Arguments
Intended labeling
√ASCRIBE (positive / meritorious) + VoiceJ(Judge) + Charge + Target · hierarchy Cognizer / Judge > Charge / Content > Target
Voice introduces Judge (proto-Agent of the attitude). The ascription relates Target to Charge under positive / meritorious HOLD. English spells two productive clothes: ACC Charge + to-Target, or ACC Target + with-Charge. A for-Charge companion (credited the contractor for finishing early) keeps Target ACC. Optional high Affectee / outer CAUSEG wrap Voice; they are not listed inner arguments.
Examples
Two productive frames (to / with), a for-Charge companion, and passive rearrangements. The clothes choose which inner participant is the Case object. Cheap NegQ association and cheap WH track ACC: Charge under the to-frame, Target under the with-frame. FIN uses the same to/with letters for MeasureP / Account — different root; pointer only below.
✓ The investors credited the early completion to the contractor.
RolesHide roles
JudgeChargeTarget
Judge The investors
Charge the early completion
Target to the contractor
to-frame · ACC Charge · to-Target
✓ The investors credited the contractor with the early completion.
RolesHide roles
JudgeTargetCharge
Judge The investors
Target the contractor
Charge with the early completion
with-frame · ACC Target · with-Charge
✓ The investors credited the contractor for finishing early.
RolesHide roles
JudgeTargetCharge
Judge The investors
Target the contractor
Charge for finishing early
for-companion · ACC Target · for-Charge
✓ The early completion was credited to the contractor.
RolesHide roles
ChargeTarget
Charge The early completion
Target to the contractor
passive · Charge promoted
✓ The contractor was credited with the early completion.
RolesHide roles
TargetCharge
Target The contractor
Charge with the early completion
passive · Target promoted
✓ They credited the weather with the early finish.
RolesHide roles
JudgeTargetCharge
Judge They
Target the weather
Charge with the early finish
weather = Target OK
✓ They credited the early finish to the weather.
RolesHide roles
JudgeChargeTarget
Judge They
Charge the early finish
Target to the weather
to-frame · weather in to-PP
✓ Didn’t they credit the early completion to the contractor?
RolesHide roles
JudgeChargeTarget
Judge they
Charge the early completion
Target to the contractor
polar NegQ · to-frame
✓ Didn’t they credit the contractor with the early completion?
RolesHide roles
JudgeTargetCharge
Judge they
Target the contractor
Charge with the early completion
polar NegQ · with-frame
* The weather credited the contractor with the win.
RolesHide roles
JudgeTargetCharge
Judge The weather
Target the contractor
Charge with the win
weather as Judge
* The investors credited the contractor the early completion.
RolesHide roles
JudgeDOC
Judge The investors
DOC the contractor the early completion
no DOC
* The investors credited the early completion on the contractor.
RolesHide roles
JudgeChargeTarget
Judge The investors
Charge the early completion
Target on the contractor
no blame on-cloth
* The investors credited the contractor of the early completion.
RolesHide roles
JudgeTargetCharge
Judge The investors
Target the contractor
Charge of the early completion
of ≠ English Charge cloth
FIN pointer only, not a MERIT cloth: The board credited 0.3 ETH to each wallet. FIN · do not deepen
NegQ baseline · association tracks ACC
✓ Didn’t they credit the early completion to the contractor? to-frame · cheap = Charge
✓ Didn’t they credit the contractor with the early completion? with-frame · cheap = Target
✓ Wasn’t the early completion credited to the contractor? passive Charge
✓ Wasn’t the contractor credited with the early completion? passive Target
✓ FIN contrast (pointer): Didn’t the board credit 0.3 ETH to each wallet?
* Wasn’t the weather crediting anyone with the win? weather as Judge under Neg
* Didn’t they credit the contractor the early completion? no Neg-rescued DOC
# Didn’t they credit the early completion to the contractor — meaning the contractor didn’t cause it. cause-true not a default
A bare No on the canonical NegQ most readily challenges the ascription event or the ACC object of the chosen cloth. Challenging the oblique wants that content already under discussion. Negation does not grow a double-object and does not create a MeasureP on MERIT. HOLD is not cause-true — parallel to FIN’s missing payout default (HAS_ON_BOOKS ≠ spendable).
