Compare with…

Arguments

Intended labeling

√ASCRIBE_FAULT + VoiceJ(Judge) + Target + Charge  ·  hierarchy Judge > Target > Charge (1+2)

Voice introduces Judge (proto-Agent of the attitude). The ascription relates Target to Charge. English spells two clothes: ACC Target + for-Charge, or ACC Charge + on-Target. Light-noun on-geometry (put / lay the blame on Target) puts FAULT on N and parks Target in on-PP — still one ascription, still no HAVE / SWAP / MeasureP. Optional high Affectee / outer CAUSEG wrap Voice; they are not listed inner arguments.

Examples

Two productive frames and light-noun / passive rearrangements. The clothes choose which inner participant is the Case object. Cheap NegQ association and cheap WH track ACC: Target under the for-frame, Charge under the on-frame.

✓ The committee blamed Kim for the delay.

RolesHide roles JudgeTargetCharge
Judge The committee Target Kim Charge for the delay

for-frame · ACC Target · for-Charge

✓ The committee blamed the delay on Kim.

RolesHide roles JudgeTargetCharge
Judge The committee Charge the delay Target on Kim

on-frame · ACC Charge · on-Target

✓ Kim was blamed for the delay.

RolesHide roles TargetCharge
Target Kim Charge for the delay

passive · Target promoted

✓ The weather was blamed for the delay.

RolesHide roles TargetCharge
Target The weather Charge for the delay

weather = Target OK

✓ They blamed the weather for the delay.

RolesHide roles JudgeTargetCharge
Judge They Target the weather Charge for the delay

for-frame · weather ACC Target

✓ They blamed the delay on the weather.

RolesHide roles JudgeTargetCharge
Judge They Charge the delay Target on the weather

on-frame · weather in on-PP

✓ Didn’t they blame the weather for the delay?

RolesHide roles JudgeTargetCharge
Judge they Target the weather Charge for the delay

polar NegQ · for-frame

✓ Didn’t they blame the delay on the weather?

RolesHide roles JudgeTargetCharge
Judge they Charge the delay Target on the weather

polar NegQ · on-frame

✓ They put / laid the blame on the weather.

RolesHide roles JudgeChargeTarget
Judge They Charge the blame Target on the weather

light noun · on-geometry

✓ Dan blamed the cow for the Chicago fire.

RolesHide roles JudgeTargetCharge
Judge Dan Target the cow Charge for the Chicago fire

Assign_Blame cow battery · Target

* The weather blamed Kim for the delay.

RolesHide roles JudgeTargetCharge
Judge The weather Target Kim Charge for the delay

weather as Judge

* They blamed Kim the delay.

RolesHide roles JudgeDOC
Judge They DOC Kim the delay

no DOC

* They blamed Kim of the delay.

RolesHide roles JudgeTargetCharge
Judge They Target Kim Charge of the delay

of ≠ English Charge cloth

* They blamed Kim with the delay.

RolesHide roles JudgeTargetCharge
Judge They Target Kim Charge with the delay

no creditMERIT with-cloth

NegQ baseline · association tracks ACC

✓ Didn’t they blame the weather for the delay? for-frame · cheap = Target

✓ Didn’t they blame the delay on the weather? on-frame · cheap = Charge

✓ Wasn’t the weather blamed for the delay? passive Target

✓ Wasn’t the delay blamed on the weather? passive Charge

✓ Wasn’t the blame laid on the weather? light noun promotes

* Wasn’t the weather blaming anyone for the delay? weather as Judge under Neg

* Didn’t they blame the airline the delay? no Neg-rescued DOC

# Didn’t they blame the weather for the delay — meaning the weather didn’t cause it. cause-true not a default

A bare No on the canonical NegQ most readily challenges the ascription event or the ACC object of the chosen cloth. Challenging the oblique wants that content already under discussion. Negation does not grow a double-object and does not create a fourth Case.

Notes

Working paper · September 2026 · English micro-entry · Attitude / ascribe fault · Index 2

Attitude / ascribe-fault sense in English. Working name √ASCRIBE_FAULT. Hierarchy Judge > Target > Charge (1+2). Same family as attributeATT and creditMERIT, opposite polarity of merit. Two Case clothes: Target for Charge · Charge on Target. No DOC, no MeasureP, no HAVE, no SWAP. Twins: Spanish culpar · French blâmer · Italian incolpare · Japanese 責める · Mandarin 怪 / 责备 · Polish obwiniać / winić · Bulgarian обвинявам / виня · Hungarian hibáztat / okol · German beschuldigen / verantwortlich machen · Dutch de schuld geven.

