Compare with…

Arguments

Intended labeling (shared with English · Bulgarian cloth)

√ASCRIBE_FAULT + VoiceJ(Judge) + Target + Charge  ·  hierarchy Judge > Target > Charge (1+2)

Voice introduces Judge (proto-Agent of the attitude). The ascription relates Target to Charge. Bulgarian spells the productive cloth as a direct-object Target plus a Charge PP or CP — обвинявам някого за нещо, обвинявам някого в нещо, виня някого за нещо, and виня / обвинявам някого, че…. The object изпълнителя is visibly the direct object (short article), not a на-phrase. Accusative го resumes that Target. Dative му is not blame’s Target; му is the dative Target of приписвам. Charge wears за, or в on обвинявам, or a CP under bare че. Light-noun вина / обвинение is scout packaging of the same ascription, not a second root. Optional high Affectee / outer CAUSE wrap Voice; they are not listed inner arguments.

Examples

Group C packages ascribe-fault without a productive DOC and without nominal case. Productive cloth: Target = direct object, Charge in за (both lemmas; the event, often definite), in в (обвинявам’s fault-type nominal, often article-less), or under bare че. Overlap of за and в on обвинявам is not ranked as exclusive. в on виня is not filed as productive. Cheap NegQ association and cheap WH track the direct-object Target, or the preposition / complementizer that hosts Charge. ATT keeps the direct object on Charge and DAT/на on Target. Clitic doubling is one Target: го plus изпълнителя is not a second argument and not a DOC.

  1. ✓ Комисията обвинява изпълнителя за закъснението. ipfv lemma · direct object = Target · за = event Charge
  2. ✓ Комисията обвини изпълнителя за закъснението. aorist обвини · same root · string already on the ATT page
  3. ✓ Винят изпълнителя за закъснението. ipfv виня · direct object = Target · за · string already on the ATT page
  4. ✓ Обвиняват изпълнителя в закъснение. в · fault-type Charge · article-less · обвинявам cloth · not Polish o
  5. ✓ Обвиняват го в небрежност. в + fault-type · го = Target
  6. ✓ Винят го, че влакът е закъснял. bare че · clausal Charge · no correlative to
  7. ✓ Обвиняват го, че влакът е закъснял. bare че on обвинявам · same CP Charge
  8. # Обвиняват го за това, че влакът е закъснял. optional correlative under за · same Charge · not required · not Polish za to, że as the default
  9. # Обвиняват го в това, че е закъснял. optional correlative under в · обвинявам only · not a fourth argument
  10. # Винят изпълнителя в закъснение. в is not the productive виня cloth · do not rank
  11. ✓ Докладът обвини изпълнителя за закъснението. document-metonymy Judge · fine
  12. ✓ Винят лошото време за закъснението. weather = Target OK · neuter object
  13. ✓ Обвиняват лошото време в закъснение. weather = Target · в cloth
  14. ✓ Изпълнителят беше обвинен за закъснението. passive promotes Target · subject article · Charge stays in за
  15. ✓ Лошото време беше обвинено в закъснение. passive · weather Target · neuter participle
  16. ✓ Обвиниха изпълнителя за закъснението. 3pl · named Judge suppressed · not a new argument
  17. ✓ Обвиниха го за закъснението. го = Target · not DAT му
  18. ✓ Комисията го обвини изпълнителя за закъснението. clitic doubling · one Target · not a DOC
  19. ✓ Обвиниха го изпълнителя за закъснението. verb-initial host · clitic then doubled DP · still one Target
  20. ✓ Не обвиниха ли изпълнителя за закъснението? не … ли · association tracks Target · Charge stays in за
  21. ✓ Не го ли винят за закъснението? го = Target under не · no GEN rewrite
  22. ✓ Не за закъснението ли винят изпълнителя? ли on the за-phrase · Charge-focus
  23. ✓ Light-noun scout: Вината на изпълнителя беше оспорена. на unresolved · possessor of вина or ATT-like Target · no GEN/DAT split · do not rank
  24. ✓ Light-noun scout: Обвинението в закъснение беше оспорено. в continues the fault-type Charge · neuter
  25. # Light-noun scout: Обвинението срещу изпълнителя беше оспорено. срещу · not a verbal frame of виня · not elicited
  26. # Onto-geometry scout: Хвърлиха вината върху изпълнителя. object = вината · върху = Target · not the verbal обвинявам cloth · not elicited
  27. ✓ ATT contrast (live): Съветът приписа закъснението на изпълнителя. ATT · ACC = Charge · на = Target · attribute-att-bg
  28. ✓ ATT contrast: Приписаха му закъснението. му = DAT Target of приписвам · not blame’s го
  29. ✓ FIN contrast (live): Не записаха ли 0,3 ETH по сметката? measuring QP stays a direct object under не · no GEN-neg host · записа · not blame’s Target
  30. * Лошото време обвини изпълнителя за закъснението. weather as Judge
  31. * Обвиниха изпълнителя закъснението. no productive DOC (object Target + object Charge)
  32. * Обвиниха му закъснението. DAT Target + object Charge is ATT cloth, not blame
  33. * Обвиниха закъснението на изпълнителя. object Charge + на Target ≠ blame
  34. * Винят изпълнителя със закъснението. no with-frame / с as productive blame
  35. * Обвиниха изпълнителя върху закъснението. върху is not the Charge P

