Arguments

Charger, Amount, Payer, Service · four places · Portuguese cloth · working claim, revisable

Voice[Charger] + ApplFROM(Payer, MeasurePAmount ⟨n, U⟩) + por-Service

Payer = a + NP or de + NP · the two prepositions are both printed and unranked · dative lhe of this person is unprinted · Amount = direct object · Service = por + NP, and the filled examples contract por + o as pelo

A fee, on this reading, has a Charger, an Amount, a Payer, and a Service, the thing the amount is asked for. They are not four equal sisters of cobrar, and the Service is not a fourth structural Case. Voice adds the Charger. The root’s measuring object is the Amount, a direct object. Portuguese nouns have no case ending, so that object is not a morphological accusative. The Payer is the person the amount is demanded from. Aulete’s fee sense prints that person with a or with de, in one label, and the example fills both: Cobra aos/dos fiéis o dízimo. The slash is the entry’s. Michaelis fills de in cobrou da patroa as horas extras. The Service is por. Aulete fills it as pelo aluguel do apartamento and pelo serviço. pelo is por fused with the masculine article o. It is the same preposition. No dictionary opened here prints the Charger, the Payer, the Amount, and por in one clause. The drawing assembles those pieces. It is revisable.

What is different from English charge. Cambridge’s money sense prints charge something for something in How much do you charge for a haircut and blow-dry?, charge someone for something in Can I charge the company for petrol I use getting to work?, and [ + two objects ] in They charge you $20 just to get in the nightclub. The business entry prints charge (sb) sth for sth in How much will you charge us for shipping and handling? and They charged $200 for insurance. The Payer you, the company, and us is a bare object. Portuguese fee lines do not print that bare person beside the amount. They print the person with a or with de. A dative lhe of the Payer is unprinted on the articles opened here. The one lhe on the Michaelis article sits inside que a empresa ainda lhe devia, the indirect object of dever, not of cobrar. English for of the haircut, the petrol, the shipping, and the insurance matches por / pelo. The cut is the Payer: English leaves that person bare, and can put the bare person and the amount in one clause; Portuguese marks the person with a or de, and the sources print that person and por in different clauses.

Places · who wears which marking

The printed fee clauses each leave at least one place empty. Aulete’s rent line and service line have the amount and pelo, and no person. The tithe line has the person in a or de and the amount, and no por. Michaelis’s overtime line has de and the thing demanded, and no por. The strings that put a named Payer, an amount, and pelo serviço in one clause are constructed on those pieces.

Printed Amount · direct object · Service pelo · Payer absent

✓ Resolveu cobrar R$600,00 pelo aluguel do apartamento. Aulete · sense 2 · label td. · pedir (determinada quantia) por produto ou serviço

✓ Cobrou R$50,00 pelo serviço. Aulete · sense 2 · label tdr. + por

He decided to charge R$600.00 for the rent of the apartment · he charged R$50.00 for the service · the sum is the direct object · pelo is por + o

Printed Payer · a or de · Amount direct object · no por

✓ Cobra aos/dos fiéis o dízimo. Aulete · sense 2 · label tdi. + a, de · the slash is the entry’s

✓ O banco cobrou dos aposentados uma taxa exorbitante. · A cantina da escola teve de cobrar aos alunos todas as despesas que ainda não foram pagas. Vieira & Faraco, Gramática do Português Brasileiro Escrito, as quoted by Sérgio Rodrigues, Folha de S.Paulo, 17 April 2024 · the grammar was not opened

✓ a empregada cobrou da patroa as horas extras Michaelis · Fazer ser pago · the article’s full clause names the ten years of overtime

He charges the faithful the tithe · the bank charged the retirees an exorbitant fee · the canteen had to charge the students the unpaid expenses · the employee charged the employer for the overtime hours · the person is a or de · the sum or the thing demanded is the direct object

Printed amount with no person and no por · and por in a definition with no clause

✓ os municípios passavam a cobrar impostos Michaelis · Proceder à cobrança do que é devido

✓ cobrar uma dívida Priberam · sense 1 · pedir ou exigir um pagamento do que é devido · Aulete sense 1 · label td.