Compare languages EN micro-entry live Index 2 Attitude ES culpar live FR blâmer live IT incolpare live JA 責める live ZH 怪 live PL obwiniać live BG обвинявам live HU hibáztat live DE beschuldigen live NL de schuld geven live NV deferred

Compare languages. Sense × language tick: blame · English. Twins: Spanish (culpar) · French (blâmer) · Italian (incolpare) · Japanese (責める / semeru) · Mandarin (怪 / 责备) · Polish (obwiniać / winić) · Bulgarian (обвинявам / виня) · Hungarian (hibáztat / okol) · German (beschuldigen / verantwortlich machen) · Dutch (de schuld geven). Geometry neighbors: attributeATT · creditMERIT · assignASCRIBE · chargeACCUSE · assign-blame. Index 2 English Attitude cites blame, credit, attribute — Vols. 1, 3.

Working paper. English micro-entry deepened from Lexical_Entry_Blame_Argument_Structure, with NegQ association maps from Negative_Questions_Blame and the light-noun contrast in Assign_Blame_Comparison. Constructed diagnostics diagnose Case clothes, Voice filter, and invert cost; they are not spontaneous-speech citations. Spanish twin live at blame-es.html; French twin live at blame-fr.html; Italian at blame-it.html; Japanese at blame-ja.html; Mandarin at blame-zh.html; Polish at blame-pl.html; Bulgarian at blame-bg.html.
Constructed examples. Frames below are packaging hypotheses aligned with the lexical entry and NegQ Blame paper. Cause-true and settlement are not entailed — same missing defaults as attributeATT and creditMERIT. Do not fake elicitation.
Sense-class. Index 2 lists English Attitude as blame, credit, attribute (Vols. 1, 3). This page deepens blame as √ASCRIBE_FAULT. Single-sense lemma — no sense subscript on the headword. Light-noun on-geometry (put / lay the blame on Target) is the same ascription with FAULT on N; assign blame to Target is assignASCRIBE + light noun (different ACC), pointed at assign / blame.
Scout / deferred. Hungarian is live at blame-hu.html (ACC = Target; -ért Charge; Focus+nem). Navajo classificatory Target packaging remains scout. Polish obwiniać / winić is live at blame-pl.html (ACC = Target; GEN-neg does not rewrite the Target/Charge association). Bulgarian обвинявам / виня is live at blame-bg.html (direct object = Target; Charge за/в/bare че; no GEN-neg). Mandarin 怪 / 责备 is live at blame-zh.html; Japanese 責める / sei at blame-ja.html; French blâmer at blame-fr.html; Spanish at blame-es.html; Italian at blame-it.html. No fake elicitation.

Hierarchy

Same inventory as Spanish culpar. Not five-place. Not four sisters of one V. Surface count can name the committee, Kim, the delay, and the weather — but the lexicon does not list four co-arguments of √ASCRIBE_FAULT.

No MeasureP. There is no verbal Amount+Denomination object. Degrees that sneak in (how much of the blame, partitives on Charge) live on the Abney spine of a light noun or of Charge — Left Branch Condition for sell / pay / chargeFEE does not apply as a verbal diagnostic here.

Weather still satisfies Target and fails Judge. Cause-true is still not entailed. Target and Charge still do not invert at Transfer cost. Treating blame as Agent > Theme > Goal, or as a primitive four-place evaluation verb, predicts a DOC, a HAVE entailment, and a grammatical weather-as-Judge — none of those exist.

WH / NegQ diagnostics · no MeasureP LBC

Unlike sell / payGIVE / chargeFEE / bet, blame has no verbal MeasureP. There is therefore no Left-Branch Condition of the Amount-from-Denomination type on √ASCRIBE_FAULT. Degrees that appear are DP-internal on Charge or on the light noun blame.

  1. ✓ Who blamed Kim for the delay? WH = Judge
  2. ✓ Who did the committee blame for the delay? WH = Target · for-frame
  3. ✓ What did the committee blame Kim for? WH = Charge · for-frame
  4. ✓ What did the committee blame on Kim? WH = Charge · on-frame
  5. ✓ What didn’t they blame for the delay? WH–Neg Target · for-frame
  6. ✓ What didn’t they blame the weather for? WH–Neg Charge · P-strand
  7. ✓ On what / on whom didn’t they blame the delay? Target pied-piped · on-frame
  8. ✓ How much of the blame didn’t they lay on the weather? degree on light noun · Abney-side
  9. * What did the committee blame Kim? missing DOC
  10. * What didn’t blame the weather for the delay? bare what in Voice
  11. * Wasn’t the weather blaming anyone? weather cannot be Judge under WH either