Notes
Working paper · September 2026 · English micro-entry · Attitude / ascribe merit · Index 2
Attitude / merit-ascribe sense in English. Working name √ASCRIBE (positive / meritorious). Hierarchy Cognizer / Judge > Charge / Content > Target. Two Case clothes: Charge to Target · Target with Charge (and a productive for-Charge companion). Opposite polarity of blame; sense-split twin of creditFIN. Japanese twin live: creditMERIT · 功績を認める. Spanish twin live: creditMERIT · acreditar. French twin live: creditMERIT · attribuer. Italian twin live: creditMERIT · attribuire. Mandarin twin live: creditMERIT · 归功于. German twin live: creditMERIT · zuschreiben. Hungarian twin live: creditMERIT · elismer. Dutch twin live: creditMERIT · toeschrijven. No DOC, no MeasureP, no HAVE, no SWAP.
Compare languages. Sense × language tick: creditMERIT · English. Twins: Japanese (功績を認める) · Spanish (acreditar) · French (attribuer) · Italian (attribuire) · Mandarin (归功于) · German (zuschreiben) · Hungarian (elismer) · Dutch (toeschrijven) · Norwegian (tilskrive). Geometry neighbors: attributeATT · blame · assignASCRIBE · chargeACCUSE · creditFIN. Index 2 English Attitude cites blame, credit, attribute — Vols. 1, 3. Keep the FIN/MERIT split: ledger increment is the other root.
Working paper.
English micro-entry deepened from the thin stub to sprint depth, twin of live
credit-merit-ja.html. Geometry from
Lexical_Entry_Credit_Argument_Structure; NegQ association maps from
Negative_Questions_Credit. Constructed diagnostics diagnose Case clothes (to/with), Voice filter, and the MERIT / FIN root split; they are not spontaneous-speech citations. Japanese twin already live; Spanish Romance twin live at
credit-merit-es.html; French Romance twin live at
credit-merit-fr.html; Italian MERIT live at
credit-merit-it.html; Mandarin MERIT live at
credit-merit-zh.html; Navajo merit companions deferred.
Constructed examples.
Frames below are packaging hypotheses aligned with the lexical entry and NegQ Credit paper. Cause-true and settlement are not entailed — same missing defaults as attributeATT and blame. Do not fake elicitation. FIN strings appear only as contrast pointers.
Sense-class · FIN/MERIT split.
Index 2 lists English Attitude as
blame, credit, attribute (Vols. 1, 3). This page deepens the
merit / ascribe reading of
credit as √ASCRIBE (+). The ledger reading is a different root at
creditFIN (√CREDIT_LEDGER; Beyond Index 2). Shared English phonology is the marked case — Groups A–D usually split the morphology (JP
功績を認める vs
入金する; DE
zuschreiben vs
gutschreiben).
Hierarchy
Same inventory as Japanese 功績を認める. Not five-place. Not four sisters of one V. Surface count can name the investors, the early completion, and the contractor — but the lexicon does not list four co-arguments of √ASCRIBE.
No MeasureP on MERIT. There is no verbal Amount+Denomination object unless Charge itself has been recoded as a share of credit (lexical entry §5.4 hybrid — flag, do not deepen). Degrees that sneak in (how much of the credit, partitives on Charge) live on the Abney spine of a light noun or of Charge — Left Branch Condition for sell / pay / chargeFEE / creditFIN does not apply as a verbal diagnostic here.
Weather still satisfies Target and fails Judge. Cause-true is still not entailed. Target and Charge still do not invert at Transfer cost. Treating creditMERIT as Agent > Theme > Goal, or collapsing it with creditFIN because English spells both credit, predicts a DOC, a HAVE entailment, a MeasureP LBC host, or a grammatical weather-as-Judge — none of those exist on MERIT.
