions. ascribe, impute — same √ASCRIBE family; productivity ranking vs attribute is scout.
  • Quantified-Charge hybrid. attributed 30% of the savings to the contractor — Charge recoded as quantified share. Diagnostics: replaceable by ascribe, not by wire; weather can wear the to-DP; the board can be wrong. Flagged, not deepened as verbal MeasureP on plain ATT.
  • Type A make + attributeATT. Outer CAUSE wraps a Judge event. Outer Neg can be cheap on the causing; the inner Voice filter survives. Not a new elicitation.
  • XFER English. Remains at attribute-xfer.html. Keep the split; do not merge pages.
  • creditMERIT with-frame contrast. Already live; do not import with-frame acceptability onto ATT.

Corpus filenames

Primary extract for this micro-entry is Lexical_Entry_Attribute_Argument_Structure (English snapshot · √ASCRIBE vs XFER). NegQ association maps from Negative_Questions_Attribute. Group A shell plate: Attribute_GroupA_Larson_Shells. Chat packaging: Tritransitive chats 15 (NegQ on attribute · ATT vs XFER · Chinese 把) and 26 (attribute argument-structure). Twin geometry shared with Mandarin and Japanese Group A remainder.

Series placement: English sense×language twin of Mandarin 归因于 and Japanese 属性する. Feeds Attitude / Evaluation Index 2 and the ascribe-content cell next to creditMERIT / blame. Keeps XFER at attributeXFER. Does not invent Romance/NV elicitation. Speculation flagged.

Index 2 citations for this class

Attitude / Evaluation citations from Index 2
CodeLanguageIndex 2 citationAs printed
ENEnglishblame EN micro-entry, creditMERIT EN micro-entry, attributeATT EN micro-entryVols. 1, 3
ESSpanishculpar ES micro-entry, creditMERIT · acreditar ES micro-entry, attributeATT · atribuir ES micro-entryVols. 3, 5
FRFrenchblâmer FR micro-entry, creditMERIT · attribuer FR micro-entry, attribuerVols. 3, 5
ITItalianincolpare IT micro-entry, creditMERIT · attribuire IT micro-entry, attributeATT · attribuire IT micro-entryVols. 3, 5
HUHungarianhibáztat, okol, tulajdonít, elismer, jóváír · blame · hibáztat / okol HU micro-entry · attributeATT · tulajdonít HU micro-entry · creditMERIT · elismer HU micro-entryVols. 3, 6
BGBulgarianобвинявам / виня, приписвам / отдавам · attributeATT · приписвам BG micro-entryVols. 3, 6
PLPolishobwiniać / winić, przypisywać · attributeATT · przypisywać PL micro-entryVols. 3, 6
DEGermanbeschuldigen, verantwortlich machen, zuschreiben · blame · beschuldigen / verantwortlich machen DE micro-entry · attributeATT · zuschreiben DE micro-entry · creditMERIT · zuschreiben DE micro-entryVol. 7
NLDutchde schuld geven, toeschrijven · blame · de schuld geven NL micro-entry · creditMERIT · toeschrijven NL micro-entry · attributeATT · toeschrijven NL micro-entryVol. 7
NONorwegianlegge skylden på · blame · legge skylden på NO micro-entryVol. 7

Languages Index 2 does not list for this class are left off the table. Mandarin and Japanese ATT sit Beyond Index 2 (no Attitude ZH/JA cell) at attribute-att-zh.html and attribute-att-ja.html.