✓ O técnico de computador queria cobrar uma fortuna Michaelis · Exigir o valor de · the service is a separate clause, o serviço não havia ficado muito bom, not por

✓ pedir determinado valor por produto, serviço, etc. Infopédia · sense 2 · the por is the definition · no clause · no person

The municipalities were to collect taxes · to charge a debt · he wanted to charge a fortune · to ask a given amount for a product or a service · the debt and the tax sit in the direct object with no por in the clause

Places of Portuguese cobrar: introducer, marking, status, English marking
PlaceIntroduced by (working)Portuguese markingStatus in the sourcesEnglish marking
ChargerSpec,VoicesubjectResolveu · Cobra · Cobrou · os municípios · a empregada · O banco · A cantina · omitted in the infinitive frame cobrar uma dívidasubject of charge
AmountMeasureP, complement of the rootdirect objectAulete R$600,00 · R$50,00 · o dízimo · Vieira & Faraco via Folha uma taxa exorbitante · todas as despesas · Michaelis impostos · uma fortuna · o pagamento · Priberam and Aulete uma dívidaobject of the money · $20 · $200 · how much · a commission
PayerApplFROM · the person the amount is demanded froma + NP or de + NPAulete aos/dos fiéis, one label, both prepositions, no regional tag · Folha quoting Vieira & Faraco dos aposentados and aos alunos · Michaelis da patroa · lhe of this person unprinted · a bare full noun beside the amount unprinted on these fee linesbare object · you · the company · us · people
Serviceselected por on the same event · not a fourth Casepor + NP · filled as peloAulete pelo aluguel do apartamento · pelo serviço · Infopédia sense 2 por produto, serviço in the definition, no clause · pela unprinted on the cobrar articles opened here · no opened source stacks the Payer and pelo in one fee clausefor + NP · for a haircut and blow-dry · for petrol · for shipping and handling · for insurance · for admission

Marking map. Read the direct object as the amount. Then read a or de as the person, and por / pelo as the service.

EN ⇄ PT valency strip

Each row lines up one English slot with a Portuguese slot. The alignment type says what happens to the slot: = (same object status), or shift (a bare object ↔ a or de). Printed lines come first. Every other Portuguese sentence is constructed, modelled on a printed line. They show the working alignment. They are not frequency, and not a bilingual corpus.

English–Portuguese valency alignment for charge / cobrar, one row per argument
SlotEN formPT formAlignEN examplePT example
ChargerSUBJsubject=They charge you $20 Cambridge · [ + two objects ]Resolveu · O banco cobrou Aulete · Folha quoting Vieira & Faraco
Amountobjectdirect object=$20 · $200 · how much CambridgeR$600,00 · R$50,00 · o dízimo · uma taxa exorbitante Aulete · Folha quoting Vieira & Faraco
Payerbare objecta + NP or de + NPshift · English you has no preposition · the two Portuguese prepositions are unrankedcharge you $20 · charge the company · charge us Cambridge · [ + two objects ] · charge someone for something · business charge (sb) sth for sthaos/dos fiéis · dos aposentados · aos alunos · da patroa Aulete · Folha quoting Vieira & Faraco · Michaelis
Servicefor + NPpor + NP · pelo= of the oblique role · pelo is por + ofor a haircut · for insurance · for shipping Cambridgepelo aluguel do apartamento · pelo serviço Aulete
Bare person + amounttwo objectsunprinted on the fee linesthe English frame has no Portuguese twin in the fee sources opened hereThey charge you $20 CambridgeCobra aos/dos fiéis o dízimo keeps a or de Aulete
lhe of the Payerobject pronoun youunprintedthe Michaelis lhe is the object of devercharge you Cambridgeque a empresa ainda lhe devia Michaelis · lhe of dever

The strip below is a set of small multiples. Each card holds one frame, with English on top and Portuguese under it. The subject chip is the party the clause actually makes the subject.

EN · PT · amount and service

R$50,00 pelo serviço

How much do you charge for a haircut and blow-dry? They charged $200 for insurance.

Cobrou R$50,00 pelo serviço. Resolveu cobrar R$600,00 pelo aluguel do apartamento.

PT · Aulete · EN · Cambridge · for · no person in the Portuguese clauses

RolesHide roles ChargerAmountService
Charger you · They · the subject of Cobrou and of Resolveu Amount how much · $200 · R$50,00 · R$600,00 Service for a haircut · for insurance · pelo serviço · pelo aluguel

Agree The amount is the object. pelo is the service, as English for is. pelo is por plus the article.

EN · PT · the person and the amount

aos/dos fiéis · o dízimo

They charge you $20 just to get in the nightclub. How much will you charge us for shipping and handling?