NegQ baseline · не … ли · association tracks Target (direct object), not Charge

✓ Не обвиниха ли изпълнителя за закъснението? cheap = Target · association not rewritten

✓ Не го ли винят за закъснението? го = Target · за = Charge

✓ Обвиниха ли изпълнителя за закъснението? polar ли · no contrastive focus

✓ Не в закъснение ли го обвиняват? ли on the в-phrase · Charge-focus · го still Target

✓ ATT contrast (pointer): Не приписаха ли закъснението на изпълнителя? ATT keeps the direct object on Charge under не

✓ FIN contrast (live): Не записаха ли 0,3 ETH по сметката? MeasureP has no genitive to fall into · credit-fin-bg.html

* Лошото време не обвини ли изпълнителя за закъснението? weather as Judge under Neg

* Не обвиниха ли изпълнителя закъснението? no Neg-rescued DOC

* Не му ли обвиниха закъснението? Neg does not install ATT’s dative Target

# Не винят ли лошото време за закъснението? — meaning the weather didn’t cause it. cause-true not a default

A bare не on the canonical NegQ most readily challenges the ascription event or the direct-object Target. Challenging the Charge wants the за / в phrase, or the clause under че, already in the associate, with ли on that phrase when the focus is the Charge. Negation does not grow a double-object, does not move Charge into the object slot, does not turn Target into the dative of приписвам, and does not produce a genitive — there is no nominal genitive to produce. HOLD is not cause-true. The Polish note “GEN-neg off on Charge unless Charge is a QP” names a host Bulgarian does not have. A measuring QP is a FIN/deduct object, not this verb’s Charge. The unambiguous direct object in the diagnostic is изпълнителя / лошото време, resumed by го.

Notes

Working paper · October 2026 · Bulgarian micro-entry · Attitude / ascribe fault · Index 2 · Group C Inner European

Attitude / ascribe-fault sense in Bulgarian. Working name √ASCRIBE_FAULT. Hierarchy Judge > Target > Charge (1+2). Same inventory as English blame, the Romance twins, Japanese 責める, Mandarin 怪 / 责备, and Polish obwiniać / winić. Single-sense lemma — no sense subscript on the headword. Index 2 Bulgarian Attitude cites обвинявам / виня, приписвам / отдавам — this page deepens imperfective обвинявам / виня as fault-ascribe. Productive cloth: the direct-object slot is Target (full DP after the verb; accusative clitics го / я / ги). Nominal case is gone, so “ACC” is that slot, not a noun ending. Charge is not a second object. It sits in за (both lemmas; event, often definite — the cloth already printed on attributeATT · Bulgarian), in в (fault-type nominal on обвинявам; not the productive виня cloth), or in a bare че-clause. That trio is not Polish za / o / za to, że: there is no o+ACC Charge letter, and bare че does not need a correlative to. Optional за това, че / в това, че repackages the same clause; it is not required. Critical contrast: live приписвам has ACC = Charge and Target as pronominal dative му / ѝ / им and/or на. Blame’s го is not that му. Clitic doubling writes one Target twice. No DOC, no verbal MeasureP, no HAVE, no SWAP. Bulgarian has no genitive of negation: не does not rewrite the Target/Charge association and has no GEN host to rewrite. Voice filter. Cause-true and settlement are not entailed. отдавам stays the ATT-page scout, not a merit root. No credit-merit-bg.html. Continues Group C blame after Polish; Hungarian hibáztat / okol is now live and closes the group.