Superiority ranks Judge > ACC object > oblique PP. In the for-frame that is Judge > Target > Charge; in the on-frame ACC outranks the oblique, so Charge outranks Target for Case cheapness — thematic names do not reorder. There is no Superiority fight between Amount and Unit.

for-Charge ≠ other English for / on jobs

for Charge = content of the attitude — not earmark Purpose, not pay Consideration, not sell Price, not swap Theme₂. on Target = ascribee — not bet Platform. Spanish twin spells the for-frame as culpar a … de; French twin as blâmer … pour; Italian twin as incolpare … di; on-geometry surfaces as light-noun (echar la culpa a / jeter la faute sur|à / gettare la colpa a|su), not as a productive Charge-ACC flip of the English on-frame type.

Geometry · blame ≠ attributeATT ≠ creditMERIT ≠ assignASCRIBE ≠ Transfer ≠ chargeACCUSE

In The committee blamed Kim for the delay, the committee holds that Kim is responsible for the delay. That is ascription, not HAVE of goods and not SWAP of Themes. Kim is Target. The delay is Charge. HOLD is an attitude; RESPONSIBLE(Target, Charge) is content, not a presupposed fact.

  • ≠ English DOC / Transfer invert. There is no productive *blame Kim the delay. Negation does not rescue it. Transfer Themes invert under Romance ¿No intercambió…?; blame Target and Charge do not.
  • ≠ attributeATT polarity merge. Shared family (ascribe content to Target) and shared Voice filter; blame writes FAULT polarity. Attribute has a to-cloth and no productive on-flip of the blame type.
  • ≠ creditMERIT. Opposite polarity of merit. creditMERIT has to/with flip options English blame lacks. No ledger MeasureP here.
  • ≠ assignASCRIBE light-noun. Dan assigned blame to the cow for the Chicago fire puts FAULT on a light noun in ACC and parks Target in to. ACC cheapness tracks the noun, not the cow. Same three participants; different Case object. Pointer: assign / blame.
  • ≠ chargeACCUSE legal overlay. Fault content can overlap in discourse; legal / speech-act overlays of accuse are not filed on this page.
  • Missing defaults. Cause-true and settlement are not entailed. Didn’t they blame the weather for the delay? is compatible with the weather not in fact causing the delay.

Shells, ApplP, and Case

Base tree (ascribe-fault · English clothes)

for-frame:
VoiceP  [ JudgeNOM
  vP / √ASCRIBE_FAULT
    ACC               Target
    PP_for            Charge ]

on-frame:
VoiceP  [ JudgeNOM
  vP / √ASCRIBE_FAULT
    ACC               Charge
    PP_on             Target ]

Light-noun on-geometry:
VoiceP  [ Judge
  vP / √PUT·LAY
    ACC               the blameN   (Charge-type / FAULT)
    PP_on             Target ]

English blame never assigns four structural Cases. No low ApplHAVE. No low ApplSWAP. No ApplTASK. No MeasureP. High Appl / Affectee is extra when present (They blamed the delay on Kim for me) and is not a listed argument of √ASCRIBE_FAULT.

Composition is V(DP) on the ACC object. The P on the other inner participant is clothing the DP wears (K on the Abney spine, or a selected relational P that does not add a fourth verbal argument). V(for(DP)) and V(on(DP)) are the wrong composition — same wrapper-K cut as attribute’s to.

Outer CAUSEG (they made the committee blame the weather) wraps Voice. The causee, not the weather, is the Judge. *They made the weather blame the committee keeps the inner filter.

Omission does not demote Charge to a pure adjunct. Selected P-layers are optional in the numeration; they are still arguments when present. The diagnostic is participanthood under Case, binding, and WH — not omitability. Charge clauses are islands in a way rationale adjuncts are not; there is no Neg-raising.

