Arguments
Intended labeling (shared English metalanguage)
√CREDIT_LEDGER / INCREMENT + VoiceA(Allocator) + MeasureP ⟨Amount, Denom⟩ + ApplTO(Recipient / Account) · hierarchy Allocator > MeasureP > Rec/Account (> outer Reason)
Voice introduces Allocator (authority over a ledger — board, bank, smart contract, clearing house). MeasureP ⟨n, U⟩ is Incremental Theme of the increment — one Case object (Amount in Spec, Denomination as N). Low Appl_TO / book-Recipient introduces Account. Optional high for-Reason / purpose PP is outer justification of the increment, not Charge of MERIT and not Purpose of earmark’s RESTRICT. Two English Case clothes flip which participant sits in ACC; they do not change the inventory.
Examples
Two clothes on INCREMENT. to-frame: MeasureP ACC + to-Account. with-frame: Account ACC + with-MeasureP. Limited DOC for some speakers when Recipient is a person rather than a wallet — realer than attributeXFER, still not listed cloth. The productive applied-object packaging is the with-frame, not the DOC. Do not conflate with MERIT’s to/with clothes (Charge vs Target).
- ✓ The board credited 0.3 ETH to each investor's wallet. canonical · to-frame · MeasureP ACC
- ✓ The board credited each investor's wallet with 0.3 ETH. with-frame · Account ACC
- ✓ The bank credited her account with 0.3 ETH. banker's English
- ✓ The board credited 0.3 ETH to each wallet for Q3. outer Reason
- ✓ The smart contract credited 0.3 ETH to each investor's wallet. Allocator = code / institution
- ✓ The clearing house credited each wallet with 0.3 ETH. system Allocator · with-frame
- ✓ 0.3 ETH was credited to each wallet. passive · MeasureP promotes (to-frame)
- ✓ Each wallet was credited with 0.3 ETH. passive · Account promotes (with-frame)
- ? The bank credited her 50 dollars. limited DOC · person-Recipient · dialectal
- ?? The board credited each investor 0.3 ETH. DOC · limited / degraded
- ?? Each investor was credited 0.3 ETH. DOC passive · limited
- * The investors credited the contractor with 0.3 ETH. MERIT with-frame + MeasureP · coerced hybrid
- * The weather credited 0.3 ETH to each investor's wallet. weather ≠ Allocator
- * The board credited 0.3 ETH from each wallet. from = deduct · not TO
- * The board credited luck with 0.3 ETH. Account ≠ inanimate cause
Passive · MeasureP vs Account (packaging decides who raises)
✓ 0.3 ETH was credited to each wallet. to-frame · MeasureP promotes
✓ Each wallet was credited with 0.3 ETH. with-frame · Account promotes
✓ How much ETH was credited to each wallet?
✓ How much ETH was each wallet credited with?
✓ Who was 0.3 ETH credited to? Recipient · P-strand
?? Each investor was credited 0.3 ETH. DOC passive
* 0.3 was credited ETH to each wallet. Amount ≠ separate promote
MERIT pointer (do not deepen · keep split)
✓ The investors credited the early completion to the contractor. MERIT · Charge ACC · to-Target
✓ The investors credited the contractor with the early completion. MERIT · Target ACC · with-Charge
* The investors credited the contractor the early completion. no DOC on MERIT
Stub twin: creditMERIT · Japanese live: credit-merit-ja.html.
Notes
Working paper · September 2026 · English micro-entry · Ledger increment / FIN · TO dual of deduct
Ledger-increment sense in English. Working name √CREDIT_LEDGER / INCREMENT. Hierarchy Allocator > MeasureP ⟨Amount, Denomination⟩ > Recipient / Account (> outer Reason). Two Case clothes on one geometry: MeasureP ACC + to-Account, or Account ACC + with-MeasureP. Increment dual of deduct; sense-split twin of twin creditMERIT. Japanese twin live: creditFIN · 入金する. Spanish twin live: creditFIN · acreditar / abonar. Mandarin twin live: creditFIN · 入账. German twin live: creditFIN · gutschreiben. Dutch twin live: creditFIN · bijschrijven / crediteren. Norwegian twin live: creditFIN · godskrive. No productive DOC as listed cloth; no √ASCRIBE; no HAVE-goods; no SWAP; payout not entailed.