BG micro-entry live Index 2 Attitude Group C Inner European EN blame live ES culpar live FR blâmer live IT incolpare live JA 責める live ZH 怪 live PL obwiniać live HU hibáztat live ATT BG приписвам live NV deferred

Sense × language tick: blame · Bulgarian (обвинявам / виня). Twins: English blame · Spanish (culpar) · French (blâmer) · Italian (incolpare) · Japanese (責める) · Mandarin (怪 / 责备) · Polish (obwiniać / winić). Geometry neighbors: attributeATT · приписвам (ACC = Charge) · отдавам scout on that page, not MERIT · assignASCRIBE · chargeACCUSE · attributeXFER / creditFIN · записа. MERIT prose pointer only (no credit-merit-bg.html). Index 2 Bulgarian Attitude cites обвинявам / виня, приписвам / отдавам — Vols. 3, 6. Single-sense lemma — plain headword, never blameASCRIBE. Keep blame / ATT / MERIT / FIN split explicit.

Working paper. Bulgarian micro-entry for Index 2 Attitude fault-ascribe, beside live attributeATT · приписвам. Geometry from Lexical_Entry_Blame_Argument_Structure; NegQ maps from Negative_Questions_Blame (chats 13 / 22) and the Group C note that Bulgarian WH clusters front together and do not split an Amount from a unit — blame has no Amount. The live ATT page is the Case contrast: приписвам ACC = Charge + DAT/на Target; обвинявам / виня direct object = Target. Its contrast strings already print за. в and bare че are the other ordinary clothes of these lemmas; they are not Polish o and not za to, że, and they are not attested as strings on the ATT page. Constructed diagnostics diagnose those clothes, clitic doubling as one Target, light-noun вина / обвинение (на does not split possessor from Target), and the missing DOC / MeasureP / HAVE / SWAP / GEN-neg. They are working-paper hypotheses, not spontaneous-speech citations and not fake elicitation. English, Spanish, French, Italian, Japanese, Mandarin, and Polish blame twins already live. There is no Bulgarian MERIT page. Navajo stays deferred.
Constructed examples. Frames below are packaging hypotheses aligned with the lexical entry, the Blame NegQ paper, and the strings already used as contrast on attribute-att-bg.html (Комисията обвини изпълнителя за закъснението; Винят изпълнителя за закъснението). в and bare че are added here as the clothes those two strings do not show. Cause-true and settlement are not entailed — same missing defaults as English blame and Bulgarian ATT. Do not fake elicitation. Completed-event strings may use aorist обвини / обвиниха of the same root; the Index 2 lemma remains imperfective обвинявам. виня is shown in the present (винят). Do not file a separate perfective of виня. XFER stays a contrast pointer. FIN is live at credit-fin-bg.html and is not an Index 2 Attitude form. Masculine definites keep the object article (изпълнителя) apart from the subject article (изпълнителят).
Sense-class · blame / ATT / MERIT / XFER split (Index 2 line). Index 2 lists Bulgarian Attitude as обвинявам / виня, приписвам / отдавам (Vols. 3, 6). This page deepens the ascribe-fault reading of обвинявам / виня as √ASCRIBE_FAULT. A legal / speech-act lean of обвинявам stays on this root; it is not a second sense and not a Bulgarian chargeACCUSE page. Bare приписвам is content-ascribe at attribute-att-bg.html (ACC = Charge). отдавам is the alternate ascribe already scouted there — not MERIT. No credit-merit-bg.html exists; do not invent that link. Ledger / book-HAVE readings sit at attributeXFER and live creditFIN · записа.
Scout / deferred. Light-noun вина / обвинение / обвиняване is scout-leaning. на on вината на изпълнителя does not spell a possessor apart from an ATT Target — Bulgarian has no nominal GEN vs DAT. Flag it; do not rank it. върху onto-geometry (хвърлям вината върху) and срещу on обвинение are scout, not verbal frames of виня, and not elicited. в on виня is not treated as productive. Reflexive виня се corefers Judge and Target; it is not the periphrastic passive. Navajo HANDLE packaging is deferred. No fake elicitation.

Hierarchy

Same inventory as English blame, Spanish culpar, French blâmer, Italian incolpare, Japanese 責める, Mandarin 怪 / 责备, and Polish obwiniać / winić. Not five-place. Not four sisters of one V. Surface count can name the board, the weather, the delay, and an outer cause — but the lexicon does not list four co-arguments of √ASCRIBE_FAULT.