Cobra aos/dos fiéis o dízimo. O banco cobrou dos aposentados uma taxa exorbitante. A cantina da escola teve de cobrar aos alunos todas as despesas que ainda não foram pagas.

PT · Aulete · Folha quoting Vieira & Faraco · EN · Cambridge · the English lines put the person bare · the Portuguese lines have no por

RolesHide roles ChargerPayerAmount
Charger They · you · the subject of Cobra · O banco · A cantina Payer you · us · aos/dos fiéis · dos aposentados · aos alunos Amount $20 · o dízimo · uma taxa exorbitante · as despesas

Move English leaves the Payer bare beside the amount. Portuguese prints that person with a or with de. Aulete’s slash does not rank them.

EN · PT · de and the thing demanded

da patroa · as horas extras

Can I charge the company for petrol I use getting to work?

a empregada cobrou da patroa as horas extras que teve de trabalhar durante 10 anos.

PT · Michaelis · EN · Cambridge · charge someone for something · the Portuguese line has no por

RolesHide roles ChargerPayerThing demanded
Charger I · a empregada Payer the company · da patroa Thing petrol, under for · as horas extras, the direct object

Move English puts the company bare and the petrol under for. Michaelis puts the employer under de and the overtime in the direct object.

EN · PT · the pieces in one clause

constructed · do Chris · pelo serviço

How much will you charge us for shipping and handling?

A loja cobrou R$50,00 do Chris pelo serviço. A loja cobrou R$50,00 ao Chris pelo serviço.

constructed · amount and pelo serviço on Aulete · de on Michaelis da patroa and on Aulete dos fiéis · a on Aulete aos fiéis · no opened source prints the three together

RolesHide roles ChargerPayerAmountService
Charger you · A loja Payer us · do Chris · ao Chris Amount how much · R$50,00 Service for shipping · pelo serviço

Move The card stacks printed pieces. English can put the bare person, the amount, and for in one frame label. Portuguese prints the person and pelo in different clauses.

Examples

Argument difference. English charge someone X for Y leaves the Payer bare and can put that person beside the amount. Portuguese prints the Payer with a or with de, prints the amount as the direct object, and prints the service as por / pelo. The person and pelo are in different clauses in the sources. lhe of the Payer is unprinted. A bare person is the press reading in the Folha headlines, where por names what is pressed for and there is no amount object.

Dictionary frames and lines · checked · quoted as printed

cobrar uma dívida · cobrar um favor · cobrar um penálti Priberam · transitive · regular conjugation · sense 1 is the debt · sense 2 is demanding a favour · sense 7 is the kick · no a, de, or por in the examples

pedir determinado valor por produto, serviço, etc. Infopédia · Porto Editora · sense 2 · por in the definition · no clause

[td. : cobrar uma dívida.] · [td. : Resolveu cobrar R$600,00 pelo aluguel do apartamento.] · [tdi. + a, de : Cobra aos/dos fiéis o dízimo.] · [tdr. + por : Cobrou R$50,00 pelo serviço.] · [int. : Esse marceneiro cobra muito caro.] Aulete · sense 1 and sense 2 · the brackets and the slash are the entry’s

[td./tdi. + a, : Cobrava (a todos os amigos) presença na festa.] · [td./tdr. + de : Cobrou (do pai) o CD prometido.] Aulete · sense 3 · the press or demand reading · the parentheses are the entry’s · the person is not bare

os municípios passavam a cobrar impostos · cobrar o aluguel dos outros inquilinos · O funcionário cobrou o pagamento que a empresa ainda lhe devia. · a empregada cobrou da patroa as horas extras · queria cobrar uma fortuna · cobrou atitude · Se você cobrar a vitória dele Michaelis · lhe belongs to dever · da patroa is de of the person · the fortune line leaves the service in another clause

O banco cobrou dos aposentados uma taxa exorbitante. · A cantina da escola teve de cobrar aos alunos todas as despesas que ainda não foram pagas. Vieira & Faraco via Folha, 17 April 2024 · the book was not opened · Rodrigues glosses the frame as cobrar algo de (ou a) alguém

Ele cobrou freio ao magistrado English Wiktionary · quotation dated 7 September 2024 · demand sense · freio direct · person a

Haddad cobra Congresso por compensação na desoneração da folha · cobra deputados por alinhamento ao PT · Fiesp cobra deputados · Lula cobra ministros a viajarem mais Folha, 17 April 2024 · headlines · bare person · Rodrigues: the older frame is de (ou a), and the newer use adds reprimand and pressure · press reading

How much do you charge for a haircut and blow-dry? · Can I charge the company for petrol? · They charge you $20 just to get in the nightclub. · How much will you charge us for shipping and handling? · They charged $200 for insurance. Cambridge · charge · money sense and the business entry

Strings below are constructed, modelled on the printed lines. They are not spontaneous-speech citations and not dictionary lines. Pat and Chris continue the named-participant series on English chargeFEE. A name does not spell a role.