Sense × language tick: creditFIN · English. Twins: creditFIN · Japanese · creditFIN · Spanish · creditFIN · Portuguese. Geometry neighbors: deduct · attributeXFER · chargeFEE · payGIVE · earmark · bet. Keep FIN/MERIT split — Index 2 files English credit under Attitude; this page is the ledger reading Beyond Index 2.
Working paper.
English-only micro-entry deepened from
Lexical_Entry_Credit_Argument_Structure (FIN half) and
Negative_Questions_Credit, sharing √CREDIT_LEDGER geometry with the live Japanese twin
credit-fin-ja.html and the FROM dual
deduct. Constructed diagnostics diagnose to/with Case flip, MeasureP integrity, Allocator filter, and the FIN / MERIT root split; they are not spontaneous-speech citations. Mandarin FIN now live at
credit-fin-zh.html; Navajo Group A companions remain deferred.
Constructed examples.
Frames below are packaging hypotheses aligned with the lexical entry’s §3.2 / §5 / §7.2 and NegQ association maps. HAS_ON_BOOKS after the event is e2. Payout / spendability is not entailed — same missing settlement default as bet and as Japanese 入金する. Do not fake elicitation. Limited DOC and scout-leaning forms are flagged.
Class table.
Index 2 does not list a financial credit verb. It files English
credit under Attitude / Evaluation. The payment-class table is a neighbour class, not a translation of
creditFIN. Like
deduct and
chargeFEE, this root sits
Beyond Index 2 as a measuring companion. Keep the FIN/MERIT split.
Scout / deferred.
Mandarin FIN now live at
credit-fin-zh.html (
入账 /
打入). Navajo BOOK packaging remains deferred. Limited person-Recipient DOC (
?credited her 50 dollars) is dialectal / speaker-variable — logged, not listed as productive cloth. Japanese deduct packaging (FROM twin) remains scout. No fake elicitation.
Hierarchy
Not five-place. Not four sisters of one V. Surface count can name the board, 0.3, ETH, each wallet, and a Q3 threshold — but Amount and Denomination share one Case object, Account is one Recipient / Domain-of-increment, and Reason is high / outer.
0.3 ETH = one MeasureP. Orthography is not extra arity. Amount and Denomination are both inner arguments of that object. Composition is V(MeasureP), not V(n)(U). Hom(e, ⟨n,U⟩): the increment is measured by degree n on scale U.
Working hierarchy: Allocator > MeasureP ⟨Amount, Denomination⟩ > Recipient / Account > Reason. to-frame Case ranking is Allocator > MeasureP > Account; with-frame flips ACC to Account (Allocator > Account > MeasureP). Weather still fails Allocator. Payout is still not entailed. Account and MeasureP flip rank only by Case cloth — same TO dual of deduct’s FROM Domain.
MeasureP WH / NegQ · LBC and to/with
Unlike creditMERIT, creditFIN has a verbal MeasureP. Amount and Denomination compose one Case object. Whole-QP pied-piping is free under Neg. Amount-only is free when the unit is bound. Left-branch extraction of Amount leaving the unit next to V is still out — same LBC deduct / sell / attributeXFER record. The with-frame does not split the QP either: with takes the whole MeasureP.
- ✓ How much ETH did the board credit to each wallet? whole MeasureP · to-frame
- ✓ How much did the board credit to each wallet? degree WH · U bound
- ✓ How much of what did the board credit to whom? n and U inside host
- ✓ To whom did the board credit 0.3 ETH? WH = Account
- ✓ Who credited how much ETH to whom? Alloc > MeasureP > Rec
- ✓ How much ETH did the board credit each wallet with? with-frame · whole MeasureP
- ✓ What did the board credit each wallet with? whole MeasureP out of with
- ✓ Who credited whom with how much ETH? Alloc > Account > MeasureP
- * How much did the board credit ETH to each wallet? LBC · U stranded
- * What did the board credit 0.3 to each wallet? what hijacks object · stranded n
- * What did the board credit each wallet with 0.3? unit stranded inside with
- * What how much did the board credit to whom? Amount ≠ verbal sister of U
- ✓ MERIT pointer: What did the investors credit to the contractor? WH = Charge · not MeasureP
- * How much did the investors credit to the contractor? unless Charge recoded as share
to-Account ≠ MERIT Target · with-MeasureP ≠ MERIT Charge
to Account = book / wallet / Recipient-as-account-holder — not MERIT ascribee, not bet Platform, not sell Recipient HAVE. with MeasureP = quantized ledger increment — not Charge content, not sell Price alone, not blame Target. Shared English letters; different licensers (Appl_TO / √CREDIT_LEDGER vs √ASCRIBE).
