Further pages, each with its own arguments: German · beschuldigen / verantwortlich machen · Dutch · de schuld geven · Norwegian · legge skylden på · Hungarian · hibáztat / okol · Polish · obwiniać / winić · Bulgarian · обвинявам / виня.
Examples from the micro-entries.
Each card quotes one diagnostic already printed on that language’s page. All six flag those frames as constructed. Nothing here is a new elicitation.
Six languages
Six argument lists. Chips name the roles on that card. Color is the derivation-sheet wash. Judge blue, Target green, Charge gold. These six cards quote a Target-object and a Charge phrase. English also has an on-frame, on the English page.
EN
blame
The committee blamed Kim for the delay.
constructed · for-frame · ACC Target · for-Charge
RolesHide roles
JudgeTargetCharge
Judge The committee
Target Kim
Charge for the delay
Agree ACC on Target in the for-frame; Charge stays inside for
Full micro-entry
JA
責める semeru
委員会は悪天候を遅延のせいで責めた。
constructed · one written string · Charge in no sei-de
RolesHide roles
JudgeTargetCharge
Judge 委員会は
Target 悪天候を
Charge 遅延のせいで
Agree Charge on this string is no sei-de. を under 責める hosts the fault or the person.
Full micro-entry
ZH
怪 / 责备
委员会怪天气,因为延误。
constructed · post-V Target · 因为 Charge
RolesHide roles
JudgeTargetCharge
Judge 委员会
Target 天气
Charge 因为延误
Move 把 may front this Target, or the Charge-host under 怪在…身上; this string leaves Target postverbal
Full micro-entry
ES
culpar
El comité culpó al clima del retraso.
constructed · a-Target · de-Charge
RolesHide roles
JudgeTargetCharge
Judge El comité
Target al clima
Charge del retraso
Agree a-Target · de-Charge
Full micro-entry
FR
blâmer
Le comité a blâmé le mauvais temps pour le retard.
constructed · ACC Target · pour-Charge
RolesHide roles
JudgeTargetCharge
Judge Le comité
Target le mauvais temps
Charge pour le retard
Agree ACC Target · pour-Charge
Full micro-entry
IT
incolpare
Il comitato ha incolpato il maltempo del ritardo.
constructed · ACC Target · di-Charge
RolesHide roles
JudgeTargetCharge
Judge Il comitato
Target il maltempo
Charge del ritardo
Agree ACC Target · di-Charge
Full micro-entry
Where they diverge
Only cloth already stated on the six micro-entries. The cards quote one Target-object + Charge-PP string each. The English on-frame, light-noun on-geometry, and the NegQ maps stay on the micro-entries. Navajo stays deferred.
Proto-role · Judge vs Target
- All Judge is the proto-Agent of the attitude. Voice introduces Judge. Target is the ascribee. Charge is the content. Weather still satisfies Target and fails Judge. *The weather blamed Kim for the delay. Cause-true is not entailed.
- All Not Recipient HAVE. Not a SWAP of Target and Charge. No productive DOC (*They blamed Kim the delay). No verbal MeasureP.
Case cloth
- EN for-frame: ACC Target + for-Charge (The committee blamed Kim for the delay). on-frame: ACC Charge + on-Target (The committee blamed the delay on Kim). Cheap NegQ tracks the ACC of the chosen cloth.
- JA Under 責める, を hosts the fault (失敗を責める, 無責任な行為を責める) or the person (君を責める). Those dictionary frames are not new sentences here. Charge on the card is no sei-de (遅延のせいで). ni marks the person under the light noun (悪天候に責任を負わせた). There is no second o.
- ZH Post-V Target; Charge inside 因为 / 为 / 因 (委员会怪天气,因为延误). Alternate 把…怪在…身上 (把延误怪在天气身上) puts the Charge-host in 把 and Target in 在…身上. 把 fronts the object of the chosen cloth, not a fourth role.
- ES a-Target + de-Charge (El comité culpó al clima del retraso). On-geometry is light-noun echar / atribuir la culpa a, not a Charge-ACC flip.
- FR ACC Target + pour-Charge (Le comité a blâmé le mauvais temps pour le retard). Not Spanish de. On-geometry is attribuer / jeter la faute à|sur.
- IT ACC Target + di-Charge (Il comitato ha incolpato il maltempo del ritardo). Not French pour. On-geometry is attribuire / dare / gettare la colpa a|su.
- All Not four objects. Charge is not a DOC applied object and not a second o beside Target.
blame ≠ attributeATT ≠ creditMERIT ≠ chargeACCUSE ≠ payGIVE ≠ sell
Shared family with attributeATT: ascribe content to a Target, same Voice filter. Blame writes FAULT. Attribute has a to-cloth and no productive on-flip of the blame type. creditMERIT is the opposite polarity of merit, with to/with flip options English blame lacks, and no ledger MeasureP here. chargeACCUSE can overlap in discourse; the legal / speech-act overlay is not filed on this root. On payGIVE · compare, Recipient HAS the Amount and the leftover PP is Consideration. On sell · compare, Recipient HAS the goods and the for-type phrase is Price. Here that phrase is Charge.
English, Spanish, French, and Italian are Index 2 Attitude. Japanese and Mandarin sit Beyond Index 2. Hub: blame.