Constructed · the pieces are printed separately

✓ A Pat cobrou R$50,00 do Chris pelo serviço. constructed · amount and pelo serviço on Aulete · de on da patroa and on dos fiéis · the three are unprinted together

✓ A Pat cobrou R$50,00 ao Chris pelo serviço. constructed · the same amount and pelo · a on aos fiéis and on aos alunos · unprinted as one clause

✓ A Pat cobrou R$50,00 pelo serviço. constructed on Aulete’s printed Cobrou R$50,00 pelo serviço · the charger is named · no Payer

* A Pat cobrou o Chris R$50,00 pelo serviço. constructed · bare person beside the amount · unprinted on the fee lines · not a grammatical claim

* A Pat cobrou-lhe R$50,00. constructed · lhe of the Payer · unprinted · the printed lhe on the Michaelis article belongs to dever

Derivations · working sketches, revisable

Each sketch is a working drawing, not a locked analysis. The drawing gives the Charger to Voice, the Payer to low ApplFROM, the Amount to the root, and the Service to por. a and de are both drawn in that Payer place. The sources do not rank them. Open one sketch at a time. Which theta role is the object is the revisable note Causative templates and argument selection. This page does not edit that note.

Voice · the Charger is the external argument

The finite verb · one external argument

[TP Resolveu
  [VoiceP  —  Voice                     ← Charger = Spec,Voice
    … cobrar … ]]

✓ Resolveu cobrar R$600,00 pelo aluguel do apartamento. Aulete

The external argument is the Charger. On pagar this layer is the Payer, the person who hands the money over. Here the subject is the one who asks for the amount. No passive of the fee string is printed on the pages opened here. The pronominal cobrou-se is paying oneself or recovering oneself, not that passive.

Payer a / de · Amount · Service por

One direct object · the Payer wears a or de · por is selected · the two prepositions are unranked · working, revisable

[VoiceP Cobra Voice
  [ApplP aos fiéis Appl                  ← Aulete · a
    [VP √cobr-
       [Amount o dízimo ]]]]             ← no por in this clause

[VoiceP Cobra Voice
  [ApplP dos fiéis Appl                  ← Aulete · de
    [VP √cobr-                           ← the slash does not rank a and de
       [Amount o dízimo ]]]]

[VoiceP cobrou Voice
  [ApplP da patroa Appl                  ← Michaelis · de
    [VP √cobr-
       [Amount as horas extras ]]]]      ← no por

[VoiceP Cobrou Voice
  [VP √cobr-
     [Amount R$50,00 ]
     [PP por [ o serviço ]]]]            ← Aulete · pelo = por + o
                                          ← Payer unrealized
                                          ← not a fourth Case

The Amount and the Service are different phrases. When the direct object is o dízimo, uma taxa, or as horas extras, the person is a or de and por is unrealized. When the service is under por, the printed clauses leave the person out. A bare second noun beside the Amount, the shape of English charge you $20, is unprinted on these lines.

✓ Cobra aos/dos fiéis o dízimo. Aulete

✓ Cobrou R$50,00 pelo serviço. Aulete

* A Pat cobrou o Chris R$50,00. constructed · bare person beside a sum · unprinted · the printed full Payer is a or de

The press frame · bare person · not this fee

Separated · Folha headlines · the guides, as Rodrigues reports them, do not print this frame

[VoiceP cobra Voice
  [VP √cobr-
     [Person Congresso ]                 ← Folha headline · bare
     [PP por [ compensação ]]]]          ← no amount object

[VoiceP Cobrava Voice
  [ApplP a todos os amigos Appl          ← Aulete sense 3 · a
    [VP √cobr-
       [Thing presença ]]]]              ← the person is not bare

The headline puts the person in the direct object and the reason under por. Aulete’s demand of a presence keeps the person under a and the thing in the direct object. Neither clause is R$50,00 pelo serviço. The fee drawing above is not this frame.