No MeasureP. There is no verbal Amount+Denomination object. Degrees that sneak in (каква част от вината, a partitive on the light noun) live on the Abney spine of that noun — Left Branch Condition for sell / payGIVE / chargeFEE / creditFIN does not apply as a verbal diagnostic here. Group C Polish GEN-neg rewrites MeasureP of FIN/deduct. Bulgarian has no nominal genitive, so there is nothing for не to rewrite the Target into, and nothing that would move Charge into the object slot. The working-paper NegQ keeps the direct object on Target, parallel to ATT Charge staying the direct object under не on attribute-att-bg.html. That is packaging. It is not an elicited denial of a genitive Bulgarian no longer has.

What Group C changes for Bulgarian blame is the direct-object Target against DAT/на on the ATT twin, the за / в / bare че Charge clothes (not Polish za / o / za to, że), clitic doubling of one Target, the unresolved на on the light noun, and multiple-WH fronting as an open packaging flag. What it does not change is the inventory. Weather still satisfies Target and fails Judge. Cause-true is still not entailed. Target and Charge still do not invert at Transfer cost. Treating blame as Agent > Theme > Goal, collapsing it with приписвам because both sit on the Index 2 line, inventing a merit page, or collapsing it with XFER/FIN because a ledger can also name an account, predicts a DOC, a HAVE entailment, a MeasureP LBC host, or a grammatical weather-as-Judge — none of those exist on blame.

WH / NegQ diagnostics · cluster note · no MeasureP LBC

Unlike sell / payGIVE / chargeFEE / bet / creditFIN, blame has no verbal MeasureP. There is therefore no Left-Branch Condition of the Amount-from-Denomination type on √ASCRIBE_FAULT. The Group C remark that Bulgarian WH clusters do not split Amount from unit (the same packaging note used beside таксувам / обвинявам on fee-levy) has nothing to split here. Degrees that appear are DP-internal on the light noun вина. не does not rewrite the Target/Charge association. ATT’s parallel, on the live twin, is that Charge stays the direct object under не.

  1. ✓ Кой обвини изпълнителя за закъснението? WH = Judge
  2. ✓ Кого обвиниха за закъснението? WH = Target · animate direct object · кого not на кого
  3. ✓ За какво винят изпълнителя? WH = Charge · за
  4. ✓ В какво обвиниха изпълнителя? WH = Charge · в · обвинявам
  5. ✓ Кого не обвиниха за закъснението? WH–Neg Target · association not flipped onto Charge
  6. ✓ За какво не винят изпълнителя? WH–Neg Charge · P fronts with the WH
  7. ✓ Кой беше обвинен за закъснението? passive · Target promoted
  8. ✓ Кого обвиниха за закъснението? 3pl · Target WH · named Judge absent
  9. ✓ Каква част от вината хвърлиха върху времето? degree on light noun · Abney-side · onto-geometry scout · not verbal MeasureP
  10. * Колко не обвиниха изпълнителя от закъснението? no verbal MeasureP LBC host
  11. * Какво обвиниха изпълнителя? bare Charge WH · missing DOC
  12. * На кого обвиниха закъснението? на кого is ATT’s Target WH, not blame’s
  13. * За кого винят закъснението? за кого is not the Target WH (кого is)
  14. ✓ Cluster hypothesis: Кой кого за какво обвини? Group C multiple-WH fronting · not a ranked elicitation
  15. ✓ Cluster hypothesis: Кой кого в какво обвини? same cluster · в cloth · not elicited
  16. ✓ Винят лошото време за закъснението. weather = Target · fine
  17. * Лошото време кого обвини за закъснението? weather still not Judge

The shared hierarchy ranks Judge > direct-object Target > PP/CP Charge > outer. Bulgarian multiple-WH fronting is a packaging note on that hierarchy (Group C cluster), not a fourth sister and not an elicited superiority paradigm. There is no ranking of Target against a silent Purpose, Price, or Theme₂. Cheap NegQ association tracks the direct-object Target. Productive Target WH is кого (animate) — not на кого and not кому, which are ATT’s dative slot (кому formal, same ATT slot, already flagged on the ATT page). Productive Charge WH is за какво / в какво, not bare какво and not на кого.