Superiority ranks Allocator > ACC object > oblique K-DP > outer Reason. Amount and Denomination never compete as two verbal WH-items. Cheap NegQ association tracks the Case object: MeasureP under the to-frame; Account under the with-frame.
Geometry · creditFIN ≠ creditMERIT ≠ deduct ≠ chargeFEE ≠ payGIVE
In The board credited 0.3 ETH to each wallet, the board writes 0.3 ETH onto each wallet’s book. That is ledger INCREMENT, not ascription and not HAVE of goods. The wallet is Account. 0.3 ETH is MeasureP. HAS_ON_BOOKS holds after the event; spendability / payout is not entailed.
- ≠ creditMERIT. Same surface family of “credit” talk; different root. MERIT ascribes Charge TO a Target (credited the early completion to the contractor / credited the contractor with the early completion). FIN has MeasureP and Account; MERIT has neither (unless Charge is quantified as a share — hybrid §5.4, still ASCRIBE). Collapsing them because both can sit next to English credit is the error the lexical entry was written to block. MERIT twin: credit-merit.html; JA live: credit-merit-ja.html.
- ≠ deduct. Shared MeasureP. Opposite polarity: deduct = FROM_SET decrement; creditFIN = TO_SET increment. creditFIN has a with-cloth; English deduct has none (*deduct every player with …). *credit … from … fails the same cut as *deduct … to …. Live twin: deduct.html.
- ≠ chargeFEE / fine. FEE is FROM (Appl_FROM Payer + MeasureP; Payer often ACC). FIN is TO (Appl_TO Account + MeasureP). Shared MeasureP object; opposite Source/Goal polarity.
- ≠ payGIVE / award. Pay/award write MeasureP with cleaner DOC and Recipient HAVE. FIN’s HAVE_ON_BOOKS is weaker; payout is a later verb (collect / withdraw / pay out / debit). Limited DOC on FIN is not award’s listed cloth.
- ≠ attributeXFER. Shared CREDIT_LEDGER family and to-Account cloth; attributeXFER lacks the productive with-frame creditFIN advertises.
- ≠ earmark / sell / SWAP. Earmark’s for is Purpose (RESTRICTED_FOR); FIN’s for is outer Reason. Sell: Recipient HAS goods; Price stays inside for. Neither FIN cloth is SWAP.
- Missing defaults. Payout and spendability are not entailed. A later debit can reverse the book without making the original credit event false. HAS_ON_BOOKS ≠ physical HAVE ≠ RESTRICTED_FOR.
- Hybrid trap (§5.4). credited the contractor with 30% of the savings can look MeasureP-shaped and still be MERIT (quantified Charge). Diagnostics: replaceable by ascribe/praise; not by wire/deposit; weather can sit as MERIT Target but not as FIN Account (*credited the weather with 0.3 ETH).