✓ Haddad cobra Congresso por compensação na desoneração da folha Folha, 17 April 2024 · headline

✓ Cobrava (a todos os amigos) presença na festa. Aulete · sense 3

English counterpart · bare Payer, for

Working · Cambridge charge

[VoiceP They Voice
  [ApplP you Appl                        ← Cambridge [+ two objects]
    [VP √CHARGE                          ← bare object · no preposition
       [Amount $20 ]]]]                  ← Portuguese a / de

[VoiceP They Voice
  [VP √CHARGE
     [Amount $200 ]
     [PP for [ insurance ]]]]            ← Cambridge
                                          ← Portuguese pelo serviço

[VoiceP you Voice
  [ApplP us Appl                         ← business charge (sb) sth for sth
    [VP √CHARGE
       [Amount how much ]
       [PP for [ shipping ]]]]]          ← one English frame label
                                          ← Portuguese prints the person
                                            and por in different clauses

Cambridge’s bare you and us are the Payer. Portuguese prints the full phrase as a or as de. Cambridge’s for is the service. Portuguese por / pelo is that oblique. The English frame can hold the bare person, the amount, and for together. The Portuguese sources do not print that stack.

Notes

Working paper · October 2026 · Portuguese micro-entry · Beyond Index 2

cobrar on the fee reading has a Charger, an Amount, a Payer, and a Service. The Charger is the subject. The Amount is the direct object. The Payer is a or de, unranked. The Service is por, filled as pelo. English charge you $20 leaves the Payer bare. A dative lhe of that person is unprinted. The debt as a direct object, and cobrar alguém as pressing someone, stay off the fee stack, cited where a source prints them.

PT micro-entry live Beyond Index 2 a and de unranked ES cobrar live FR facturer live

Sense × language: chargeFEE · Portuguese (cobrar). The fee is the page. Collection of a debt, the press reading, recovery, and the sports kick stay off the four-place stack, cited where a source prints them. Geometry neighbors: Spanish cobrar, Italian addebitare, Portuguese pagar. Index 2 does not list cobrar.

Open items

  • The four places in one clause. Aulete prints the amount and pelo without a person, and prints the person and the amount without por. Michaelis prints da patroa and the overtime without por. The constructed R$50,00 do Chris pelo serviço stacks printed pieces. No source opened here prints that stack.
  • a against de. Aulete prints both in one label and does not rank them. The Folha quotation of Vieira & Faraco prints one clause with de and one with a. Michaelis fills de on the overtime line and does not fill a of a person there. No ranking is added here.
  • European and Brazilian argument structure. No source opened here states a difference, by variety, in the Payer of a fee. Aulete, a Brazilian dictionary, prints a and de with no regional tag. Priberam and Infopédia, the European articles, print no person. Silence in those articles is not a variety rule. English Wiktionary’s cobramos / cobrámos note is the spelling of the 1pl perfect, not a frame split. The roubar note on steal · Portuguese is not transferred.
  • lhe. Unprinted for the Payer. The constructed cobrou-lhe is not a grammatical claim. The printed lhe on the Michaelis article is the object of dever.
  • pela. Unprinted. The filled service nouns are masculine, so the contraction is pelo. A feminine service under por is not constructed.
  • The passive of the amount. Unprinted. cobrar-se is the pronominal of paying oneself or recovering. No passive is constructed.
  • Unopened books. Houaiss, Aurélio, the Academia das Ciências dictionary, Luft’s Dicionário Prático de Regência Verbal, Vieira & Faraco itself, and 501 Portuguese Verbs. No Ciberdúvidas answer on cobrar was located. No sentence is quoted from a source that was not opened, except where an opened page already quotes it and the quotation is tagged as such.

Corpus filenames and sources checked

Dictionary frames: Priberam, Infopédia (Porto Editora), Michaelis, Aulete Digital, Wikcionário, and the English Wiktionary for cobrar. Regency as quoted: Sérgio Rodrigues, Folha de S.Paulo, 17 April 2024, citing Vieira & Faraco (the grammar was not opened). English: Cambridge charge. Sibling frames: charge-fee, charge-fee-es, charge-fee-fr, charge-fee-it, and pay-give-pt. Constructed clauses reuse a printed a, de, or pelo with named participants. Index 2 does not list cobrar.

Records cobrar as a fee with the amount in the direct object, the Payer under a or de, and the service under por / pelo. The bare Payer is the English frame, and, on a separated reading, the press headlines.