WH / NegQ diagnostics · no MeasureP LBC
Unlike sell / payGIVE / chargeFEE / bet / creditFIN, creditMERIT has no verbal MeasureP. There is therefore no Left-Branch Condition of the Amount-from-Denomination type on √ASCRIBE. Degrees that appear are DP-internal on Charge or on a light noun such as credit / merit.
- ✓ Who credited the early completion to the contractor? WH = Judge
- ✓ What did the investors credit to the contractor? WH = Charge · to-frame
- ✓ Who did the investors credit with the early completion? WH = Target · with-frame
- ✓ Who was credited with the early completion? passive Target
- ✓ What was credited to the contractor? passive Charge
- ✓ How much of the credit did they give the contractor? degree on light noun · Abney-side, not verbal MeasureP
- * How much didn’t they credit completion to the contractor? no verbal MeasureP LBC host on MERIT
- ✓ They credited the weather with the win. weather = Target · fine
- * They made the weather credit the contractor with the win. weather still not inner Judge under make
Superiority ranks Judge > ACC > K-DP > outer for. Flip to/with and Charge and Target change rank — Case prominence, not a fixed thematic ranking (contrast Volume 3’s blame Cognizer > Target > Content default). Cheap NegQ association tracks the Case object. There is no ranking of Charge against a silent Purpose, Price, or Theme₂.
to-Charge ≠ FIN MeasureP · with-Target ≠ FIN Account
to Charge = content of the attitude — not ledger Amount, not sell Price, not pay Consideration, not swap Theme₂. with Target = ascribee — not FIN wallet / Account, not bet Platform, not sell Recipient HAVE. Chat 23: the to/with flip is Case cloth on one root family; MERIT and FIN share the letters and split the roots.
Geometry · creditMERIT ≠ creditFIN ≠ blame ≠ attribute ≠ sell
In The investors credited the early completion to the contractor, the investors hold that the contractor is responsible for the early completion under meritorious evaluation. That is ascription, not HAVE of goods and not ledger INCREMENT. The contractor is Target. The early completion is Charge. HOLD is an attitude; MERITORIOUS(Target, Charge) is content, not a presupposed fact.
- ≠ creditFIN. Same surface family of “credit” talk; different root. FIN writes MeasureP TO a Domain / Account (The board credited 0.3 ETH to each wallet / credited each wallet with 0.3 ETH). MERIT has no MeasureP and no Account. Collapsing them because both can sit next to English credit is the error the lexical entry was written to block. FIN deepened at credit-fin.html — pointer only this tick for ledger strings.
- ≠ English DOC / Transfer invert. There is no productive *credited the contractor the early completion. Negation does not rescue it. Transfer Themes invert under Romance swap NegQ; MERIT Target and Charge do not.
- ≠ attributeATT polarity merge. Shared family (ascribe content to Target) and shared Voice filter; creditMERIT writes positive / meritorious polarity. Attribute does the same root split without a productive with-frame — credit is the clearer packaging case because English advertises the to/with flip.
- ≠ blame / √ASCRIBE_FAULT. Opposite polarity. Blame ascribes fault; credit ascribes merit. Blame has for/on clothes English credit lacks as a productive on-Target cloth; credit has to/with flip options English blame lacks.
- ≠ sell / ApplHAVE. No ApplHAVE, no for-Price MeasureP. Surface for on MERIT is Charge companion, not Price.
- Missing defaults. Cause-true and settlement are not entailed. Didn’t they credit the early completion to the contractor? is compatible with the contractor not in fact causing the early completion. Ironic polarity (credited her with the robbery) is lexical HOLD content, not a fourth argument.
Japanese twin spells the default as Charge o + Target ni (功績を認める); there is no productive with-flip of the English credit type as a second Case object. English twin: to-frame Charge ACC / Target to; with-frame Target ACC / Charge with. Weather OK as Target, *not* as Judge.