Shells, ApplP, and Case
Base tree (ledger-increment · English · to-frame)
VoiceP [ Allocator = the board
(ReasonP) [ for Q3 ] // optional, outer
ApplP_TO / book-Rec [ to [ each investor's wallet ]
VP [ √CREDIT_LEDGER [ MeasureP [ Amount 0.3 ] [ N ETH ] ] ] ]
]
with-frame (same geometry · Case flip)
VoiceP [ Allocator = the board
ApplP_TO [ ACC Account = each wallet
VP [ √CREDIT_LEDGER [ with [ MeasureP ⟨0.3, ETH⟩ ] ] ] ]
]
— same INCREMENT / HAS_ON_BOOKS; Account promotes in passive
English assigns one structural ACC per frame. to-frame: ACC = MeasureP; Account wears wrapper-K to. with-frame: ACC = Account; MeasureP wears wrapper-K with. Composition is V(DP), not V(to(DP)) and not V(with(DP)) — same wrapper-K point as the attribute entry (§6.4). No low ApplHAVE of goods. No low ApplSWAP. No √ASCRIBE. High Appl / Affectee / outer Reason is extra when present. Each investor’s wallet is a DP-internal container on the Recipient — Abney restrictor, not a fourth verbal Location.
Neo-Davidsonian sketch (entry §7.2)
∃e [ INCREMENT(e)
∧ INIT(e, board)
∧ DEGREE(e, 0.3) ∧ UNIT(e, ETH)
∧ TO_SET(e, R) ∧ Hom(e, ⟨0.3, ETH⟩)
∧ JUSTIFIED_BY(e, Q3) ] // Reason optional
result: ∀y ∈ R. HAS_ON_BOOKS(y, ⟨0.3, ETH⟩) after e
Replace TO_SET with FROM_SET and INCREMENT with DECREMENT and the deduct entry drops out. The with-frame does not change the semantics; it changes which participant is the ACC object. That is why (2) and (2′) are truth-conditionally equivalent and raising-theoretically distinct. e2 = HAS_ON_BOOKS; e3 payout is not asserted.
Voice filter · Allocator (same cell as deduct’s Agent-ish)
✓ Who credited 0.3 ETH to each investor's wallet?
✓ The smart contract / the clearing house / the bank credited … institutional Initiator
?? What credited 0.3 ETH to each wallet? improves if what = the contract / the script
* The weather credited 0.3 ETH to each investor's wallet. not a ledger authority
✓ What the smart contract did was credit each wallet with 0.3 ETH.
* What the weather did was credit each wallet with 0.3 ETH. Culicover & Jackendoff
Milder than MERIT’s Judge filter (systems pass on FIN; weather still fails on both). Inanimate Targets welcome on MERIT; inanimate Accounts fail on FIN unless construed as books.
Type A · outer make wrap
✓ Didn’t they make the board credit 0.3 ETH to each wallet? outer Neg denies causing
* Didn’t they make the weather credit 0.3 ETH to each wallet? weather still not inner Allocator
Underivables (English FIN)
- * The weather credited 0.3 ETH to each investor's wallet. weather / inanimate as Allocator
- * What the weather did was credit each wallet with 0.3 ETH. do-test · Voice filter
- * How much did the board credit ETH to each wallet? LBC · U stranded
- * What did the board credit 0.3 to each wallet? LBC · stranded n
- * What did the board credit each wallet with 0.3? unit stranded inside with
- * The board credited 0.3 ETH from each wallet. from ≠ TO · use deduct
- * The board credited luck / the weather with 0.3 ETH. Account ≠ inanimate cause
- * The board credited 0.3 ETH to luck. Rec must be account-holder
- * The investors credited the contractor with 0.3 ETH. MERIT cloth + FIN MeasureP hybrid
- * The smart contract credited the early completion to the contractor. system Allocator ≠ MERIT Judge (coerced)
- ✓ institution / contract as Allocator: The smart contract credited 0.3 ETH to each wallet. book-keeper fine
- ✓ award contrast DOC: The board awarded each investor 0.3 ETH. cleaner DOC · different root packaging
NegQ pointer · association sites
Negative questions on creditFIN keep the FIN map; they do not invent a fifth theta name and do not create a Charge. Neg sits high and associates downward. Cheap inner associate = the Case object (MeasureP in the to-frame; Account in the with-frame). Reason stays outer. Payout / spendability is systematically missing as a default Neg target — same moral as bet’s missing settlement.
English NegQ / WH–Neg core (from Negative_Questions_Credit · FIN)
✓ Didn’t the board credit 0.3 ETH to each investor's wallet?
✓ Wasn’t 0.3 ETH credited to each wallet?
✓ Wasn’t each wallet credited with 0.3 ETH?