Underivables (English)

  1. * The weather blamed Kim for the delay. weather / inanimate as Judge
  2. * Wasn’t the weather blaming anyone for the delay? Voice filter survives Neg
  3. * They made the weather blame the committee. CAUSEG wrap does not wash Voice filter
  4. * They blamed Kim the delay. no productive DOC
  5. * What did the committee blame Kim? missing DOC under WH
  6. * How much didn’t they blame of delay on Kim? no verbal MeasureP LBC host
  7. * They blamed Kim for new technology. for Purpose coercion ≠ Charge (odd unless coerced)
  8. * They swapped the weather for the delay. SWAP cloth ≠ ascribe-fault
  9. * What platform didn’t they blame the delay? on ≠ bet Platform

Groups A–D packaging · this tick English only

English micro-entry (deepened stub). Spanish and French Group B twins are live. Brief pointers only:

  • Group A. Japanese semeru / sekinin-o owaseru now live at blame-ja.html; ni Target under light-noun, de / no sei-de Charge; Double-o unused. Mandarin 怪 / 责备 Target 因为 Charge, or 把 delay 怪在 Target 身上 — live at blame-zh.html. Navajo: scout — classificatory stem for weather as Target, not as Judge.
  • Group B. Spanish live at blame-es.html; French live at blame-fr.html; Italian live at blame-it.html.
  • Group C. Polish live at blame-pl.html (ACC Target; za/o Charge; GEN-neg does not rewrite the Target/Charge association). Bulgarian live at blame-bg.html (direct-object Target; за/в/bare че; clitic го; no GEN-neg). Hungarian is live at blame-hu.html (ACC Target; -ért; Focus+nem; no GEN-neg).
  • Group D. German is live at blame-de.html (beschuldigen / verantwortlich machen; ACC Target; Charge genitive / wegen / dass; wofür resumes Charge, not Platform; zuschreiben stays ATT/MERIT). Dutch is live at blame-nl.html (de schuld geven; accusative = the noun; IO/aan Target; van Charge; toeschrijven stays ATT/MERIT). Norwegian is live at blame-no.html (legge skylden på; accusative = the noun; på Target; tilskrive stays ATT/MERIT). Group D blame closes on NO.

Open items

  • Italian twin. Live at blame-it.html (di-Charge; light-noun colpa; ne quantity).
  • Nominal blame on the Abney spine. whose blame was it? — Target vs Judge ambiguity the verbal Voice filter does not have. Flagged, not solved.
  • Communicative lean. they blamed the remark on her ≈ authorship of speech — how far VoiceJ stays.
  • Group C packaging. Polish is live at blame-pl.html. Bulgarian is live at blame-bg.html. Hungarian is live at blame-hu.html. Mandarin Group A live at blame-zh.html; Japanese at blame-ja.html. No fake elicitation.
  • thank / praise under Neg. Positive-polarity attitude neighbors. Not filed this tick. No paradigm invented here.
  • Type A make + blame. Outer CAUSE wraps a Judge event (they made the committee blame the weather). Outer Neg can be cheap on the causing; the inner Voice filter survives. Not a new elicitation.

Corpus filenames

Primary extract for this micro-entry is Lexical_Entry_Blame_Argument_Structure (English snapshot). NegQ association maps from Negative_Questions_Blame. Light-noun contrast from Assign_Blame_Comparison. Chat packaging: Tritransitive chats 13 (assign vs blame Case / NegQ) and 22 (blame in negative questions · no fourth theta). Box extract: /workspace/blame-en-notes.txt.

Series placement: English sense×language twin of Spanish culpar, French blâmer, and Italian incolpare. Feeds Attitude / Evaluation Index 2 and the ascribe-fault cell next to attributeATT / creditMERIT. Polish is live at blame-pl.html. Bulgarian is live at blame-bg.html. Hungarian is live at blame-hu.html. German is live at blame-de.html. Dutch is live at blame-nl.html. Speculation flagged.

Index 2 citations for this class

Attitude / Evaluation citations from Index 2
CodeLanguageIndex 2 citationAs printed
ENEnglishblame EN micro-entry, credit, attributeVols. 1, 3
ESSpanishculpar ES micro-entry, atribuirVols. 3, 5
FRFrenchblâmer FR micro-entry, attribuerVols. 3, 5
ITItalianincolpare IT micro-entry, attribuireVols. 3, 5
HUHungarianhibáztat / okol HU micro-entry, attributeATT · tulajdonít, creditMERIT · elismerVols. 3, 6
BGBulgarianобвинявам / виня BG micro-entry, attributeATT · приписвамVols. 3, 6
PLPolishobwiniać / winić PL micro-entry, attributeATT · przypisywaćVols. 3, 6
DEGermanbeschuldigen, verantwortlich machen, zuschreiben · blame · beschuldigen / verantwortlich machen DE micro-entryVol. 7
NLDutchde schuld geven, toeschrijven · blame · de schuld geven NL micro-entryVol. 7
NONorwegianlegge skylden på · blame · legge skylden på NO micro-entryVol. 7

Languages Index 2 does not list for this class are left off the table.