Direct-object Target ≠ ATT Charge · PP/CP Charge ≠ FIN MeasureP · ≠ merit root

Blame’s direct object is the ascribee under HOLD — not sell Theme, not ATT Charge, not FIN Amount. Charge in за / в / че is the content of the fault — not ledger Amount, not sell Price, not pay Consideration. ATT’s direct object is Charge and ATT’s Target is DAT/на (приписа закъснението на изпълнителя; приписаха му закъснението). Index 2 does not print a Bulgarian merit root; отдавам is the ascribe companion, scouted on the ATT page. Do not invent a merit page. Group C: Polish GEN-neg rewrites MeasureP of FIN/deduct; Bulgarian blame keeps the Target/Charge association, keeps го on Target under не, and does not put the Charge in the object slot. Same на letters can show up next to a ledger account — different object.

Geometry · blame ≠ приписвам ≠ отдавам-as-MERIT ≠ attributeXFER ≠ sell

In Комисията обвинява изпълнителя за закъснението, the board holds that the contractor is responsible for the delay. That is ascription of fault, not HAVE of goods and not ledger INCREMENT. The contractor is Target. The delay is Charge. HOLD is an attitude; cause-true is not a presupposed fact.

  • ≠ attributeATT · приписвам. Shared Index 2 line, opposite object. Blame’s direct object is Target (обвини изпълнителя за закъснението; винят изпълнителя за закъснението; обвиняват изпълнителя в закъснение). Attribute’s direct object is Charge and its Target is DAT/на (приписа закъснението на изпълнителя; приписаха му закъснението). Blame’s за / в are not productive ATT frames — the ATT page already rejects за and върху on приписвам. ATT’s dative is not a productive blame Target. Collapsing them because both can sit next to на изпълнителя ignores the cloth: that на is ATT’s Target, or an unresolved possessor on вина, while blame’s object is изпълнителя resumed by го.
  • ≠ Polish za / o / za to, że copied onto these lemmas. Polish obwiniać / winić is live and shares the hierarchy and the ACC-Target idea, with real accusative morphology. Bulgarian Charge letters are за and в, plus bare че. There is no o+ACC vs o+LOC cut, and no required correlative to. в is обвинявам’s fault-type P; it is not the twin of Polish o on obwiniać, and it is not filed on виня. Clitic doubling and the missing genitive are Bulgarian, not Polish.
  • ≠ MERIT and ≠ отдавам deepened as MERIT. Opposite polarity of merit in other languages. Bulgarian has no live MERIT micro-entry. Do not invent credit-merit-bg.html. отдавам нещо на някого is the Index 2 companion and an alternate ascribe cloth, already scouted on the ATT page. Do not import it as the default blame cloth and do not open a second sense page for it here.
  • ≠ attributeXFER / creditFIN. Ledger MeasureP / Account is a different root. Не записаха ли 0,3 ETH по сметката? is live at credit-fin-bg.html, a measuring object that stays a direct object under не, not an Index 2 Attitude citation. Blame has no MeasureP and no Account. XFER stays at attribute-xfer.html.
  • ≠ English DOC / Transfer invert. There is no productive *обвинявам някого нещо. Negation does not rescue it. Transfer Themes invert under swap NegQ; blame Target and Charge do not. English for-frame (object Target) is the nearer cloth; English on-frame (object Charge) is not the Bulgarian verbal default. Onto-geometry, if it is real, lives on the light noun (вината върху), scout only. The ATT page already rejects върху as an ATT frame.
  • ≠ sell / ApplHAVE / allocateGOAL. No ApplHAVE, no Price MeasureP, no optional HAVE Goal. The direct object is Target of an attitude, not goods that change hands. Surface на on the ATT twin is Target Case, not a Goal address.
  • ≠ light-noun collapse. вината на изпълнителя does not spell GEN possessor apart from DAT Target. приписаха вината на изпълнителя is the ATT verb with вина as Charge-type object — pointed on the ATT page’s geometry, not a blame direct object. обвинение в continues the fault-type Charge. срещу and върху are scout clothes of the noun, not of виня.
  • Missing defaults. Cause-true and settlement are not entailed. Не винят ли лошото време за закъснението? is compatible with the weather not in fact causing the delay.

English twin spells for-frame object Target / for-Charge, and on-frame object Charge / on-Target. Spanish twin: a-Target / de-Charge. French twin: object Target / pour-Charge. Italian twin: object Target / di-Charge. Japanese twin: object Target under 責める; ni Target under light-noun; de / no sei-de Charge. Mandarin twin: Target post-V or 把-fronted; Charge via 因为. Polish twin: morphological ACC Target; Charge za / o / za to, że; GEN-neg does not rewrite the association. Bulgarian twin: direct-object Target; Charge за / в / bare че; clitic го doubles that Target; no DOC and no GEN-neg. Weather OK as Target, not as Judge. Document-metonymy Judge OK.