✓ How much ETH didn’t the board credit to each wallet?
✓ How much didn’t the board credit to each wallet? U bound
* How much didn’t the board credit ETH to each wallet? LBC under Neg
✓ How much ETH didn’t they credit each wallet with?
✓ To whom / to which wallets didn’t they credit 0.3 ETH?
✓ What didn’t they credit 0.3 ETH to each wallet for? / Why didn’t they …? Reason
✓ MERIT contrast (pointer): Didn’t the investors credit the early completion to the contractor?
* Didn’t the weather credit 0.3 ETH to each wallet?
Missing defaults: no payout-true; no spendability as e3. A bare negative answer most readily challenges the increment event or the ACC MeasureP (to-frame). Challenging the Account wants that book already under discussion.
Open items
- Romance FIN micro-entries. Spanish live at credit-fin-es.html; French live at credit-fin-fr.html; Italian next. Keep FIN/MERIT split.
- Mandarin / Navajo micro-entries. Same Group A geometry; 把 / BOOK packaging. Deferred — do not invent depth this tick. spec
- Limited person-Recipient DOC. ?credited her 50 dollars / ??credited each investor 0.3 ETH — speaker check; not listed cloth. Award/pay contrast stays cleaner.
- Japanese deduct packaging. FROM dual (kōjo-suru / 控除); scout / deferred. English deduct is the live FROM twin; JA FIN is already live at credit-fin-ja.html.
- English MERIT deepening. credit-merit.html remains a stub this tick. JA MERIT already live — keep FIN/MERIT split; do not conflate.
- Debit as named dual. NegQ Credit open item: does NegQ on debit copy the FIN map with polarity flipped, and does debit have any attitude reading? Prediction: no MERIT debit.
- Outer CAUSE NegQ. make / lassen / faire + credit — Type A wrap; outer Neg denies causing; weather still fails as causee Allocator.
- Hybrid QP Charge (§5.4). Controlled discrimination of credited X with 30% of the savings (MERIT share) vs true FIN MeasureP — speaker check recommended in the lexical entry.
- Group D FIN. German is live at credit-fin-de.html (gutschreiben vs zuschreiben). Dutch is live at credit-fin-nl.html (bijschrijven / crediteren vs toeschrijven). Norwegian is live at credit-fin-no.html (godskrive vs tilskrive). Polish GEN-neg is not a Germanic diagnostic. spec
Corpus filenames
Primary extract for this micro-entry is the FIN half of Lexical_Entry_Credit_Argument_Structure (frames §3.2, Voice §4.1, MeasureP WH §5.2, shells §7.2) plus FIN NegQ association from Negative_Questions_Credit. Japanese twin deepened earlier from Group A §12. Decrement dual: Lexical_Entry_Deduct_Argument_Structure. Chat packaging: Tritransitive chats 23 (NegQ on credit · two-root), 25 (credit attitude vs transfer), and 35 (credit argument-structure acceptability).
- Lexical_Entry_Credit_Argument_Structure.docx primary · √CREDIT_LEDGER · to/with · Allocator filter · MERIT ≠ FIN
- Negative_Questions_Credit.docx Neg association · MeasureP LBC under Neg · missing payout
- Lexical_Entry_Deduct_Argument_Structure.docx FROM dual · decrement mirror
- WH_Raising_Denominations.docx / WH_Movement_Denominations_Deduct.docx MeasureP LBC · Amount vs unit
- 23-negative-questions-on-credit-two-root-analysis.md chat 23 · two-root
- 25-credit-attitude-vs-transfer-verb.md chat 25
- 35-credit-argument-structure-acceptability.md chat 35
- INDEX2_Verbs.txt EN credit under Attitude; no separate FIN lemma
Series placement: English sense×language twin of Japanese creditFIN · Spanish creditFIN · French creditFIN · Spanish creditFIN · French creditFIN. Feeds Payment / measuring companions Beyond Index 2 and the ledger-increment cell next to deduct / chargeFEE / attributeXFER. Sister of twin creditMERIT / live creditMERIT · Japanese — keep the FIN/MERIT split. Does not invent ZH/NV elicitation. Speculation flagged.