Shells, ApplP, and Case
Base tree (ascribe-merit · English clothes)
to-frame:
VoiceP [ JudgeNOM
vP / √ASCRIBE
ACC Charge
PP_to Target ]
with-frame:
VoiceP [ JudgeNOM
vP / √ASCRIBE
ACC Target
PP_with Charge ]
for-companion:
VoiceP [ JudgeNOM
vP / √ASCRIBE
ACC Target
PP_for Charge ]
English MERIT never assigns four structural Cases. Charge or Target is ACC; the other wears P. No low ApplHAVE. No low ApplSWAP. No ApplTASK. No MeasureP (unless share-of-credit hybrid — flag). High Appl / Affectee is extra when present and is not a listed argument of √ASCRIBE.
Composition is V(DP) on the ACC object. To and with are wrapper-K on the Abney spine (same cut as attribute’s to, §6.4): V(DP), not V(to(DP)). Early completion does not travel a path; the contractor is not an instrument of with.
Outer CAUSEG (they made the investors credit the contractor with the win) wraps Voice. The causee, not the weather, is the Judge. *They made the weather credit the contractor with the win keeps the inner Voice filter. Type A climbing unions Voice domains; Charge stays content and never climbs as a dative MeasureP.
Omission does not demote Charge to a pure adjunct. Selected P-layers are optional in the numeration; they are still arguments when present. The diagnostic is participanthood under Case, binding, and WH — not omitability. Charge clauses are islands in a way rationale adjuncts are not; there is no Neg-raising out of Charge.
Type A · make wrap
✓ Didn’t they make the investors credit the early completion to the contractor? outer Neg denies causing
* They made the weather credit the contractor with the win. weather still not inner Judge
Underivables (English MERIT)
- * The weather credited the contractor with the win. weather / inanimate as Judge
- * Wasn’t the weather crediting anyone with the win? Voice filter survives Neg
- * They made the weather credit the contractor with the win. CAUSEG wrap does not wash Voice filter
- * The investors credited the contractor the early completion. no productive DOC
- * What did the investors credit the contractor? missing DOC under WH
- * How much didn’t they credit completion to the contractor? no verbal MeasureP LBC host on MERIT
- * The investors credited the contractor with 0.3 ETH as merit. FIN MeasureP ≠ MERIT Charge (unless share hybrid — flag)
- * The investors credited the early completion on the contractor. no blame on-cloth
- * They swapped the contractor for the early completion. SWAP cloth ≠ ascribe-merit
- ✓ weather as Target: They credited the weather with the early finish. inanimate Target fine
Groups A–D packaging · this tick English only
English micro-entry (deepened stub). Japanese Group A twin is live. Brief pointers only:
- Group A. Japanese live at credit-merit-ja.html (功績を認める / 手柄にする; ACC Charge, ni Target; Double-o unused). Mandarin live at credit-merit-zh.html (归功于; 把 fronts Charge; 没 / 没有 over that object). Navajo: scout — HANDLE packaging for Target, not Judge. FIN Japanese (入金する) is the sister micro-entry at credit-fin-ja.html — keep the FIN/MERIT split.
- Group B. Romance usually splits morphology (attribuer / ascribe vs créditer / ledger). en resumes FIN quantity, not MERIT Charge. Spanish MERIT live at credit-merit-es.html; French MERIT live at credit-merit-fr.html; Italian MERIT live at credit-merit-it.html.
- Group C. Hungarian MERIT is live at credit-merit-hu.html (elismer; Focus+nem; DAT Target + ACC Charge). Polish GEN-neg on Charge remains predicted / scout.
- Group D. German names the roots (zuschreiben vs gutschreiben) — live at credit-merit-de.html. Dutch toeschrijven vs bijschrijven / crediteren is live at credit-merit-nl.html (continues Group D; DAT Target + ACC Charge). Norwegian tilskrive vs godskrive is live at credit-merit-no.html (continues Group D; til-Target + ACC Charge).
Open items
- Mandarin / Navajo micro-entries. Same Group A geometry; 把 / HANDLE packaging. Deferred — do not invent depth this tick.
- Romance merit micro-entries. Spanish / French / Italian live (Group B closed). Scout / deferred for remaining Romance FIN twins.