Shells, ApplP, and Case

Base tree (ascribe-fault · Bulgarian clothes)

productive cloth (обвинявам / виня някого за/в/че):
VoiceP  [ Judge
  vP / √ASCRIBE_FAULT
    direct object     Target     ← изпълнителя / го / лошото време
    PP_за             Charge     ← both lemmas; event
    PP_в              Charge     ← обвинявам fault-type; not productive on виня
    CP_че             Charge ]   ← bare clause; no required correlative
                                   not a DOC, not DAT Target

clitic doubling (still one Target):
    ACC_clitic        Target     ← го / я / ги
    direct object     Target     ← not a second argument

*ATT cloth (live on attribute-att-bg · unavailable as blame):
VoiceP  [ Judge
  vP / √ASCRIBE
    direct object     Charge
    DAT / PP_на       Target ]   ← приписвам нещо на някого / му

optional correlative (same Charge, not required):
    PP_за/в + това + CP_че

Light-noun scout (на not split):
DP  [ N / вина
    PP_на             possessor or Target ]  ← flag, do not rank
DP  [ N / обвинение
    PP_в              Charge ]
onto / against scout (not elicited):
    direct object     вината
    PP_върху          Target
    PP_срещу          Target-like   ← on обвинение, not on виня

passive (promotes Target):
VoiceP  [ Target
  vP / √ASCRIBE_FAULT
    PP_за/в         Charge ]

Bulgarian blame never assigns four structural Cases, and it does not assign a nominal accusative or dative ending. Target is the direct object. Charge wears за, в (on обвинявам), or a CP under че. Doubling writes that one Target twice. No low ApplHAVE. No low ApplSWAP. No ApplTASK. No MeasureP. High Appl / Affectee is extra when present and is not a listed argument of √ASCRIBE_FAULT. Aorist обвини is not a second root on this tree. виня is the other Index 2 imperfective, not a second sense. отдавам is not on this tree.

Composition is V(DP) on the direct-object Target. The P on Charge is clothing the DP wears (K on the Abney spine, or a selected relational P that does not add a fourth verbal argument). V(за(DP)) and V(в(DP)) are the wrong composition — same wrapper-K cut as English for. The че-clause is a CP argument, not a rationale adjunct and not a second object. A correlative това is a host for that same CP; it is not a new theta role. The accusative clitic is a spell-out of the same Target, hosted before the finite verb when something precedes it (Комисията го обвини…) and after a verb-initial host (Обвиниха го…). Clitic position is not a new argument. That is the same cluster fact the ATT page states for му, on a different Case.

Pronoun height: го / я / ги resume Target; му / ѝ / им do not. Inanimate Target is fine. Inanimate subject as Judge is not generated — that is the Voice filter, not a Case accident. Passive promotes Target (беше обвинен). It does not promote Charge into a subject that still takes a bare object Target. 3pl обвиниха can suppress a named Judge; it does not add an argument. Reflexive се on виня се corefers Judge and Target. It is not the periphrastic passive and not a demoted external Judge.

Outer CAUSE wraps Voice. The causee, not the weather, is the Judge. Weather still fails as inner Judge under the wrap. There is no Neg-raising out of Charge.

Omission does not demote Charge to a pure adjunct. Selected P-layers and the че-clause are optional in the numeration; they are still arguments when present. The diagnostic is participanthood under the object slot, binding, and WH — not omitability. Charge clauses are islands in a way rationale adjuncts are not.

Outer cause · Voice filter survives

✓ Не накараха ли съвета да обвини изпълнителя за закъснението? outer Neg denies causing · object causee = inner Judge · constructed

* Не накараха ли лошото време да обвини изпълнителя за закъснението? weather still not inner Judge

* Закъснението беше обвинено изпълнителя. passive does not promote Charge

Underivables (Bulgarian blame)

  1. * Лошото време обвини изпълнителя за закъснението. weather / inanimate as Judge
  2. * Лошото време не обвини ли изпълнителя за закъснението? Voice filter survives Neg
  3. * Не накараха ли лошото време да обвини изпълнителя за закъснението? CAUSE wrap does not wash Voice filter
  4. * Обвиниха изпълнителя закъснението. no productive DOC
  5. * Какво обвиниха изпълнителя? as DOC under WH missing DOC under WH
  6. * Обвиниха му закъснението. no ATT dative on blame
  7. * Обвиниха закъснението на изпълнителя. object Charge + на Target is приписвам
  8. * Винят изпълнителя със закъснението. no with-frame
  9. * Обвиниха изпълнителя върху закъснението. върху ≠ Charge cloth
  10. * Колко не обвиниха изпълнителя от закъснението? no verbal MeasureP LBC host
  11. * Съветът размени изпълнителя за закъснението. as ascribe-fault SWAP cloth ≠ ascribe-fault
  12. * Закъснението беше обвинено изпълнителя. passive does not promote Charge
  13. ✓ weather as Target: Винят лошото време за закъснението. inanimate Target fine
  14. ✓ document Judge: Докладът обвини изпълнителя за закъснението. metonymy Judge fine

Groups A–D packaging · this tick Bulgarian only

Same hierarchy as English blame. This tick is Bulgarian only and continues Group C blame after Polish. Hungarian is live at blame-hu.html and closes Group C.

  • Group A. Japanese 責める live at blame-ja.html; ni Target under light-noun, de / no sei-de Charge; Double-o unused. Mandarin 怪 / 责备 live at blame-zh.html. Navajo: scout — classificatory stem for weather as Target, not as Judge. Sell·Navajo stays deferred; this page does not touch NV.
  • Group B. Spanish live at blame-es.html; French live at blame-fr.html; Italian live at blame-it.html. Charge letter there is de / pour / di. Bulgarian за / в / bare че is the Group C spelling of the same Charge, not a Romance clitic paradigm. Doubling here is one Target, not a Romance clitic-resumption paradigm.
  • Group C. Polish is live at blame-pl.html: morphological ACC Target, za/o Charge, za to, że, light-noun GEN vs DAT where the noun splits. Bulgarian is now live on this page: direct-object Target, за / в / bare че, clitic го doubling one Target, на on вина unresolved, multiple-WH as an open flag. There is no GEN-neg to rewrite the association — the same honesty as ATT Charge staying the direct object under не, and a different morphology from Polish. Hungarian is live at blame-hu.html (ACC Target; -ért; Focus+nem; no GEN-neg) and closes Group C.
  • Group D. German is live at blame-de.html (beschuldigen / verantwortlich machen; genitive / wegen / dass; not this page’s за / в / bare че). Dutch is live at blame-nl.html (de schuld geven). Norwegian is live at blame-no.html (legge skylden på).

Open items

  • Light-noun вина / обвинение / обвиняване. Scout. на does not spell possessor apart from Target. върху onto-geometry and срещу are not ranked and not elicited. приписвам вината на is the ATT verb, not this page’s direct object.
  • за vs в vs bare че. за is shared and is the cloth the ATT page already prints. в is filed on обвинявам as the fault-type P (often article-less). в on виня is not ranked. Bare че is the clausal Charge and does not require това. за това, че and в това, че are optional correlatives of the same Charge, not a fourth argument and not a copy of Polish za to, że / o to, że. Overlap of за and в on обвинявам is not ranked as exclusive.
  • No GEN-neg. Nominal case is gone. не does not rewrite blame’s Target/Charge association and does not put Charge in the object slot. Polish GEN-neg on a FIN/deduct MeasureP is a different language’s host. The older note “off on Charge unless Charge is a QP” still names a PP Charge elsewhere, not a verbal MeasureP on this verb and not a Bulgarian genitive.
  • Clitic doubling. го plus the full DP is one Target. Position (preverbal after a host, postverbal when the verb is first) is not a new argument. му is ATT.
  • Aspect pair. Index 2 lemmas are imperfective обвинявам / виня. Aorist обвини is a same-root perfective string, not a second sense page. Do not file a separate perfective of виня.
  • Reflexive се. виня се corefers Judge and Target. Not the passive беше обвинен, and not elicited as a Voice demotion. Impersonal allegation (обвинява се, че…) is a different construction and is not given a paradigm here.
  • отдавам. Stays the ATT-page scout. Not a blame root and not MERIT.
  • MERIT. No credit-merit-bg.html. Prose pointer only. Do not invent a live link. Same refusal for Polish.
  • XFER / FIN. FIN Bulgarian ledger записа is live at credit-fin-bg.html. The string on this page is the “no genitive on a measuring object” contrast. XFER stays at attribute-xfer.html. Do not merge pages.
  • WH cluster ranking. Кой кого за какво обвини? is a Group C packaging hypothesis. It is not an elicited paradigm. It does not split Amount from unit, because blame has no Amount.
  • Hungarian blame. Live at blame-hu.html (ACC = Target; -ért Charge; Focus+nem; no GEN-neg). German blame is live at blame-de.html. Dutch is live at blame-nl.html (de schuld geven). Norwegian is live at blame-no.html (legge skylden på).
  • Navajo. Deferred. Do not touch NV. Sell·Navajo stays deferred.