- Share-of-credit MeasureP hybrid. Lexical entry §5.4: Charge recoded as quantified share (credited the contractor with 30% of the savings). Diagnostics: replaceable by ascribe/recognize, not by wire; weather can wear the with-DP; the board can be wrong. Flagged, not deepened as verbal MeasureP on plain MERIT.
- Ironic polarity. credited her with the robbery — HOLD polarity inside the attitude, not a fourth argument. How far VoiceJ stays under irony is open.
- Nominal credit on the Abney spine. whose credit was it? — Target vs Judge ambiguity the verbal Voice filter does not have. Flagged, not solved.
- Type A make + creditMERIT. Outer CAUSE wraps a Judge event. Outer Neg can be cheap on the causing; the inner Voice filter survives. Not a new elicitation.
- FIN English / Japanese. Already live at credit-fin.html and credit-fin-ja.html. Keep the split; do not merge pages.
Corpus filenames
Primary extract for this micro-entry is Lexical_Entry_Credit_Argument_Structure (English snapshot · √ASCRIBE vs √CREDIT_LEDGER). NegQ association maps from Negative_Questions_Credit. Chat packaging: Tritransitive chats 23 (NegQ on credit · two-root · to/with ACC tracking), 25 (credit attitude vs transfer), and 35 (credit argument-structure acceptability). Twin geometry shared with Japanese Group A remainder (§12).
- Lexical_Entry_Credit_Argument_Structure.docx primary · √ASCRIBE · to/with clothes · Voice filter · MERIT ≠ FIN
- Negative_Questions_Credit.docx NegQ association · ACC tracks cheap · Groups A–D
- Subject_Constraints_Nonvolitional_Attitude_Verbs.docx Judge vs Target · weather battery
- 23-negative-questions-on-credit-two-root-analysis.md chat 23 · to/with · ACC vs に
- 25-credit-attitude-vs-transfer-verb.md chat 25
- 35-credit-argument-structure-acceptability.md chat 35
- INDEX2_Verbs.txt English Attitude · blame, credit, attribute — Vols. 1, 3
Series placement: English sense×language twin of Japanese 功績を認める. Feeds Attitude / Evaluation Index 2 and the ascribe-merit cell next to attributeATT / blame. Keeps FIN at creditFIN. Does not invent ZH/NV/Romance merit elicitation. Speculation flagged.
Index 2 citations for this class
Attitude / Evaluation citations from Index 2
| Code | Language | Index 2 citation | As printed |
| EN | English | blame EN micro-entry, creditMERIT EN micro-entry, attribute | Vols. 1, 3 |
| ES | Spanish | culpar ES micro-entry, creditMERIT · acreditar ES micro-entry, atribuir | Vols. 3, 5 |
| FR | French | blâmer FR micro-entry, creditMERIT · attribuer FR micro-entry, attribuer | Vols. 3, 5 |
| IT | Italian | incolpare, attribuire | Vols. 3, 5 |
| HU | Hungarian | hibáztat, okol, tulajdonít, elismer, jóváír · blame · hibáztat / okol HU micro-entry · attributeATT · tulajdonít HU micro-entry · creditMERIT · elismer HU micro-entry | Vols. 3, 6 |
| BG | Bulgarian | обвинявам / виня, приписвам / отдавам | Vols. 3, 6 |
| PL | Polish | obwiniać / winić, przypisywać | Vols. 3, 6 |
| DE | German | beschuldigen, verantwortlich machen, zuschreiben · blame · beschuldigen / verantwortlich machen DE micro-entry · creditMERIT · zuschreiben DE micro-entry | Vol. 7 |
| NL | Dutch | de schuld geven, toeschrijven · blame · de schuld geven NL micro-entry · creditMERIT · toeschrijven NL micro-entry · attributeATT · toeschrijven NL micro-entry | Vol. 7 |
| NO | Norwegian | legge skylden på · blame · legge skylden på NO micro-entry · Beyond Index 2: creditMERIT · tilskrive NO micro-entry | Vol. 7 |
Languages Index 2 does not list for this class are left off the table. Japanese MERIT sits Beyond Index 2 (no Attitude JA cell) at credit-merit-ja.html.