Corpus filenames

Primary extract for this micro-entry is Lexical_Entry_Blame_Argument_Structure (√ASCRIBE_FAULT; for/on clothes; Voice filter; Groups A–D). NegQ association maps from Negative_Questions_Blame. Light-noun contrast from Assign_Blame_Comparison. Group C shell plate: Attribute_GroupC_Larson_Shells (BG cluster beside HU Focus and PL GEN-neg) — the cluster note is packaging, and the GEN-neg note is Polish, not a Bulgarian genitive. The Case split against ATT is the live page attribute-att-bg.html (direct-object Charge + DAT/на Target; за and върху rejected on ATT; contrast strings обвини изпълнителя за закъснението and винят изпълнителя за закъснението). в and bare че are not those strings; they are the other ordinary clothes of the Index 2 lemmas, constructed here and labeled as such. Chat packaging: Tritransitive chats 13 (assign vs blame Case / NegQ) and 22 (blame in negative questions · no fourth theta). Index 2 Bulgarian Attitude cites обвинявам / виня, приписвам / отдавам. Constructed BG frames diagnose packaging; they are not new elicitation. Polish za / o / za to, że is live at blame-pl.html and is not the cloth copied onto this page.

Series placement: Bulgarian sense×language twin of English blame, Spanish culpar, French blâmer, Italian incolpare, Japanese 責める, Mandarin 怪 / 责备, and Polish obwiniać / winić. Feeds Attitude / Evaluation Index 2 beside live attributeATT · приписвам. Group C blame is closed by Hungarian hibáztat / okol. Keeps отдавам as a scout on the ATT page. Keeps XFER at attributeXFER and FIN at live записа. Does not invent a MERIT link or NV elicitation. Speculation flagged.

Index 2 citations for this class

Attitude / Evaluation citations from Index 2
CodeLanguageIndex 2 citationAs printed
ENEnglishblame EN micro-entry, creditMERIT EN micro-entry, attributeATT EN micro-entryVols. 1, 3
ESSpanishculpar ES micro-entry, creditMERIT · acreditar ES micro-entry, attributeATT · atribuir ES micro-entryVols. 3, 5
FRFrenchblâmer FR micro-entry, creditMERIT · attribuer FR micro-entry, attributeATT · attribuer FR micro-entryVols. 3, 5
ITItalianincolpare IT micro-entry, creditMERIT · attribuire IT micro-entry, attributeATT · attribuire IT micro-entryVols. 3, 5
HUHungarianhibáztat, okol, tulajdonít, elismer, jóváír · blame · hibáztat / okol HU micro-entry · attributeATT · tulajdonít HU micro-entry · creditMERIT · elismer HU micro-entryVols. 3, 6
BGBulgarianобвинявам / виня, приписвам / отдавам · blame · обвинявам / виня BG micro-entry · attributeATT · приписвам BG micro-entryVols. 3, 6
PLPolishobwiniać / winić, przypisywać · blame · obwiniać / winić PL micro-entry · attributeATT · przypisywać PL micro-entryVols. 3, 6
DEGermanbeschuldigen, verantwortlich machen, zuschreiben · blame · beschuldigen / verantwortlich machen DE micro-entry · creditMERIT · zuschreiben DE micro-entry · attributeATT · zuschreiben DE micro-entryVol. 7
NLDutchde schuld geven, toeschrijven · blame · de schuld geven NL micro-entry · creditMERIT · toeschrijven NL micro-entry · attributeATT · toeschrijven NL micro-entryVol. 7
NONorwegianlegge skylden på · blame · legge skylden på NO micro-entry · Beyond Index 2: creditMERIT · tilskrive NO micro-entry · attributeATT · tilskrive NO micro-entryVol. 7

Languages Index 2 does not list for this class are left off the table. Mandarin and Japanese blame sit Beyond Index 2 at blame-zh.html and blame-ja.html.